3 ms·
I know Alice and Bob are mega-classic foo/bar-style example names, but I also feel like it brings an unnecessary implication to use gendered names as examples w
by Lammy 6y ago
I know Alice and Bob are mega-classic foo/bar-style example names, but I also feel like it brings an unnecessary implication to use gendered names as examples when talking about hiring.
- dpc_pw 6y agoRelax, Bob is transgender. You can't make assumptions like that without asking for pronouns first. Duh. :D
- shadowmore 6y agoI can't tell satire from reality anymore.
- Lammy 6y agoI'm being very sincere. It feels out of place here for the masculine example name to be the outgoing FOSS-contributing self-driven one ("ideas people and leaders") and the feminine example name to be the one who is good at showing up on time, keeping her head down, and being told what to do.
- pluto9 6y agoIf they were reversed, you could take offense to Alice being the head-in-the-clouds, undisciplined, and unreliable one while Bob is focused, hard-working, and gets the job done. Of course that would be equally silly, because an example is just an example and there's no reason to read this sort of thing into it.
- mpweiher 6y ago"It's you who's drawing all those dirty pictures" The Rorschach Test http://bouldertherapist.com/html/humor/MentalHealthHumor/rorschach.html http://bouldertherapist.com/html/humor/MentalHealthHumor/ror...
- Lammy 6y agoHey now I didn’t say I was offended, just that it seems out of place in such a context :)
- mpweiher 6y agoPoe's Law: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poe's_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poe's_law
- stevula 6y ago1. Is the suggestion to use unisex names like Alex and Taylor instead? Do we have to say Candidate A and Candidate B? 2. Did you find Alice was a negative gender stereotype in the post? I actually had the opposite impression: Bob is a free spirit/idealist who can’t focus on his day job but Alice is a practical/good employee who gets stuff done. If the roles had been reversed I think it would have been more likely to raise a flag for me. I can how someone could have the opposite interpretation, that Bob is a thought leader and Alice is a simple worker bee. It seems to depend on the reader's interpretation.
- scpedicini 6y agoI know we're all searching for ways to become morally outraged, but it feels like no rational person would draw this conclusion, particularly considering that Alice and Bob were originally created as generic placeholders when discussion cryptography. Sometimes a cigar is just a cigar.
- Lammy 6y agoThere's no need to imply I'm morally outraged when I posted this in about as un-outraged a manner possible. It's easy for you or I to think it's ridiculous when we have knowledge of the history of these names as examples throughout computing, but it feels like no rational person could look at them in this context and not think that a person who lacks that background knowledge may draw the wrong conclusion.