3 ms·
I didn’t make any comment on whether the person read the article. By ‘reading along’ I was referring to earlier places in this thread where the issue is alread
by zepto 6y ago
I didn’t make any comment on whether the person read the article.
By ‘reading along’ I was referring to earlier places in this thread where the issue is already addressed, for example: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23705338 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23705338
If you have counted this as a violation of the site guidelines, please decrement the counter.
What shortening is recommended in this case?
- dang 6y agoWell, that's a distinction without a difference. That guideline isn't technically just about reading an article vs. something else. HN is a spirit-of-the-law, not letter-of-the-law place. https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&query=by%3Adang%20spirit%20letter&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&qu... I would recommend just leaving out the first sentence. It's not clear that the comment loses anything by it. Alternatively, you could say "This issue is already addressed upthread, for example <link>". That would be the equivalent of "the article mentions that". Yes, that's not shorter, but the intention here is to make one's points without personal swipes. And linking to the other explanation also adds information. By the way, once I read your explanation of what you meant, it seemed like a much lesser violation than it did when I read it without that. The trouble, though, is that other readers encounter such a comment without knowing what you meant either.
- zepto 6y agoOk, I’ll err on the side of not saying this kind of thing, however I note that simply ignoring the conversation so far and making an assertion that is clearly contradicted by an earlier commenter’s personal experience is at least as much of a violation of the spirit of decent conversational standards as expressing mild frustration at such behavior.
- zepto 6y agoI’m also going to just say for the record: I think it is clear that I neither violated the spirit of the rule, nor the letter of it. It’s also simply not reasonable to say I made a distinction without a difference. We know that a lot of people engage with the comments on HN without fully reading the source material, and this is now expected behavior. This makes the guideline as written a good way to avoid a common and unproductive antipattern. However there is a clear difference between not fully reading the source material and not reading the comments you are replying to. If you want the rule to cover both cases, then you should update it to do so. A rule like ‘don’t make inferences about other commenters knowledge or understanding of the post or the thread - but rather address this through commenting on the meaning of their statements’ would cover this and a host of other issues, but the one you have used simply does not. Your suggestion - “This is addressed unthread” can be a dismissal (especially if inaccurate) that is significantly more offensive than “sounds like you aren’t reading along”. “How can it be objectively user hostile, if someone such as csunbird loves it?” Would fit this rubric. In any case, something seems off about this particular moderator intervention.