2 ms·
> Uber is big tech, but still loses money hand over fist. But whose money are they losing? Nobody holds a gun to your head and requires you to buy shares in Ub
by AnthonyMouse 6y ago
> Uber is big tech, but still loses money hand over fist.
But whose money are they losing? Nobody holds a gun to your head and requires you to buy shares in Uber.
- throwawaygh 6y agoThat's somehow beside the point, since the topic is organizational competence.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoBut it isn't, because the competition still works. Incompetent private organizations fail and go away and lose only the money of their investors and not unwilling third parties.
- throwawaygh 6y ago> Incompetent private organizations fail and go away I'll keep that in mind next time I read a thread about tech consulting shops or ISPs... > and lose only the money of their investors and not unwilling third parties. Well, there's also the employees, anyone invested in massively managed funds that include the private organization, etc. Who are all willing participants. But really only in the same sense that you, too, could get a graduate degree in a STEM field and immediately emigrate to another country.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> I'll keep that in mind next time I read a thread about tech consulting shops or ISPs... ISPs are as they are as a result of government regulations. I don't know what the problems with "tech consulting shops" are supposed to be, but they sound like something people should stop doing business with until they go away. > But really only in the same sense that you, too, could get a graduate degree in a STEM field and immediately emigrate to another country. Except not in that sense at all, because emigrating to another country -- which may not be any better -- is a dramatic high-cost change to your entire life, whereas not investing in or working for a particular company is the default state that happens if you do nothing.
- throwawaygh 6y ago> but they sound like something people should stop doing business with until they go away.... because emigrating to another country -- which may not be any better -- is a dramatic high-cost change to your entire life, whereas not investing in or working for a particular company is the default state that happens if you do nothing. This sequence of thoughts expressed so closely together powerfully demonstrates how fundamentalism results in motivated reasoning that retards certain conclusions in one context and hyper-charges rationalization in the opposing context. If you don't like market capture in the USA, you have the simple choice of simply stop doing business with the USA. Just like businesses always have the simple choice of simply stop doing business with abusive counterparties.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoHow is it that you think an individual leaving behind their friends and family and everything they've ever known and picking up and moving to an entirely different hypothetically better country which may or may not even accept them as a citizen is on the same level as choosing Canonical over Oracle?
- throwawaygh 6y ago>>>> Incompetent private organizations fail and go away The point is that a private organizations often continue to exist despite incompetence because other (competent and highly profitable) organizations are not able to efficiently executing on the choice to end a business relationship. The point is this: ending a business relationship can take as long, or even longer, than an individual executing on the choice to emigrate to a new region. Ask any bank that has been continuously trying to move off of big iron since the 90s whether switching off of mainframes is, to use your words, a "dramatic high-cost change to your entire organization". > ...leaving behind their friends and family and everything they've ever known... Yes, and so is breaking a long-term business relationship... My point is NOT that citizens should be expected to move between countries. My point is that your expectation about the efficiency with which firms can execute on their preferences is just as flawed as the expectation that labor can efficiently execute on its preferences (by e.g. moving between countries). So, no, incompetent private organizations do not fail and go away. That baseless religious belief of market fundamentalists has no basis in reality.