4 ms·

"You will be able to select all or some of the content on your bookmarked page to save it as long as you want." Really? Even if copyright holders litigiously

"You will be able to select all or some of the content on your bookmarked page to save it as long as you want." Really? Even if copyright holders litigiously suggest otherwise? Of more practical value, does it work on pages that use JavaScript to dynamically render a page?

copyto 16y ago
Copyright issue applies to all services that allow you to save a page, even Google would be guilty for caching. It is up to the user to judge for a copyright infringement before saving a page.
- cskau 16y ago
  Since I'm currently exploring some of the same problems, I'd like to ask further.. How do you guard yourself against user-shared copyrighted content* ? Do you delete on request from the copyright holders? Do you weed out in the shared content once in a while? Do you have some kind of policy or agreement transfering the infrigement to the sharing user in such cases ? *Say, a user has access to some content behind a paywall, but shares it un-blocked through your service.
  - copyto 16y ago
    We have to delete public content that has been requested to be deleted by the copyright holders. In such a case the user will be notified about the infirigement and the possible removal of his content.
blacktip 16y ago
If you have an example site that dynamically renders a page I could try it out and show you the result
- jamesbritt 16y ago
  http://lifehacker.com/#!5785555/how-perfectionism-can-lead-to-procrastination-and-what-to-do-about-it http://lifehacker.com/#!5785555/how-perfectionism-can-lead-t... for example. I was pleasantly surprised to find that Firefox will do a successful Save As of the content, even though View Source only shows the original page. And the ScrapBook plug-in also saves the page correctly.
  - blacktip 16y ago
    There you go: http://copyto.co/b/MTQ http://copyto.co/b/MTQ , used the Chrome extension to select the main content only and saved it + made the bookmark public
    - jamesbritt 16y ago
      Sweet! Thanks.

copyto 16y ago

Copyright issue applies to all services that allow you to save a page, even Google would be guilty for caching. It is up to the user to judge for a copyright infringement before saving a page.

cskau 16y ago
Since I'm currently exploring some of the same problems, I'd like to ask further.. How do you guard yourself against user-shared copyrighted content* ? Do you delete on request from the copyright holders? Do you weed out in the shared content once in a while? Do you have some kind of policy or agreement transfering the infrigement to the sharing user in such cases ? *Say, a user has access to some content behind a paywall, but shares it un-blocked through your service.
- copyto 16y ago
  We have to delete public content that has been requested to be deleted by the copyright holders. In such a case the user will be notified about the infirigement and the possible removal of his content.

blacktip 16y ago

If you have an example site that dynamically renders a page I could try it out and show you the result

jamesbritt 16y ago
http://lifehacker.com/#!5785555/how-perfectionism-can-lead-to-procrastination-and-what-to-do-about-it http://lifehacker.com/#!5785555/how-perfectionism-can-lead-t... for example. I was pleasantly surprised to find that Firefox will do a successful Save As of the content, even though View Source only shows the original page. And the ScrapBook plug-in also saves the page correctly.
- blacktip 16y ago
  There you go: http://copyto.co/b/MTQ http://copyto.co/b/MTQ , used the Chrome extension to select the main content only and saved it + made the bookmark public
  - jamesbritt 16y ago
    Sweet! Thanks.