3 ms·
Pretty-printing the abstract content into an arbitrary target language (a better way of putting it than "translation") would be quite the challenge, because "co
by zozbot234 6y ago
Pretty-printing the abstract content into an arbitrary target language (a better way of putting it than "translation") would be quite the challenge, because "conceptual models" do vary by language. One can attempt to come up with something that's "as abstract/universal as possible" but it remains to be seen how practically useful that would be.
For that matter, making the source model "logical" and "compositional", as implied by the Wikilambda idea, only opens up further cans of worms. Linguists and cognitive scientists have explored the idea of a "logical" semantics for natural language, even drawing on the λ-calculus itself (e.g. in Montague grammar and Montague semantics), but one can be sure that a lot of complexity will be involved in trying to express realistic notions by relying on anything like that.
- memexy 6y agoI didn't assume the translations would be lossless. It's obvious there will be conceptual mismatches but that's why this is interesting. Because when the abstract model is made concrete people can notice the gaps and improve the abstract model. I can imagine a feedback loop that improves both the abstract and concrete/translated models as people work on improving both to reduce the conceptual gaps between the abstract and concrete models.
- numpad0 6y agoI’m starting to feel the structure and content of “abstract content” is going to be quite like Wikipedia pages in target languages zipped into single archive plus overheads...