5 ms·
Is there more of a summary of what this film or thing ... is? My reading comprehension sometimes escapes me, but to me the article starts like I already know w
by duxup 6y ago
Is there more of a summary of what this film or thing ... is?
My reading comprehension sometimes escapes me, but to me the article starts like I already know what it is talking about. So these people went about their daily lives being constantly filmed only on set? Round the clock? They lived there? They chose to do this?
- CharlesW 6y agoAlong with the links in TFA, this might be helpful: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DAU_(project) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DAU_(project)
- trabant00 6y agoThe point of the article was to get you outraged, not informed. Such is polygon.
- karaterobot 6y agoThe linked article doesn't provide a lot of information. However, the Guardian article it links to is a bit better, despite being much older. https://www.theguardian.com/film/2019/jan/26/inside-the-stalinist-truman-show-dau-i-had-absolute-freedom-until-the-kgb-grabbed-me https://www.theguardian.com/film/2019/jan/26/inside-the-stal...
- watwut 6y agoThe first paragraph seems to answer most of your questions: > The cinematic behemoth was meant to unfold in a living, breathing three-acre recreation of postwar Moscow, built in the Ukrainian town of Kharkov. Cameras would follow hundreds of non-professional actors and thousands of extras day and night, as they lived life as if under the watchful eye of the KGB
- duxup 6y agoI felt like that left more questions than answers as to how this played out exactly. Who chose to participate, what did hey know, how do they feel about their experience, why? It seems like an extraordinary system like that should involve ... a bit of elaboration. The article seems to question more than just the quality of the film but the treatment of the actors, and other topics, but doing so without understanding how such a strange film was actually made seems off...
- watwut 6y agoIsnt that odd information to expect from what seems to be primary movie review? Even if the article wants also criticise some abuse that happened, the whole "who chose to participate, what did hey know, how do they feel about their experience, why" still seems like too much information/expectation. Just getting interviews and verifying them would take awful lot of work for basically review.
- duxup 6y agoNormally I don't watch a movie and think the people on screen are actually being abused. I feel like they raised the issues that sort of ask those questions.... did abuse happen? Then yeah you kinda should explore that fact or not.
- watwut 6y agoThey did not raised questions. They directly stated that abuses happened. They did not went into bacstories and motivations of people who were actors or participants.
- duxup 6y agoRaise questions, directly state it. I feel like either way they should explain that a little. Looking at other article I'm not sure that it's a given fact or such. There are lots of vague articles but none seem particularly factual as far as what actually happened. It seems strange to me to raise the question or say it happened but not actually address if it happened and the we say discuss how "well it's a movie review so I don't have to explain that".
- ajzinsbwbs 6y agoThese are good questions to ask, but I wouldn’t expect a movie reviewer to do investigative journalism and hunt down the people from this film. It’s not really in the job description.
- acqq 6y agoFrom the "open letter" to the co-directors of the Berlin Film Festival: https://kkbbd.com/2020/02/29/an-open-letter-to-carlo-chatrian-and-mariette-rissenbeek-from-accredited-russian-members-of-the-berlinale-press/ https://kkbbd.com/2020/02/29/an-open-letter-to-carlo-chatria... "We are obligated to reserve our judgment of the project as a whole — but we are within our rights to discuss DAU. Natasha, which is competing as an individual title." "At the time when Harvey Weinstein is found guilty of sex crimes, in an era marked by the struggle against the culture of violence and abuse in the film industry, does the Berlinale see any ethical issues in screening a film that (by its own authors’ stark admission) contains scenes of real psychological and physical violence against non-professional actors, as well as unsimulated sex between people under the influence of alcohol? In the festival directors’ opinion, would such a film be possible to exhibit if it were created in the so-called First World — for instance, Germany, France, the United Kingdom, or the U.S. — and used on-screen talent from these countries?" (emphasis mine: "a film that (by its own authors’ stark admission) contains scenes of real psychological and physical violence against non-professional actors")
- pjc50 6y agoThis seems absolutely bonkers. World's largest LARP. Extremely Soviet to have what is effectively a Potemkin village for an audience. Bizarre that more of it wasn't filmed, producing "only" 700 hours of film, and the whole thing seems to have been done fairly quietly rather than a massive blaze of publicity. Like Endemol's "Big Brother", on a city scale. The abuse may also have become .. intrinsic to the project? The voyeuristic dominant seems to be a common type among film directors. He had a unique opportunity to control and film sexual interactions, and he may simply have decided to carry on with it because nobody stopped him.