4 ms·
I'm extremely convinced the "anti-cancel-culture"-culture has to be the most thriving white collar subscription industry of our times. For people being cancelle
by Barrin92 6y ago
I'm extremely convinced the "anti-cancel-culture"-culture has to be the most thriving white collar subscription industry of our times. For people being cancelled I can't really tell how many dozens of blog posts with thousands of likes like this I see of people publicly talking about not being able to publicly talk.
Following the obligatory comparisons to 1984 for being cancelled out of the network-tv drag queen tv show community, comparisons to the Soviet Union followed promptly.
As someone who had family in East Germany let me tell you what Soviet cancel culture was. Being thrown into a dungeon where the light doesn't shine or someone being shot in the head by a Stasi agent.
Extremely bored people being cancelled out of some community by other extremely bored people on the noise generating machine that is social media is about as much Soviet Union as Trump fearing STDs was his Vietnam.
This reminds me of the valiant defenders of the intellectual dark web, which is so dark that it seems to occupy the permanent topspot on every podcasting service on the internet
- 9HZZRfNlpR 6y agoThe cancel culture in soviet union (i was a citizen) was very similar, more often than not you weren't shot in the head but you weren't accepted to university, couldn't get a goid job etc all because you or your parents shed the guilt of disagreeing with extremists communists. For the average person the culture was similar what were seeing today, during the Stalin times they preferred bullet or Siberia indeed.
- Barrin92 6y agoLet's remember though the woman writing that article in particular is a lawyer and partner at a VC firm. I've seen Eric Weinstein talk about this stuff a lot, he's managing director at Thiel Capital. We're not talking about factory workers being cancelled by the communist party for not spying on their neighbours, we're talking about a bunch of upper-class professionals being cast out of the intelligentsia, which annoys them a lot. As the saying goes, "the conflict is so fierce because the stakes are so low". But this is not the Soviet Union. Not even as a metaphor. The entire cancel culture debate is in itself extremely limited to the kind of people who are overly online. Nobody who is flipping burgers or driving Uber is being cancelled, because they don't have an audience, or the time to waste and probably the good judgement to waste their time like we do
- zozbot234 6y agoIt's not about the professionals themselves, it's what this cancel culture run amok does to the climate of intellectual debate. We want powerful people to be meaningfully engaged with civil society, and they aren't going to do that if they expect that they'll be treated unfairly. If the meaningful alternative to being "cast out of the intelligentsia" is to start exerting arbitrary power yourself... well, we can guess the outcome and it isn't pretty.
- Barrin92 6y agoI think underlying the disagreement here is really a different estimation of how much this stuff matters. To many people these sort of debates between intellectuals appear very important, they have this idea that culture sort of flows down from the 'elites' and so on. Hence say, Jordan Peterson being very panicked about universities, and the university students being very panicked about Peterson. I don't think it actually matters at all, it's like the Seattle autonomous anarchists. It's all simulated outrage. Ezra Klein points out in his book on polarization that the US was much, much more violent during the 60s and 70s, when there was very little polarization or cancel culture. Just count the number of political assassinations or compare riots then to today. Today is peaceful by comparison. Reactionaries haven't turned around acceptance of gay rights yet, cancel culture hasn't cancelled the conservative judiciary yet and ushered in the red guard. Very little has materially changed, it's almost all pure spectacle, if anything a distraction for actual change. You see how much Zucc cares about being cancelled? Anyone remember occupy Wall Street? Maybe cancelling is at an all time high because of how little it actually does.
- zozbot234 6y ago> Ezra Klein points out in his book on polarization that the US was much, much more violent during the 60s and 70s, when there was very little polarization or cancel culture. Well, obviously the Internet wasn't a thing yet in the 1960s and 1970s, but I'm not confident about your claim that there was no political polarization back then. And fringe radical culture wasn't entirely unknown, either. The controversial cancel culture of today has its own roots in the political agitation of the 1960s and 1970s - which in turn was drawing much inspiration from the Maoist "cancel culture" of sorts in the PRC.
- blub 6y agoA totalitarian regime is about control. Sure, that comes with some imprisonment, torture and murder and these will continue to occur throughout the regime's lifetime, but they are merely tools they use to achieve their goals. And while they're effective tools, they are rarely applied at scale, for the simple reason that if too many people are dead or imprisoned this will be both counter-productive and risky for the regime. Purges notwithstanding, of course. Instead the tools they apply at scale are fear and indoctrination, to the point that the people aren't sure any more what is sane, right, just. To the point that even if they manage to keep their sanity, their spirit is broken and wouldn't dare question the status quo even with their friends or family. This is the great sin and corruption of tyranny, it smothers free thinking, the mind and the soul. Modern totalitarian governments have become even smarter and only use physical violence surgically, instead relying on other subtler measures. Which brings me to my point: you're now relaxed and confident because no one's imprisoning or killing people for their opinions. They're only getting fired, having their reputations or businesses destroyed, etc. You're focusing on the tools instead of the effects - people are being confused and unsure about what it means to be a good person and they're afraid to express their thoughts. I doubt that Americans will be facing Soviet Union conditions anytime soon, but you're on the path of having free thinking squeezed out of you and this is why many of us are alarmed.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]