3 ms·
> To completely dismiss the more prominent factors at play including states rights Question #1: Name three states rights the South supposedly aruged for. Ques
by jcranmer 6y ago
> To completely dismiss the more prominent factors at play including states rights
Question #1: Name three states rights the South supposedly aruged for.
Question #2: Count how many of those rights they actually granted to their own states.
For it being supposedly such a major factor in their succession, states rights are conspicuously silent in both the ordinances of succession, contemporary oratory, and in the text they wrote in their own Constitution.
- henriquez 6y agoYour questions miss the point. The Confederate states wanted to be free from federal economic control. Such a freedom is not an individual liberty that would be conferred by the state upon its citizens but rather an organizational mainstay that would define the state’s relationship with the federal government. Slavery was the tipping point but the conflict goes much deeper than that.
- jcranmer 6y agoThe only federal economic control they objected to was the abolitionism movement that would rid them of slaves. At an extreme stretch, maybe you could claim objections over federal industrial policy and internal improvements, but you'll have to observe that there was zero mention of this in their ordinances of succession, they were avid supporters of this on the state level, and despite their constitutional prohibitions against it, they enacted such policies during the Civil War due to their abysmal infrastructure. And as a footnote, it is worth pointing out that a large part of the animus against internal improvements is driven by fear of the dilution of wealth in the slaveholding elite.