2 ms·
If the null hypothesis is that research professionals' discovery of and access to papers interesting and relevant enough to their own paper to cite is independe
by notahacker 6y ago
If the null hypothesis is that research professionals' discovery of and access to papers interesting and relevant enough to their own paper to cite is independent from the paper also being available on Scihub, I don't think the paper's demonstration that papers interesting enough to garner future citations are [predictably] also more popular on Scihub than those which aren't does much to support its rejection.
There's no reason to believe the correlation between realized access and future citations isn't exactly the same or stronger for subscription platforms or paper copies in university libraries, and nothing in the paper itself to suggest that researchers publishing in top tier journals might discover and access papers exclusively through those methods rather Scihub.
I'm sure the frequency with which papers are referenced in undergraduate essays also correlates with future citations in top tier academic journals, but any paper arguing for a causal Undergraduate Essay Effect on citations in top journals would be laughed off, especially if they made claims like 'revealed the importance of undergraduate scholarship in almost doubling the number of [top tier journal] citations of articles mentioned by undergrads'
[FWIW I don't think the direct and indirect impact of papers being accessible Scihub on professional research work is literally zero, but this paper does nothing to indicate otherwise.]