3 ms·
A huge factor is multiple insurance companies add a lot of overhead to the system as they all try to negotiate lower prices. It’s common for a doctor to spend
by Retric 6y ago
A huge factor is multiple insurance companies add a lot of overhead to the system as they all try to negotiate lower prices. It’s common for a doctor to spend more time dealing with your insurance company after a visit than you. Which clearly means they need to dramatically raise prices to cover that overhead.
- lotsofpulp 6y ago> It’s common for a doctor to spend more time dealing with your insurance company after a visit than you. Which clearly means they need to dramatically raise prices to cover that overhead. How do you know the doctor wouldn’t be billing erroneously anyway? People have no idea what doctors do or what is appropriate. The insurance company serves as an educated advocate for the patient (they employ doctors and pharmacists) to reduce over billing. Yes, the people working at insurance companies could be over zealous, but the same applies to healthcare providers. If doctors didn’t want to deal with insurance, they are free to hang a sign that says $50 per 15 min consultation.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> The insurance company serves as an educated advocate for the patient (they employ doctors and pharmacists) to reduce over billing. Insurance company profits are capped at a percentage of payout, and they are part of oligopolies protected by high barriers to entry, why would they reduce overbilling or advocate for patients?
- lotsofpulp 6y agoBecause if they payout too much then they have higher premiums compared to their competitors, which means customers would opt for a different insurer? Obviously not forcing everyone to go through healthcare.gov crippled the ability for numerous health insurance to exist and compete, but that is a political problem.
- Retric 6y agoWith single payer systems it’s much easier to sanity check what’s going on. For example billion one organization for 20 hours of work per day is laughable, but spread that across 10 companies and they can’t tell. Similarly, having more data allows for better statistical analysis when combined with random sampling.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoYes, but without single payer, I don’t see a viable alternative to insurance companies or a similar organization double checking a doctor’s billing.
- Retric 6y agoOne option is to separate the verification process from the insurance companies. In other words you have some list of pre defined standards that are covered at some rate and then an independent agency applies those standards and looks for fraud. Aka a hospital might negotiate a separate rate for stitches with each company, but they don’t get to decide if it was needed on a case by case basis. Alternatively, apply the Japanese system where all procedures have a single agreed upon rate negotiated regularly.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoThat function is also performed by insurance companies in the US, sometimes known as managed care organizations. Many large companies self insure and use health insurance companies’ resources to implement their health benefits. Most, if not all, states outsource the implementation of their Medicaid plans to large insurers like Anthem or UHC or Humana, etc.
- Retric 6y agoAn agency outsourcing that function to a private company for all care in a state does not invalidate the savings. It’s a question of efficiency and conflict of interest not inherently a government function. That said, outsourcing them back to the same insurance companies which also offer plans has major issues.