5 ms·
Why ban the players, and not just the design? I once ran a large online forum and set up a word filter to replace certain phrases with "fluffy bunnies" and oth
by reaperducer 6y ago
Why ban the players, and not just the design?
I once ran a large online forum and set up a word filter to replace certain phrases with "fluffy bunnies" and other absurdities. It did a remarkable job of improving discourse once the foul-mouthed types realized their hateful messages were being massaged.
Microsoft could use some kind of super-cool AI-drived ML-based image recognition to replace the flag with a rainbow flag or something.
- ochoseis 6y agoI like this idea as long as it’s transparent that’s what’s happening, because it creates less of a wedge and is humorous to most. Booting people off a platform would lead polarizing resentment imho.
- notahacker 6y agoI think it'd be funnier if it was done silently like shadowbanning, so the racist troll didn't know why people kept apparently innocently assuming he was gay. But I wouldn't expect MS to go for humour, especially not dealing with sensitive politics and audiences involving a lot of minors.
- GuiA 6y agoI played similar games when I ran forums, but really you're just shuffling the problem around. Bored trolls/extreme ideologues will be delighted to play cat and mouse with your measures, and will feel particularly proud of themselves when they circumvent them creatively. In the end, you have to decide what outcome you want - using half effective measures hoping that the racists will keep it down, or kicking them out and making it clear that they aren't welcome? You can't have it both ways.
- arcticfox 6y ago> Why ban the players, and not just the design? This is a silly complaint IMO. If you break the rules, whatever they are, a ban is a completely reasonable punishment. A 1- or 2- strike policy gets the same result you are talking about with no "super-cool AI-driven ML-based image recognition"
- fzeroracer 6y agoIn your online forum case, what exactly do you do when toxic users wisen up and start working around your filter? Do you ban them or just continue letting them flaunt the rules?
- fpgaminer 6y agoI've seen the replacement filter on a few forums, and it's _surprisingly_ effective. People just ... didn't bother working around it. No idea why, it seems like they would, but I guess they just couldn't be arsed. Don't forget that the replacement filter is just for banned words. Toxic/abusive behavior would be covered by the usual manual moderation. Though I don't recall ever seeing someone banned for working around the filters on the rare instances that they did. EDIT: This is in stark contrast to normal filters which just remove or blank out words. Those were _always_ worked around. For whatever reason people feel affronted by those kinds of filters, but the silly replacement filters were "fun".
- reaperducer 6y agoIn your online forum case, what exactly do you do when toxic users wisen up and start working around your filter? It didn't happen. The system worked fine for the 15ish years I was running it, with about 30,000 daily active users. The offenders just got bored and moved on.
- numpad0 6y agoDisrupt the forum regularly? Toxic users tends to prevail against newcomers.
- ApolloFortyNine 6y ago>I once ran a large online forum and set up a word filter to replace certain phrases with "fluffy bunnies" and other absurdities. It did a remarkable job of improving discourse once the foul-mouthed types realized their hateful messages were being massaged. Really? When I've seen this done, all that happens is you end up the 'approved' word. Everyone knows what it means though. So I guess if all you care about is the word itself, and not the meaning of it, it does work great. In reality if every instance of 'shit' is replaced with 'barnacle', if I call you a 'barnacle head' on said forum, we both know what I'm saying.
- holler 6y agothat doesn't mean everyone else knows though, and it at least detoxifies the conversation to observers
- VRay 6y agoHearthstone and some other online games only allow you to say a handful of positive messages to your opponents. Of course, what happened is that this somehow made interactions MORE toxic, since any time I say "Good game" or "Well played!" my opponent assumes I'm being sarcastic, and starts repeatedly blasting me with the same emote again and again.
- holler 6y agoahh, the same thing happens in Rocket League
- BEEdwards 6y agoso you mean they can use coded language to spread hate without being discovered? Almost like a dog whistle, that only some can hear...
- holler 6y agoI mean, ok... Is saying "fuck!" spreading hate? what about "you asshole!"? Sometimes humans just express their emotion using words. It isn't always about race. Gaming in particular evokes lots of emotions and always has. Personally I don't like when words are scrambled such as the case with Rocket League, because as someone else pointed out, you end up with barely being able to say anything without some part of it being scrambled. But I can understand the motivations for a company to do such a thing.
- tptacek 6y agoWhy not ban the players? The game platform will do fine without them. Accommodating them --- tracking the number of "strikes" they've received, etc --- costs resources. There's a finite amount of resources; why spend any of them on these particular players?
- snowwrestler 6y agoIt's way more efficient to just keep a graphic from being uploaded, than it is to set up a super-cool AI ML system that constantly monitors every car for unapproved imagery. If we hypothesize that it would take X level of effort for MS to centrally detect and alter the graphics of every car, we can conclude it would be at most X/accounts effort (way easier) for each human player to detect and remove the same graphic from each of their own cars.
- whalesalad 6y ago> Why ban the players, and not just the design? The goal is not to censor the image, it is to change the behavior of society. The goal is to punish bad behavior and set a good example. The reason we are in this mess in the first place is that people turn the other way and sweep bad behavior under the rug instead of facing it head on and addressing it.
- eindiran 6y agoThis is actually how "weeaboo" became a word (outside of the Perry Bible Fellowship cartoon[0]). There was a filter on 4chan that turned "wapanese" into a "weeaboo", and pretty soon the former was completely forgotten and the word that is actually in use in "weeaboo". [0] This comic is the original source of the word: https://pbfcomics.com/comics/weeaboo https://pbfcomics.com/comics/weeaboo