4 ms·
Be sure to explain to your parents that this particular news outlet (Bloomberg) has a history of playing fast and loose with reality, particularly in regard to
by CamperBob2 6y ago
Be sure to explain to your parents that this particular news outlet (Bloomberg) has a history of playing fast and loose with reality, particularly in regard to supposed Chinese industrial espionage activities. [1]
Also you might point out that the company pays bonuses to its "journalists" for successfully affecting financial markets. [2]
1: https://appleinsider.com/articles/19/10/04/editorial-a-year-later-bloomberg-silently-stands-by-its-big-hack-icloud-spy-chip-story https://appleinsider.com/articles/19/10/04/editorial-a-year-...
2: https://www.businessinsider.com/bloomberg-reporters-compensation-2013-12 https://www.businessinsider.com/bloomberg-reporters-compensa...
- smabie 6y agoAre you suggesting that Nortel wasn't hacked by the Chinese?
- geofft 6y agoThe article itself suggests that it's a possibility. There's no evidence connecting the hack to Nortel's flagging fortunes, and there's no evidence connecting Huawei's success to the information in the hack. The article makes a much stronger argument that effective Chinese government support of Huawei and the failure of the Canadian government to support Nortel, as well as Huawei's ability to hire away many of Nortel's top researchers, led to their success. (The journalist's own summary of her article: "It turns out Canada really blew it." https://twitter.com/natalieobiko/status/1278366529591980032 https://twitter.com/natalieobiko/status/1278366529591980032)
- Barrin92 6y agogetting downvoted for pointing out facts and reiterating the authors own words. The anti-Chinese hysteria on this website really is a sight to behold at this point. Is "China bad" how HN and the US is going to look for the next 20 years as North America goes down the hill? For an actual science based look at Nortel there was a good study done by a team at the Tefler School of Business years ago.[1] Taking an extensive look at the corporate culture and the state of the business which was despite dotcom evaluations in a pretty sorry state already. Tracing the decay back to the 80s and 90s and a whole row of disastrous decisions. [1](https://obj.ca/article/nortels-failure-was-years-making-telfer-study-finds-0 https://obj.ca/article/nortels-failure-was-years-making-telf...)
- smnrchrds 6y agoAs someone who is neither Chinese nor American and has no horse in this race, I find it amusing how strong the bias against China is on this site. TikTok accesses clipboard, it must be an intelligence operation; LinkedIn and AirBnB do the same, I guess the devs were lazy and didn't do enough testing. Someone find a security hole in a Huawei device, that must be a communist backdoor; a Cisco device has the same security issue, they are just moving fast and breaking things. You know the old saying that we judge ourselves by our intentions and others by their actions. If you cut someone off while driving, it's just a simple error and no biggie, you just misjudged the road situation momentarily; but if someone cuts you off, they are a idiot who should not be on the road and deserves to get their license taken away and their car impounded. The reaction to anything China on HN is like the above, applied at a national scale.
- TedDoesntTalk 6y ago> we judge ourselves by our intentions People also judge others by past behaviors. Wrong or right, many Americans see China as an enemy. News is filtered through that light. And some news, like convictions about IP theft by Chinese (Xu at IBM, 3 individuals at Sinovel, etc, etc, etc), leave little room for debate. These stories color the ones which may or may not be nefarious like TikTok. Guilt by association.
- desi_ninja 6y agoalso Huawei's Cisco theft is a well known case. so there is precedence already
- close04 6y ago> People also judge others by past behaviors. But they are very selective in doing that. Even when the same actions are done in the same context they will use different measures for different people based on their sentiment toward them. And that just adds to the bias and fuels the cycle. As explained by this simple but accurate picture [0]. They see China and and their hackers as enemies. Do you think they see the NSA and by extension their own country as an enemy? Discarding (unwittingly) half of the context makes it a lot easier to assume they have the moral high ground. Propaganda doesn't mean it's a lie, just that you take the same truth and shape it into an opinion for the people, depending on what you want to achieve. And it's a tool used by every superpower. [0] https://i.redd.it/nn3k727v08g01.jpg https://i.redd.it/nn3k727v08g01.jpg
- CamperBob2 6y agoI'm suggesting that I don't know if Nortel was hacked by the Chinese, and that I don't know if any such hack was responsible for the company's eventual downfall, and that reading a Bloomberg article will be of little or no help with either condition.
- geofft 6y agoYeah - I was shocked to see that "The Big Hack" was their suggested "read next" article. You'd think they wouldn't want to remind people about it.
- euix 6y agoIt's funny because all in all Bloomberg has a vested interest in staying on the good side of the Chinese government given their terminal business. You can see it in their editorial line which is rather neutral on most China issues compared to other publications like WSJ.
- fakeslimshady 6y agoBloomberg's last China hack article was completely discredited, and still no retraction/explaination. They have the appearances of Trump's propaganda machine. Considering the timing of this relative to the election and GOP's sole strategy of China scapegoating we can all take this latest as more of the same
- famouslastwords 6y agoIn case you're not a troll and your vision was just clouded by mindless Trump and GOP hate: Have you ever heard the name Michael 'Mike' Bloomberg[1] before? He was a registered Democrat candidate running against(!) Trump in the presidential race. The same Mike Bloomberg is also the founder and owner (well, majority shareholder) of Bloomberg L.P.[2]. Why would a Democrat presidential candidate use his company's influence support the strategy of his outspoken opponent? [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_Bloomberg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_Bloomberg [2]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bloomberg_L.P https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bloomberg_L.P.
- geofft 6y agoIt's possible for two people of different political parties to agree on something. Bloomberg's brief candidacy was characterized by being to the right of the entire rest of the Democratic field.