7 ms·
"They note that the finance sector today produces a greater percentage of GDP than at any time in history." This is not an effective argument. The computer so
by tedunangst 16y ago
"They note that the finance sector today produces a greater percentage of GDP than at any time in history."
This is not an effective argument. The computer software industry is also producing a larger than ever percentage of GDP. In other news, the building wooden ships sector is not responsible for much of the GDP in recent years. Is that a problem?
- rriepe 16y agoThey follow up with why it's noteworthy in the very next paragraph: "Historians will tell you that empires collapse when they become too dependent on finance, but I’m not so pessimistic."
- med555 16y ago...and economists will tell you something completely different. His points are awful and rely on no empirical evidence.
- fabjan 16y agoThe difference being historians have facts to go by, and economists have dreams.
- med555 16y agoWait, what? Maybe the Austrian School goes by theory if that, but every other school of economics goes by facts -- including the Chicago School, Monetarists, Keynesians, New Classical, etc. Economists' whole basis for their arguments is through empirical data and mathematical facts. Saying economists just relies on dreams is absolutely absurd and shows complete ignorance of the field.
- robak 16y agoOh really? What about latest Bernanke dream that you can solve problem of too much debt by getting more into debt? Isn't he dreaming?
- achompas 16y agoImplying economists use anything but data in developing macroeconomic forecasts is just absurd. Give it a rest.
- mattdeboard 16y agoI think you meant that bankers have dreams. They are the ones who invented the CDOs and other financial abstractions.
- robak 16y agoEconomists who do tell that too much finance ALWAYS led to social and economic collapse: Jensen, Faber, Rogers, Schiff... and read some history too before you accuse someone of not relying on empirical evidence. FIRE - Finance, Insurance, Real-Estate Economy - based on fake (paper) money, fake (virtual) instruments and debt won't hold for too much longer against a real economy based on production (China). Just wait for the day when Chinese tie their Yuan to gold/silver/oil/whatever. FIRE economies repeated through-out the History. They always failed. You can't build on paper foundation (read: on promises). You need to have REAL assets to back up your economy.
- rbarooah 16y agoIt's a problem because unlike other activities finance produces benefits to society only when it well, finances people doing things other than finance. Other activities are valuable in themselves.
- med555i 16y agoYou do realize companies that provide those valuable goods can grow faster, hire more people, and grow our economy's GDP much quicker, with more capital, correct?
- rbarooah 16y agoNo. Not correct at all. There is no evidence whatever showing that the current size of the financial industry caused faster growth, more hiring or GDP growth other than the financial industry itself.
- med555i 16y agoThat is a complete straw man. Please stop using straw man arguments.
- rbarooah 16y agoHow is it a straw man? You claimed something, and I said there was no evidence for it. I guess you just don't have any evidence.
- rbarooah 16y agoAnd since we're on the subject of evidence - what do you think of this: The private goods-producing sector value added fell 6.4 percent in 2009, after a 4.2 percent decline in 2008. The private services-producing sector declined by 2.1 percent, after a 0.4 percent increase in 2008. The finance and insurance industry grew 6.1 percent in 2009, partially offsetting the widespread economic decline. The increase was primarily driven by the strong recovery of the insurance carriers industry. From a December 2010 report from the government's bureau of economic analysis. http://www.bea.gov/newsreleases/industry/gdpindustry/gdpindnewsrelease.htm http://www.bea.gov/newsreleases/industry/gdpindustry/gdpindn...