4 ms·
> FM audio quality is enough I really disagree there. The difference in quality between FM and DAB (not even DAB+) is very significant, and I’m not even an aud
by toyg 6y ago
> FM audio quality is enough
I really disagree there. The difference in quality between FM and DAB (not even DAB+) is very significant, and I’m not even an audiophile.
The problem is that 1) you don’t know it until you actually make the switch, and it’s not like you can borrow a car stereo system for a week to try it out, and 2) that’s pretty much the only advantage of DAB, from consumers’ perspective, so the price/value proposition is not good enough to make it a no-brainer purchase.
- corty 6y agoThe difference is only significant if the radio station uses a sufficient bitrate. There are some with atrocious quality in DAB because of their low bitrate.
- ooklala 6y agoI can only speak for the UK, but FM here sounds considerably better than DAB because stations on DAB are usually 32 or 64kbps & mono since they want to fit as many stations into the multiplex... (techmoan has a rant about it— https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=27w3quNTP84 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=27w3quNTP84)
- iso947 6y agoI had an early dab radio back in 2003ish, it was rubbish. I have dab/FM in the car now, and It’s noticeably better than FM. I use dab almost exclusively, but there are remote areas where only fm reaches.
- dtgriscom 6y ago> you don’t know it until you actually make the switch A perhaps philosophical question: if you have to train yourself to be able to perceive the higher-quality audio, do you end up enjoying the audio more, or are you just training yourself to dislike the lower-quality audio?
- raverbashing 6y agoThe first one It's similar to listening to a song over good headphones instead of crappy notebook speakers for example You start hearing all the details that were added to the sound. It's like seeing a movie on the cinema rather than in a small TV for example
- Retric 6y agoAdditional details is not always a net plus, IMO some recordings are significantly worse with ‘better’ audio equipment. For example the sounds of people repositioning their hands across musical instruments really bothers me.
- heavenlyblue 6y ago> For example the sounds of people repositioning their hands across musical instruments really bothers me. Would you prefer to be blind because if you can see you can also see a dead body?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Retric 6y agoBlindness is a straw man argument. I am saying for specific content there are limits to optimum resolution. If we are talking high vs low resolution, then no I don’t want to see extremely high resolution in focus pictures of corpses. Do you?
- heavenlyblue 6y agoLet’s be honest, your argument is no less straw man than mine. Why not watch high-resolution images of corpses? People working in medicine do this all the time. You’re clearly making a Luddite argument: under the circumstances of two things being the same but one of them providing a worse resolution anyone reasonable would pick the higher resolution, because you can always go back to a lower resolution but not vice-versa.
- puzzlingcaptcha 6y ago>I really disagree there. The difference in quality between FM and DAB (not even DAB+) is very significant, and I’m not even an audiophile. It might be appreciable at home, does it still apply in a moving vehicle? I personally can't tell the difference.
- giobox 6y agoI imagine for quite a few readers, car may be fanciest sound system they own and one of the only places they listen to FM radio in the first place. The extremely low bit rate used to broadcast some DAB stations is absolutely noticeable even on “cheap” equipment. The low bitrate issue is compounded further by DAB being mpeg 2 based, which is a hugely inefficient codec by modern audio standards. A 64 Kbps mono mpeg 2 audio stream is not great frankly, and common in DAB.
- gertrunde 6y agoWith good signal strength, DAB wins over FM easily, but it degrades horrifically badly with weaker signal strength, generally I tend to find this isn't that much of an issue with BBC stations, but worse with the commercial stations, and especially worse in a moving vehicle. (Not that the UK commercial radio space is exactly in a good place anyway after the global/bauer radio-pocalypse).
- jankiehodgpodge 6y agoDepends on the station. Some stations are broadcasting 32Kbit mono audio which certainly doesn't stand up to FM.
- switch007 6y agoMaybe I’m weird but some songs sound better on FM. Eg Bruce Springsteen Born to Run. Maybe it’s nostalgia kicking in