4 ms·
I’m a stubborn person. Sometimes to a fault. It’s a blessing and a curse. The incessant “install our app” messages on Reddit are a major turn off and one of
by mulmen 6y ago
I’m a stubborn person. Sometimes to a fault. It’s a blessing and a curse.
The incessant “install our app” messages on Reddit are a major turn off and one of the reasons I use Reddit so little. There’s no reason Reddit can’t work just fine in a browser. The only reason to encourage the app so much is if it benefits Reddit. At that point our relationship becomes adversarial and there’s no reason to continue.
Nothing here is surprising. The app was clearly user hostile and doing something nasty, now we just know what it was doing.
- vmception 6y agoI've been a narwhal user for several years, its a third party reddit app and there are other more up to date ones. Your post is interesting because I never thought about reddit's poor mobile user experience bouncing people, I think of it is as just one implementation of their API and the content is still fire
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- TwoNineA 6y agoI paid for Apollo (3d party Reddit app), one of my best iOS app store purchases.
- waterfowl 6y agoApollo is also maybe the only iOS app I have used that put real thought and effort into idiomatic 3d touch/pressure/etc UX patterns. It's lovely and pro was like $3? $5?
- dijit 6y agoCareful with that. I used Alien Blue for a similar reason; before reddit just straight up bought it and deprecated it.
- ericol 6y agoBoth Reddit & Quora has this sort of "annoying" pattern (In Quora it turns into a dark one as you're not allowed to scroll down on a page after a certain point). On Reddit, on my opinion it seems how bad the page looks on mobile is on purpose (Compared to, say, HN). Besides that, I don't understand how clipboard access is not something the apps should ask permission for (And be able to work without it, obviously). Finally, considering the obvious use the clipboard has, there should be some sort of "this time only" permission possible.
- KingOfCoders 6y agoIf clipboard is mostly copy text, paste text into form field it shouldn't have anything to do with an app, there is no need for the app to have clipboard access, this should be managed by the OS. Only if you have "take license key from clipboard" or something like this, the app should ask for a one time permission as you've said.
- tomjen3 6y agoThere is nothing wrong with e.g getpockets functionality to show the url that you have in your clipboard and offer to add it. There is something wrong with sharing that information anywhere else - which should result in a permanent revocation of the dev cert for the organization that has produced it, as should any type of telemetry (spyware, as we called it in the old days).
- ericol 6y agoYou're 100% correct.
- WaxProlix 6y agoI wonder if there's a correlation between pushiness to use an app and nastiness of the app itself's behavior. I feel the same way about a lot of this crap, and it's everywhere these days; even my bank has a shady 'Continue' button on its Use Our App modal which takes you to the damn app rather than continuing to your bank account. To get to the account and actually continue, you have to click a much much smaller "Not this time" or something below. Awful stuff.
- boardwaalk 6y agoI suspect they care more about browser-level ad blocking than your clipboard, but the end result is the same.
- thinkingkong 6y agoI still browse to https://old.reddit.com https://old.reddit.com It's actually still so much better to pinch and zoom on the old site. The new one is super janky and totally broken on mobile. The app is just a pain to use anyway.
- Silhouette 6y agoAt this point, I do slightly wonder whether a significant number of people are using the "new" Reddit at all, or whether it's just being kept online as a face-saving exercise. The publicly visible feedback seems to have been overwhelmingly negative and remains so, and I can't remember ever seeing anyone comment anywhere that they actively prefer the new version. I use old Reddit routinely myself. I quite often see advice to use old Reddit, such as the parent comment. I do occasionally see an indication that someone is using the new interface, for example because they used the ``` notation for code on a programming subreddit, but this seems relatively rare compared to encountering criticism or advice to avoid it.
- dmix 6y agoAnd on desktop auto-redirects to old.reddit.com are a must addon: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-CA/firefox/addon/old-reddit-redirect/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-CA/firefox/addon/old-reddit-re... https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/old-reddit-redirect/dneaehbmnbhcippjikoajpoabadpodje https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/old-reddit-redirec...
- jedberg 6y agoIf you’re logged in to Reddit these aren’t necessary. There is in an option in the user prefs to always use old Reddit.
- ljm 6y agoEven when I set that I still get redirected to the new version. I guess I've just learned to cope with the new design and all the stuff being added into it that make it even worse. This whole obsession with reducing information density and making more space for ads and huge 'cards' or pictures is pretty much a UX anti-pattern as far as I'm concerned. It's like how 'minimalism' is considered a rich-person's hobby because everything's spacious and clean, rather than small and cosy. Web minimalism takes up more space to do less, while tending to cost a lot more in terms of bandwidth used.
- ezoe 6y agoI wish the thing is that simple. The reality is more concerning than petty data gathering. Today's smartphone users don't use the generic web browser. When they heard that there is a trending web service X and they decided to try, they search from the app store for the X app, blindly install the top hit app completely disregarding whether it's official, unofficial or complete malicious fake app. That's why most of the modern web service must provide the brainless apps that is just a wrapper of the browser. Otherwise, people use whatever random garbage app they found at the app store that contains the service name and believe that is the web service you provide. It is my opinion that smartphone makes people dumb. Or maybe it's reverse so the smartphone allow even the dumb people get access to the computer and the Internet.
- uniqueid 6y agoOn a related note, does anyone here use, or know of, a good, Raspberry Pi-based content proxy server? Pi-hole is only a DNS server, so it wouldn't block half the nonsense on the web today.
- dehrmann 6y agoDo you really want to install a custom certificate to get it to work? Most content blocking has shifted to the browser because of this.
- uniqueid 6y agoThanks. The last time I considered doing this was a decade ago, before "https everywhere." Is it some kind of wildcard cert that covers the entire internet? I'd have to research what it would break, and the security ramifications. Probably not worth it :(
- dehrmann 6y ago> Is it some kind of wildcard cert that covers the entire internet? Yeah, you'd set up a new CA. > I'd have to research what it would break Initially, anything using HPKP will break, and any apps doing cert pinning will break. It's probably not worth it.
- d_tr 6y agoReddit has, on more than one occasion, outright blocked me from reading posts from the phone's browser, demanding that I download their garbage in order to continue (I did not, of course).
- app4soft 6y agoJust never use official apps (for anything; not only Reddit); instead use something like Slide or RedReader.
- oneweekwonder 6y agopersonally dropped using old.reddit.com or i.reddit.com and found http://reddit.premii.com http://reddit.premii.com a lot more enjoyable to read /r/ on mobile.
- watertom 6y agoGee I can't imagine why the Chinese who control Reddit would want a spy app on your phone.
- mariushn 6y ago+1. Other examples: https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/think-twice-when-installing-mobile-apps-marius-andreiana https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/think-twice-when-installing-m... (ironically, on linkedin...)