2 ms·
Internet forums are typically for conversation not formal arguments constrained by some catechism of 'fallacies'. Domain expertise, consensus among domain exper
by pvg 6y ago
Internet forums are typically for conversation not formal arguments constrained by some catechism of 'fallacies'. Domain expertise, consensus among domain experts, etc are perfectly sensible heuristics one can apply to claims.
- colordrops 6y agoHow do you know this person is a "domain expert"? It's frankly outright foolish to give any weight to an anonymous "expert". Even then an anonymous comment could be valuable if there were links to sources demonstrating "consensus among domain experts", but nothing of the sort was provided. Your comments about what internet forums are for is completely unrelated and also incorrect. Internet forums are for whatever someone is willing and allowed to discuss.
- pvg 6y agoI don't know they're a domain expert! Hence the 'heuristic' part. I do know that in the course of normal conversation I'm not owed 'links to sources'. I can certainly ask for them if I can't figure out how someone arrives at their conclusions but it doesn't make reading comments without them (or without a list of the commenter's verifiable credentials) 'outright foolish'. What you are describing doesn't sound like a general purpose forum anyone would want to participate in. And the way you're describing it sounds outright scoldish.