4 ms·
Isn't the term "big tech" just successful companies? So we ignore all the failures to get to that point and then declare them better? Isn't this like asking w
by duxup 6y ago
Isn't the term "big tech" just successful companies?
So we ignore all the failures to get to that point and then declare them better?
Isn't this like asking why the Super Bowl champs are always good at football?
- throwawaygh 6y agoAnd it’s not even big tech. It’s like 4 companies with great pr and monopoly-like market power, being judged mostly on the basis of Naive public perception and brand awareness. Oracle and SAP and Infosys are big tech companies by any reasonable definition of big. You’ll be hard pressed to find technologists who would decscribe those companies as competent. And there are some amazing teams within those orgs that do stuff which is genuinely more impressive than hacking out protobufs from 1030am to 415pm with an hour long lunch, which is just to say that even within tech there’s a lot of PR/brand sentiment shaping opinions of people who should know better. Uber is big tech, but still loses money hand over fist. And even if we limit ourselves to the few companies with the most competent PR — the faangs — are they really so competent? Or are they just extracting value from near-monopoly market power?
- duxup 6y ago>Or are they just extracting value from near-monopoly market power/ Yeah I do wonder, if you somehow could, could those companies as they stand now just up and "do it again", could they? Granted that's a complex question, but I suspect the answer isn't automatically yes... and likely very much a hard no.
- throwawaygh 6y agoFacebook has already bought its replacements a few times over, right?
- icedistilled 6y agoUsing a lot of oracle software is like going to the worst california dmv.
- throwawaygh 6y agoBut that can't be true! Big tech is super competent and government is broken! /s
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> Uber is big tech, but still loses money hand over fist. But whose money are they losing? Nobody holds a gun to your head and requires you to buy shares in Uber.
- throwawaygh 6y agoThat's somehow beside the point, since the topic is organizational competence.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoBut it isn't, because the competition still works. Incompetent private organizations fail and go away and lose only the money of their investors and not unwilling third parties.
- throwawaygh 6y ago> Incompetent private organizations fail and go away I'll keep that in mind next time I read a thread about tech consulting shops or ISPs... > and lose only the money of their investors and not unwilling third parties. Well, there's also the employees, anyone invested in massively managed funds that include the private organization, etc. Who are all willing participants. But really only in the same sense that you, too, could get a graduate degree in a STEM field and immediately emigrate to another country.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> I'll keep that in mind next time I read a thread about tech consulting shops or ISPs... ISPs are as they are as a result of government regulations. I don't know what the problems with "tech consulting shops" are supposed to be, but they sound like something people should stop doing business with until they go away. > But really only in the same sense that you, too, could get a graduate degree in a STEM field and immediately emigrate to another country. Except not in that sense at all, because emigrating to another country -- which may not be any better -- is a dramatic high-cost change to your entire life, whereas not investing in or working for a particular company is the default state that happens if you do nothing.
- robbyt 6y agoThere are several big tech companies who are not good at anything other than making and managing money. Inertia machines like IBM, Oracle, and probably some other ones you can think of...
- duxup 6y agoValid point. Some aren't very good too.
- indigochill 6y agoI have no actual idea about the state of the AI industry, but I was under the impression IBM was doing pretty well there, as well as in quantum computing R&D. But that's based largely on the obvious products they provide in those fields. I don't think I'd miss Oracle if they ceased to exist tomorrow, though. Aside from VirtualBox.
- avalys 6y agoCongratulations, you’ve discovered the idea of competition and why it makes the free market better! Failures fail and go away, and what you’re left with are the successful organizations that know how to do things! Unlike in government, where failure is often rewarded with an increased budget and a chance to try again next year with more money.
- duxup 6y agoI feel like that is too much of a pass for the "free market". I don't buy into the idea that the failures don't count and we just recognize the success.
- ptmcc 6y agoIf this were true, companies like Oracle, SAP, Infosys, etc. would have died out a long time ago. They are bureaucratic hellscapes internally that rival even the worst governmental orgs, with even less oversight. We have nothing close to a free market as idealized by libertarians. And whether we should or not is an entirely separate argument.
- avalys 6y agoThose companies do have to convince people to keep paying them money, otherwise they would cease to exist. The government is unconstrained by even that requirement.
- baggy_trough 6y agoThose companies probably aren't going to exist in 100 years, but the U.S. government still will (doubtless even less competent than today.)
- dgb23 6y agoI think you've been down-voted because your statements read like shallow (neo-liberal) propaganda rather than insightful observations. A sufficiently well functioning government is necessary for a market to be well functioning and vice versa. > Failures fail and go away, and what you’re left with are the successful organizations that know how to do things! This isn't generally true and is dependent on what you define as a failure. The private sector is exploiting, polluting and destroying natural resources all over the world even with regulations. Some of it are honest mistakes and ignorance, but much of it are "trade-offs". The general and consistent quality of products and services in prosperous societies is enforced by regulations. Your food is (very) healthy, your houses are solid. Similarly workers are being exploited all over the world. The only reason there are places where people are (close to) guaranteed to live decent, free lives is based on decades of activism, unions and governmental action. There are also things where the government is just strictly more efficient than markets. Mostly projects and services which are very long-term oriented such as education, police, military, infrastructure, public transport, foundational research etc. They all have two things in common: They are based on collaboration rather than competition and they achieve long-term goals. You see there is a balance here between the short-term gains of the competitive markets and the long-term stability of the collaborative governments and non-profits. As with many things this can be simply observed from nature and evolution. Both competition and collaboration are important strategies of survival.