3 ms·
That's because it's really hard to explain physics to non-physicists without using mathematics. The clever part isn't classifying the orbitals, it's finding the
by mhh__ 6y ago
That's because it's really hard to explain physics to non-physicists without using mathematics. The clever part isn't classifying the orbitals, it's finding the Schrodinger equation in the first place.
We knew electrons had wavelike properties, but what equation did they obey? Even with hindsight it's still a difficult thing to derive - the relativistic answer is actually wrong, for example.
You reach the truism because the equations take years to learn - in engineering you can just take the result and run but in physics you have to be careful to understand what you're doing.
The Schrodinger equation for hydrogen isn't that difficult to solve (try it), but conveying that process in English is difficult.
- vertbhrtn 6y agoMy understanding of QM is very naive, but Schrodinger equation seems really simple to me. I could probably even explain it to a 5 year old. I'd show a few pictures of standing waves on a drum surface: the first two energy levels create simple shapes, higher levels create more sophisticated shapes. Then I'd say that an electron is such a wave. Then I'd introduce the idea of electric potential: I'd put a heavy thing in the center and say that this is how the atom's nucleus warps the electric field; and this changes the wave patterns somewhat, but the idea remains the same. Then I'd say that often multiple standing waves mix together and we get a quasipattern that oscillates between a few standing waves. That's really it.