7 ms·
The point of the original post is exactly what you are saying. They are only thinking about what it takes to avoid overwhelming the hospital system without thi
by colordrops 6y ago
The point of the original post is exactly what you are saying. They are only thinking about what it takes to avoid overwhelming the hospital system without thinking at all about collateral damage and other externalities. There was a recent UN study that estimates that 50 million children will go into poverty due to current measures. There is another NIH study showing several thousands non-covid deaths a day above the average, at least toward the start of the pandemic. I personally know two people that died because they didn't get the medical care they needed at the beginning of the quarantine. Suicides are up significantly. Overdoses are up almost 50%. Depression is rampant due to isolation and financial distress. Domestic violence went up drastically at the start of quarantine. Violent offenders were released from prison due to worries about covid infection due to overcrowding. It's not clear AT ALL whether we are net positive overall due to the current particular quarantine measures.
That is not to say that we shouldn't take measures. What it's saying is that the measures in place are not doing well at accounting for all impacts, which is certainly a difficult problem.
- rgbrenner 6y agoThat's a good point.. But also keep in mind that the number we need to compare those deaths to isn't the current covid death rate.. it's the death rate that occurs once the hospital system is overwhelmed... since that would be the result if all of the restrictions (that cause the effects you listed) were lifted.
- elmo2you 6y agoYou might want to give that line of reasoning some additional critical thinking. Because there appears to be a big assumption in that statement. One that might sound all but certain to you, but might not be. What I can tell you is this: I happen to have first hand experience from a country that initially took some of the most draconian of measures when the virus surfaced. All with the usual explanations as for why all that was absolutely necessary. Then, after some time, the local ruler needed to secure a reelection he had already planned before the virus spread. All of a sudden, it was like there was no virus anymore. Of course there was, but the topic was practically taboo while the elections where going on. Now that the elections are over, and said ruler has galvanized his position for the foreseeable future, the virus has returned and the number of infections grown. No surprise that stronger measures came back too. But that's not the interesting part. What is interesting, is that during the elections none of the doom scenarios that almost every country around the globe has used to justify/explain their measures (whatever those might be), happened. There is a good chance that a lot of bad news was suppressed and covered up. If only to ensure the election would not be forcefully shut down. But there are only so many mysteriously dead people and failing hospitals that even a government with absolute power and no accountability can cover up. The point here is this: that despite all the rhetoric about why all those draconian measure were so much necessary, when they were (practically all) temporarily lifted for political reasons, the world did not stop turning and neither did any systems collapse. In fact, in many/most aspects the country managed to temporarily recover more/faster than other countries in the region. That was, of course, until the election was over, and the virus "returned". I am not saying that any of the measures are wrong or that they didn't help prevent deaths. But what I am saying is that maybe the "reasoning" regarding what will happen without them isn't as much established fact as many people like to believe.
- dtech 6y agoWithout giving the country and statistic your rhetoric is meaningless. We know nothing about the state of your healthcare, the excess deaths, or how long the restrictions were lifted.
- elmo2you 6y agoMaybe I have good reasons for doing neither. And maybe those reasons have nothing to do with the numbers not suiting/supporting my "rhetoric". Either way, it doesn't take rocket science to figure out which country I'm speaking of. I "only" suggested to be careful about assuming what will happen to the systems, when the current measures are (temporarily) gone. That on itself should not be a revolutionary act in the first place. Remember, assumptions are the mother of all fuck-ups. If I did not have a seriously surprising experience myself, regarding the story I told, then I certainly would not have responded as I did. But decide for yourself what you do with the info. If you (want to) dismiss it all outright, only because it does not come in a package you demand, then go ahead. I honestly couldn't care.
- pessimizer 6y ago> from a country that initially took some of the most draconian of measures when the virus surfaced. If you had perfect quarantine for a month, you would eradicate the virus. If you had harsh measures for a period of time, then ended them in order to do some massive social event, I'm not sure why you would expect outcomes similar to if you had never had a lockdown. A harsh quarantine is a reset button. Places need a little time and a few outsiders in order to be reinfected and start the process again.
- elmo2you 6y agoFrom personal contacts, directly within the medical community, I can assure you that the measures did not eradicate the virus. If anything, the combination of an already dismal state of the local healthcare system, political opportunism and incompetence, and a systemic (and maybe intentional) failure to test even people who had been in substantial direct contact with the confirmed infected, made sure the virus spread quite "successfully". While in theory your logic might hold, the reality of countries that take such measures, and by which use of power they usually do so, might make that the effects end up almost the opposite of what you might expect.
- colordrops 6y agoDid I say anything about all restrictions being lifted? I don't think I did. Binary thinking here is rampant. There are hundreds of dimensions to quarantine policy, each of which could be tweaked.
- ardit33 6y agoyou are missing the point altogether as well.... people dying is a larger problem than missing income as well... income can be replaced, death is ultimate.... Also, we generally know that for every 1% increase in unemployment, there are 5000 extra death a year... (sickness, suicides, lack of basic items etc) so a 10% increase of unemployment, will cause an extra 50k deaths... Meanwhile covid has already caused 130k+ deaths. If left completely unchecked it can go into millions territory... (1-2 mil). If you halve the covid deaths, you can save at least 500k lives, at the collateral expense of 50k lives (due to rising unemployment).
- umvi 6y agoIf we are going the utilitarian route... Is a covid death worth same as an unemployment death? I sort of assumed most covid deaths were elderly people that have already lived full lives so only 5-10 years of life are lost per death. A suicide of a 30 year old on the other hand is ~50 years of life down the drain...
- pessimizer 6y agoAssume the average covid patient had 10 years left to live, and the average unemployment suicide had 65 years left to live. If we've had 130K covid deaths, and we arbitrarily say that whatever lockdown measures you think were excessive cut covid deaths by a third - are you postulating 10K excess suicides in the last 4 months?
- colordrops 6y agoNo, there are other possibilities, such as enacting policies around masking and cleanliness in business and public, without shutting anything down, e.g. Sweden, which has a number of deaths in line with other countries that had lockdowns.
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoThe worst case outcome in a pandemic is mass panic. A lot of people don't understand that death is a threat until they start to experience a lot of it in their cohort. If that happens after exponential growth, you get a sudden phase change where a large percentage of the working population switches from "This won't touch me and I don't care" to "OMG this is going to kill me." At that point people stay at home regardless, and the economy is badly damaged anyway. The difference is it's damaged in an uncontrolled way, with panic buying and supply chain interruptions - neither of which you want. The awful truth is that it's actually better to allow some businesses to die in lockdown as a fire break than to allow a pandemic to get completely out of control - because the latter results in a much higher death toll and more severe economic damage, as well as a permanent loss of trust in effective government.
- dtech 6y agoThis, and similar comparisons, miss the economic damage an uncontrolled outbreak has. "Letting it run it's course" will result in large portions of the workforce being unavailable at the same time for months, and permanently reducing the workforce due to excess deaths and likely decreasing the long-term health and capability due to insufficient medical care of severe cases. It's not a choice of doing nothing and having a stable economy at the cost of increased human suffering, it's a choice between severe economic damage because of lockdown measures and severe economic damage because of human suffering, healthcare costs and workforce capability reduction.
- colordrops 6y agoTwo problems with your response - first, you are putting words in my mouth. I said the opposite of "letting it run its course". Read the end of my comment. Second, how are you certain that alternative policies would be worse? That's my original point - that the numbers aren't really being investigated and compared. Please feel free to prove me wrong and provide links to comprehensive studies that account for secondary effects on society.
- pessimizer 6y agoThese are all choices we're making as a state aside from lockdown. Poverty and financial distress are a result of choosing not to preserve incomes (or protect those who didn't have incomes) during lockdown. Our economy was precarious before covid, and we were granted the perfect excuse to juice the economy. Congress held back (although we did far better than what was done after 2008) and spent more on crony giveaways than high-multiplier direct payments to individuals. The replacement that we did for incomes kept people in quarantine. Servicing people in quarantine was also an excellent opportunity to expand employment by the state that mostly wasn't taken, except by Amazon and big box stores. And the roadwork we could have gotten done. That one really annoys me. Outdoor jobs without close contact should have been ramped up. We had perfect weather for it in the US. A real quarantine would have been legitimately over by now in 99% of the country. I've even read that cities who were good at quarantine didn't even see much of a rise in cases due to the Floyd protests (based on positive test rates in people who said they protested) while places that had looser rules are seeing a bump from the protests. To me, that means that places that instituted complete quarantines were pretty much out of the woods a month ago.
- salmon30salmon 6y agoHow would a quarantine be over by now? We don't have a vaccine nor any reliable treatment. Unless we closed our borders completely like NZ, we would have an outbreak immediately upon reopening. Just like we are seeing now.