5 ms·
Yes, mitigate the possibility of overwhelming the hospitals. However, there are unintended consequences to that mindset. From domestic violence to substance abu
by chiefalchemist 6y ago
Yes, mitigate the possibility of overwhelming the hospitals. However, there are unintended consequences to that mindset. From domestic violence to substance abuse to the economic fallout [1], these "side effects" are real. Yet somehow completely unaddressed. How do we know the cure isn't going to be worse?
[1] There's plenty of data on economy vs health from the circa 2008 economic implosion. We could start with that, but we haven't. That's risky, for some fatal.
- vharuck 6y agoIt'd be hard to determine the difference between extra deaths and economic damage because of government actions versus what we would have seen with different or no action. I think, if there had been no government action, people still would've reacted to the pandemic on their own, causing economic damage and a spike in suicides. The difficult part is finding a good model to estimate the difference in effect. But by the time we saw cases on the West and East coasts in the US, there were no "good" options. We'd also need to account for a drop in deaths from fewer car and workplace accidents.
- claudeganon 6y agoYes, people keep mixing up cause and effect when talking about this. It’s true that bad government responses can exacerbate things (as the US seems intent on proving), but the pandemic was going to inflict serious economic damage anywhere it reached the uncontrolled state like now exists in the US. The only way to have prevented that was to act early and competently, which many countries have successfully done. But once you’ve crossed that threshold, demanding people risk serious illness and death for the sake of the economy isn’t going to get you very far in correcting things.
- chiefalchemist 6y agoThe point is, how much suffering and how many deaths are "collateral damage" from "the war"? Why are we assuming? What if the path we're on is worse? Do we really expect the elected officials to admit the error? Will the media ask? It's wrong to assume. If nothing else it devalues the lives lost and damaged from the side effects. Either we're all in this together or we're not.
- claudeganon 6y agoI’m not sure what the appeal is here? We know what kind of responses are effective and limit economic damage and death (Taiwan, South Korea, and Vietnam) and those that do not (the US, Sweden, and Brazil). Again, the economic impact and failure to confront the disease are inextricably linked. If you’re argument is that “if we’re already doing poorly, why do anything?” then the answer is the depth of how poorly we’ll do depends on what steps we take to mitigate the damage, even assuming we’re already on a bad path. It’s the difference between causing hundreds of thousands of deaths because of our screw up vs millions. All of this bad response spectrum will also have varying degrees of terrible knock-on effects, but those also exist because of the failure to intervene early and effectively, and put the US on a good path.
- chiefalchemist 6y agoI don't have an argument. I have a simply question: With regards to the collateral damage from the war on Covid 19, what are the estimates of suffering and death - both short and long term? That's it.
- claudeganon 6y agoThat’s highly variable depending on if we can contain it, as other countries have done. Taiwan, South Korea, and Vietnam are pretty much back to normal. New Zealand did a real, strictly-adhered to quarantine and now is fine. The US is probably in for a lot of pain because it refuses to acknowledge that throwing more bodies at the economy, irregardless of safety or sanity, isn’t going to fix things.
- chiefalchemist 6y agoDifficult? Yes. But we could and should try. Again, we have data and hindsight from "the great recession." That's a start. If we can model the virus' spread and buy into that interpretation, why can't we also try to model and discuss the "side effects" of that "war"?
- watwut 6y agoAfaik, domestic violence organizations organisations organized by the beginning of lockdown. They did had more work to do then usual and did what they could. It us just not true that this would be completely unaddressed. Also, while they loudly talked about risks, they were not saying we should not do lockdown. Turns out, abused people get sick too and can get their relatives sick too.
- chiefalchemist 6y agoThe issue here is the _aggregate_ collateral damage. It not any single entity (e.g., domestic violence). It's a massive mistake to assume the total collateral damage is minimal.
- SonOfKyuss 6y ago> these "side effects" are real. Yet somehow completely unaddressed. How are they completely unaddressed? The varying state responses and reopening strategies show that they are being addressed, just with different priorities. Some states have heavily favored shutdowns to minimize the direct impact, while others have weighed the second order effects as more critical and pushed to reopen more aggressively.
- chiefalchemist 6y agoThere's been minimal discussion of: - deaths due to an economic collapse - the longer term affect on health outcomes due to the economic collapse - suffering and deaths due to delayed health care - increase in deaths due to suicide - increase in suffering and deaths due to substance abuse - suffering and deaths due to domestic violence - Increase in obesity and diseases related to lockdown - And so on... - And so forth... There's an unsubstantiated narrative that dictates that Covid 19 is public enemy #1. The disconnect is that narrative is in truth a balloon grab. There _are_ plenty of negative and deadly side effects from blindly embracing that narrative. This isn't about Covid 19 being real. It's a headon realization that the aggregate side effects of "going to war" with Covid 19 is producing significant collateral damage. Assuming the former is more significant than the latter is naive and negligence.