3 ms·
I worked at a company that did this almost a decade ago. The idea seemed simple enough, but the unintended consequences started adding up over the next few year
by PragmaticPulp 6y ago
I worked at a company that did this almost a decade ago. The idea seemed simple enough, but the unintended consequences started adding up over the next few years.
The biggest problem was that the company became the arbiter of what was offensive and what was not. We felt like we came up with a comprehensive list when we started, but a few people became very good at finding new words that might possibly be offensive to someone, somewhere, in some context. Eventually the company has to draw the line and decline to remove potentially-offensive words, at which point the company is effectively declaring that topic not offensive enough to take action. This doesn’t go over well, and some people are very eager to make a big deal about it on social media.
The second problem is that declaring certain words to be possibly offensive is easily misinterpreted as declaring those words as always offensive. We had problems with people assuming ill intent when interview candidates and new hires accidentally used words on the banned list with no ill intentions. Marking the words themselves offensive instead of the person’s intentions creates a lot of traps for people who don’t know about or haven’t yet fully memorized the bad words list. This created a lot of divisions and cliques within the company where people were hesitant to interface with certain other groups for fear of being mistakenly marked as offensive. When the safest option is to keep to yourself or a small group of peers who you know won’t misinterpret your words, cooperation and coordination decreases.
The third problem was the long tail complexity of eliminating these words from the business. Doing a search and replace on the codebase and documentation is easy enough. But you’re still left with third party open source projects and services that contain the bad words. Once you reach the point of people suggesting to fork open-source services just to rename parts of the source code, the complexity and cost grows exponentially. At the worst point, we had a team trying to justify creation of an Ubuntu fork that used the phrase “manual pages” everywhere instead of the possibly-sexist “man pages”. The amount of engineering time, energy, and dollars spent debating these topics and implementing solutions spiraled into far more complexity than any of us imagined at the start.
- spo81rty 6y agoWhere does this ever end is my thought as well.
- stareatgoats 6y agoWhere does anything ever end? The answer is always "when a reasonable balance is found". The idea that we can't do something because "where does it end" is symptomatic of black/white thinking. If I may say so (yes I may).
- dgfitz 6y agoI am wondering when “finger” “poke” and “mount” are under the microscope.
- trvrprkr 6y ago> The biggest problem was that the company became the arbiter of what was offensive and what was not. Companies already have to do this and they have done this for a long time. There are undoubtedly offensive words, phrases, and actions which a company actively discourages or will not tolerate. The problem is that society progresses in disjointed ways, and common vernacular often lags far behind that as well. Instead of waiting for the overwhelming majority of people to understand that some words which once were perceived as neutral actually carry a darker, less-desirable connotation, Twitter (and others) are working to get ahead of that. Sure, the lines may be blurry now, but that's no reason to claim that companies weren't arbiters of offensive words or actions in the past.
- loopz 6y agoModern authority have moderated speech. Trying to ban words is insulting, reprehensible and incompetent. At some online forums it may need to be done, but that is lack of better alternatives, like better moderation systems. Moderate behaviour and speech, not words and people.
- bJGVygG7MQVF8c 6y ago> Companies already have to do this and they have done this for a long time. Setting aside that you've honed in on a peripheral part of the OP: You're missing something that should be obvious here. What you're attempting to claim here is that engineers second-guessing themselves at every turn as they write code and being dependent on high-level authority to make low-level decisions at the level of word choice is normal and desirable. It's neither. It simply doesn't happen and it's incredibly boneheaded. Same as ever: Get woke, go broke.