3 ms·
I could see the point of digital radio back when they started switching to it, if they had put some rules in place to assure decent quality instead of allowing
by tzs 6y ago
I could see the point of digital radio back when they started switching to it, if they had put some rules in place to assure decent quality instead of allowing stations to opt for cramming in more streams by using ridiculously low bit rates. See the video from rwmj's comment [1].
But now? I don't see the point even if the streams were good quality.
When they started development, cell phones were expensive and not widely used. By the time they deployed, cell phones were much more common, but were mostly just voice and text.
But now they are widely deployed, and usually include internet. They also usually include WiFi and in cities public WiFi is widely available.
It seems more efficient, then, to not have a separate digital radio service and instead just serve digital radio streams over internet.
Then there is no need for people on the go to buy dedicated hardware for listening to radio. They've already got what they need with their phone.
People listening at home might prefer to listen on their A/V receiver than on their computer, but modern A/V receivers have Ethernet and/or WiFi and know how to stream, so again internet streaming can serve the needs that would have been served by digital radio. (And if they don't, it is almost certain that something else hooked up to your A/V systems, such as a Roku or a Fire Stick or a Blu-ray or a cable set top box or a TV has an internet radio app).
Keep analog radio. It doesn't use a lot of bandwidth [2], and you can make really cheap receivers that run for a very long time on batteries or hand cranks and do not require configuration or buying a service. It makes a good backup to have for emergencies.
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23739360 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23739360
[2] This may vary from country to country, but I think generally the AM band is about 1 MHz wide and FM about 20 MHz wide. In TV terms, that's about 1/6th the bandwidth of a single color TV channel for all of AM, and a tad under 3.5 color TV channels of bandwidth for all of FM.