4 ms·
To move forward as a country you need to care about and build public infrastructure - from roads, and science, to health all the way to city parks and internet.
by coldtea 6y ago
To move forward as a country you need to care about and build public infrastructure - from roads, and science, to health all the way to city parks and internet.
Companies and private moguls wont create good infrastructure out of charity, and what little they will create, it will be created to be milked as much as possible, and milked as much as possible. Think cost-cutting and short/mid-term profit, not vision and future thinking.
And having the state "incentivizing" private companies to build such infrastructure (paying, cutting taxes, letting them reap the profits, create oligopoliges, etc), as opposed to build it itself or pay companies to do it (but design, control, and run it as a public infrastructure) is even worse... Kind of like why Korea or some such countries have the fastest internet on the world, and places like New York despite 10+ million densely packed citizens don't, after trillions given from the state to telcos...
- onepointsixC 6y ago>Companies and private moguls wont create good infrastructure out of charity, and what little they will create, it will be created to be milked as much as possible, and milked as much as possible. Think cost-cutting and short/mid-term profit, not vision and future thinking. How is that meaningfully different to what NYC and NY have been doing themselves with regards to infrastructure? Crossing the George Washington Bridge costs $10.50. There's so much congestion all throughout but legislatures are happy to sit on the laurels of infrastructure investments many decades ago instead of aggressively building more, thus deepening income inequality.
- sameers 6y agoThis is essentially what Marc Andreesen's point was in his "build" essay. Most local governments have gotten stuck in a perfect storm of rentier interests, environmental regulation barriers, union disputes, lack of public interest, etc. I guess it's a kind of short-termism, with each interest group looking out for its constituents. And there are too many interest groups at too many levels. There's a great analysis of transportation infrastructure costs that came out in the New Yorker, as part of a story on the new head of the NYMTA, Andy Byford (Bynum?). The bottomline is that we can't blame any specific political section, like saying that it's all the unions' fault, or all because we regulate the environment too much. Other OECD countries have the same concerns, in terms of protecting worker safety and the environment. But in the US, the number of competing groups has gotten past some critical point that it's making the whole system move way too slowly.
- coldtea 6y agoIn the "you need to care about and build public infrastructure" part. Merely not having private interests build them is not enough - it's just the second, different, point I've made.
- koheripbal 6y agoThe correlation between public spending and the metrics lagging in the article doesn't really exist. The areas of the country that lag behind the most, have huge investments in these social welfare projects and infrastructure. I'd like to see an accurate correlative model that demonstrates high correlations within the US to see what the winning strategy is.
- jhbadger 6y agoDo they? Places like Mississippi that are lagging behind on metrics aren't particularly known for their social welfare or infrastructure.
- koheripbal 6y agoI don't think individual anecdotes really serve the argument. We need data.
- coldtea 6y agoI, for one, don't think data clarify the situation in political/social issues - they're either distorted (and mis-collected) to misrepresent the situation, or misinterpreted and diced and re-defined based on whatever biases a side has. Plus you always need to have a theory and a point of view to interpret data (raw data are just numbers and metrics, with tell little by themselves). Having open eyes and a point of view trumps data -- it's just difficult (and of course you can think you've achieved that when you haven't).
- devalgo 6y ago>To move forward as a country you need to care about and build public infrastructure What are you a dirty commie?? /s
- jeffbee 6y agoThe counterexample to your claim is New York's Central Park, which has been funded by private donors since 1980.
- coldtea 6y agoIt's easy to do that near prime real estate, where the park (existing, already reserved and cleared up as an area, and built by the city) helps prop property values (managed or owned) by many of the same beneficial donors... Less easy to do so for roads to working class neighborhoods, school districts in Mississippi, and so on...
- jellicle 6y agoThe city hired a non-profit to manage the park. The vast majority of funds spent in Central Park come from the taxpayer. The main reason for the setup is so that the city will have plausible deniability when rich people want to use part of the park for their own endeavors (weddings, galas, etc.). You certainly aren't pretending that Central Park is some sort of privately provided amenity, are you?
- jeffbee 6y agoNot sure which Central Park you are referring to but in New York City the private Central Park Conservancy raises the vast majority of the park's normal operating funds and over the last 30 years has provided virtually all of the capital for renovations. https://www.city-journal.org/html/set-parks-free-11996.html https://www.city-journal.org/html/set-parks-free-11996.html
- washadjeffmad 6y agoNot that the rich are incapable of long-term thinking or charity, but the Conservancy is a non-profit that gets 25% of it's $65M funding from taxpayers and does a lot fundraising. Where I'm from is a monument to private works. There are signs showing what areas looked like through the decades, and while barren for most of it, great parks and buildings once existed for the local wealthy who razed swathes of the city rather than allow them to be converted to public use by blacks and the poor. The names of the neighborhoods are the only remains of those times. Parks and Halls and Clubs downtown sit with no parks or halls or clubs nearby them, roads torn up or blockades built to cordone off access. One park that the rich didn't eat is nice, but I wouldn't run out to put any utilities or infrastructure in their hands because of it.