3 ms·
How about we actually fix our revenue problems and adopt a VAT? https://www.taxpolicycenter.org/briefing-book/what-vat https://www.taxpolicycenter.org/briefing-
by rayiner 6y ago
How about we actually fix our revenue problems and adopt a VAT? https://www.taxpolicycenter.org/briefing-book/what-vat https://www.taxpolicycenter.org/briefing-book/what-vat
> The value-added tax (VAT) is the world’s most common form of consumption tax, in place in more than 160 countries, including every economically advanced nation except the United States.
It’s absurd that we faff around trying gimmicks instead of using proven tools in use almost everywhere else.
- donw 6y agoFirst, because VATs are regressive. Imagine Alice has an income of, say, USD 50k. She's going to spend a big chunk of that on goods and services: housing, food, etc. Bob, on the other hand, makes USD 500k. He spends maybe twice as much as Alice does -- nicer house, flash car, all that. Bob can save and invest far more than Alice with a VAT. Second, because our governance problems are not because of a lack of money. The US has horrible schooling, in spite of being the 4th-highest spender on secondary education in the world, yet we rank in the same cohort as Latvia. I promise you they don't spend like we do on education. The US has a cultural problem. Part of which is throwing money at problems without actually fixing them.
- alejohausner 6y agoCanada has federal and provincial VATs. They are not regressive, because low income people get a tax refund, quarterly. VATs are good.
- donw 6y agoIf we replaced existing taxes with VATs, and did a prebate (e.g., Yang's proposal), that'd be a lot more palatable. Although I'd be curious what this would do to housing prices -- e.g., if you buy a house, is a VAT applied to your purchase price?
- tptacek 6y agoCountries with VATs seem to tend to exempt residential real estate.
- donavanm 6y agoAs an aside there are murmurs here in Australia, particularly NSW, about moving from property stamp duties to annual property or land taxes. Principal residences are currently exempt from the 1.6% annual land tax.
- lsllc 6y agoWe need progressive taxes! VAT is just noise if you're a billionaire, but it'll be a significant chunk of your income if you're at or below median wage. I always liked Steve Forbes' flat tax idea -- the first ~$52K exempted (or whatever median income is) and then a flat rate of 17% beyond that no matter _how_ it's earned (W-2, dividends, long/short term gains, whatever, it's 17%). Oh and we get to scrap the tax code. https://www.forbes.com/sites/steveforbes/2016/04/18/tax-day-a-painful-reminder-of-why-we-must-have-the-flat-tax/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/steveforbes/2016/04/18/tax-day-...
- tptacek 6y agoIf what you care about is funding services, which is ostensibly what we're taxing people for in the first place, billionaires are just noise; there aren't enough of them to fund anything interesting. A flat tax is great if your goal is to just stop funding anything at all.