12 ms·
> When she got her unemployment benefits, she realized something unheard of: She was making more money not working. The temporary COVID unemployment bill was s
by PragmaticPulp 6y ago
> When she got her unemployment benefits, she realized something unheard of: She was making more money not working.
The temporary COVID unemployment bill was so rushed that they didn’t index the unemployment to the person’s earnings. If you lost your job or had your hours reduced, you get an extra $600/week on top of state unemployment. About half of people receiving this are receiving more from the combined unemployment measures than they did from their jobs.
This is was a necessary compromise to get the relief enacted as quickly as possible. We didn’t have an easy way to implement a more complex unemployment system at a national level, so we compromised with a flat rate for everyone. Unfortunately, many people are misinterpreting this and assuming that unemployment is always this lucrative (it’s not, and the $600/week ends after July) or assuming that our government has enough money lying around to pay everyone this much all of the time (we don’t, this is actually very expensive for the taxpayers).
- hobs 6y agoOur Quantitative easing and corporate bailouts are in the trillions, why would we not pay out significantly less for people who are struggling to find jobs? Why does the till start counting when its normal people affected?
- tkeAmarktinClss 6y agoThe bailout have totally changed my mind on why you should work for a fortune 500 company Individuals will never have political power like a billion dollar corporation. If you can rise up the ranks, you get some of this power. Sure it's a moonshot, but how many self made people make billion dollar companies? You could count them. I think I'm going to pick a major fortune 500 and leach off it. Even if I hang around there for 30 years, I get profits and tax payers will subsidize the losses.
- chasd00 6y agoi've sort of came to this conclusion too. I've spent most of my career in the small biz and startup world. I'm over worrying about the fate of the entire company every hour of the day. I have a family and these days I just want a paycheck that isn't late, a 401k, and PTO. Maybe i'm officially old... or maybe just more wise ha.
- jschwartzi 6y agoThe medical insurance is typically really good too. When my fiancé quit her job due to the hazards of working retail it turned out that for only 200 more a month we could retain her insurance and shave 12000 off the cost of having a baby. They pay for IVF too if we need it which is normally a six figure procedure. Having a baby was otherwise so expensive we weren’t sure we could afford it.
- greedo 6y agoIVF shouldn't cost six figures. When we did it, it was about $12K.
- jschwartzi 6y agoThat's about what it cost my friends.
- greedo 6y agoAs I commented, we didn't pay that much. https://www.verywellfamily.com/how-much-does-ivf-cost-1960212#:~:text=The%20average%20cost%20for%20one,high%20as%20%243%2C000%20per%20cycle https://www.verywellfamily.com/how-much-does-ivf-cost-196021.... The drugs are separate, but I think we paid around $5K for them. Now if you're unlucky, you might have to go through multiple cycles, but our specialist only charged us the base cost. We had to pay for the additional drugs however.
- greedo 6y agoMy employer isn't public, but is a large insurance company. The issues with working for a large company is bureaucracy and corporate lethargy. Of course this depends on your team, the company, etc. And while you might have job security, that can be tenuous as well. Really just depends on how savvy you are at promoting yourself and managing up.
- packetlost 6y agoBecause bailouts (usually) make the government money in the long run. They're in the form of low-interest loans, they aren't just handing out money to corporations.
- eli_gottlieb 6y agoNonetheless, bailouts come with the social cost of increasing market concentration and moral hazard.
- hobs 6y agoDo you think subsidizing the poor enough so our economy doesn't have to choose between immediately collapsing and killing the poor wouldn't save us an enormous set of costs?
- bradstewart 6y agoI absolutely think we should do that. The problem is it's extremely hard to quantify that cost/gain, while its extremely easy to quantity the cost/gain of low-interest loans. Not to say its impossible, or that we shouldn't try--we should. But when you have a bunch of senators arguing, it's easier to point to the easy numbers.
- PragmaticPulp 6y ago> why would we not pay out significantly less for people who are struggling to find jobs? The CARES act allocated most of the money to individuals, state and local governments, public health, and education initiatives. The amount given to large corporations (much in the form of loans that will be paid back) is less than that given to individuals: NPR has a good breakdown. The idea that corporations are receiving “trillions” in cash payments is a myth. https://www.npr.org/2020/03/26/821457551/whats-inside-the-senate-s-2-trillion-coronavirus-aid-package https://www.npr.org/2020/03/26/821457551/whats-inside-the-se... I fully agree that the allocation and lack of oversight around the funds to corporations is not good, but it’s incorrect to suggest that trillions are going to corporations or that more money is going to corporations than individuals under this bill. Furthermore, you can’t compare loans and measures like quantitative easing to cash payments like that. Giving someone a cash payment and giving a loan to a business have very different actual costs in the long-run, obviously.
- gregwebs 6y agoThat breakdown is missing the trillion dollars of corporate debt that the fed is now engaging in purchasing. Correction: in terms of direct corporate debt purchase, they have currently committed to less than half a trillion dollars of purchases independent of the CARES act. But the breakdown is also missing $210 billion of reduced corporate taxes! The CARES act is a good attempt at providing fair outcomes for everyone, but that is just one of the things the fed is funding. Take a look at their balance sheet from their own website: it went up over 2 trillion in the blink of an eye and they are not done yet: https://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/bst_recenttrends.htm https://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/bst_recenttren... There are winners and losers in what is going on now, and corporate America is without doubt the biggest winner. By proxy, the wealthiest Americans that are the biggest owners of the financial assets the fed is supporting are also the biggest winners. Since we are accomplishing all this by printing money, those that don't win lose even more because their dollars are worth less. The long-term result on the current course will be even greater wealth disparity between the rich and the poor. You might have noticed many people complaining about this wealth disparity during the recent economic recovery in which the fed has added almost 4 trillion dollars to their balance sheet (again see the fed's chart). These wealth gaps historically lead to populism, which gets us our current president.
- andrewmutz 6y agoThat's not a fair comparison. QE are loans that get paid back, and bailouts are equity purchases. The government makes money on these programs. Stimulus payments are gifts, and the government loses money on them. To be clear, the stimulus payments are essential for helping people and are a great thing for the wider economy. But you can't compare them dollar-for-dollar, as they are not like each other.
- throwanem 6y agoWhen was profitability added to governments' remit?
- andrewmutz 6y agoThe government is not chartered to make money, but that's frequently a side effect of lending and equity. You can see the numbers here from the last bailout: https://projects.propublica.org/bailout/ https://projects.propublica.org/bailout/ The government handed out $634B. The government recouped $390B + $364B = $754B. So, $120B profit. Again, I'm not saying we should bailout corporations and ignore the little guy. The stimulus checks are critical. But you can't compare them dollar for dollar.
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 6y agoIt's not profitability for profitability's sake. It's a positive number on a budget balance sheet. At the end of the day, they have some kind of budget to spend on stuff. The sum of the expenses has to fit the budget. If this comes out as a net positive, they can spend more elsewhere, like on unemployment benefits or schools or whatever else they're planning to need money for in the future.
- Armisael16 6y ago> The sum of the expenses has to fit the budget. Is this actually the case? They have a money printer. What’s the problem with using it, as long as inflation stays low? I mean, I suppose technically seigniorage is part of the budget but then your statement is just a statement of definitions, not an insight.
- Melting_Harps 6y ago> Our Quantitative easing and corporate bailouts are in the trillions, why would we not pay out significantly less for people who are struggling to find jobs? Why does the till start counting when its normal people affected? Seriously, this is just bleating, tired banker/cronyist narrative we've always seen when the Economy blows up like in 2008; there are billions/trillions for Bankers destroying the economy but if that is re-directed to the People who have lost their jobs because of State incompetence hell breaks loose--I worked in Culinary so I'm one of those, but I have a diverse skill-set so I can pivot unlike mnay of my co-workers. Also, I've been immersed in the Hong Kong struggle since 2014, and when this mystery pandemic kicked off in mid-January and the CCP was forcing borders open there and dissappearing journalists, citizens and punishing physicians I knew the spread was going to happen if all nations didn't contain it as China was not going to. Flash forward to February and the CCD did this despite what was coming out in PUBLIC MEDIA: https://www.dallasnews.com/news/public-health/2020/03/02/coronavirus-patient-mistakenly-released-from-isolation-in-san-antonio-before-testing-positive-for-illness-mayor-says/ https://www.dallasnews.com/news/public-health/2020/03/02/cor... https://ktla.com/news/nationworld/wuhan-evacuee-released-from-quarantine-in-texas-later-tested-positive-for-coronavirus/ https://ktla.com/news/nationworld/wuhan-evacuee-released-fro... Hong Kong was already quarantining by mid Janurary and their economy and the protests started to decrease due to the influx of Mainlanders invading HK and overwhelming the Medical Industry. The fact that this spread throughout the rest of the World was an inevitability as travel remained, I was personally in San Antonio when they released those people from Wuhan on my way back from Boca Chica headed back to Colorado. This is State incompetence at its most extreme sense and should be just as a stark wake up call as Police Brutality was for Society; the fact is this is a scale issue, not an individual party one should not be ignored. There was no way anyone would accept a shutdown of the Economy of any significant size,or even on a logistical level even when they were gawking at Wuhan leaked videos in early January and commenting on Social Media about it. The only ones that did were small city-states like Hong Kong, Taiwan and larger island nations like New Zealand and South Korea who are on constant alarm due to N. Korean and CCP interference and constant missile alarms so knew how to mobolize when needed--a very undesirable.miserable thing when you realize the SK population is 41 million, or roughly that of California. In summary: some would have you believe that the People, especially those who have had their Industry and entire Life's work destroyed, don't deserve to have financial support but are often those who pay the most in real terms for the ever increase in taxes/cost of living. But God-forbid the Jamie Dimon's or Lloyd Blankfein's of the World go without their corporate welfare. F-them, seriously: even when Dimon/JP Morgan came out in support of Bitcoin I only hoped he gets his much deserved comeuppance soon.
- ceejayoz 6y agoIsn't the point to get people to stay home? "I'm making more doing what I'm supposed to be doing" seems like a good approach, not a side effect of rushed legislation. Aren't you also not eligible for this unemployment if your work has reopened? You only get unemployment if you're willing to work.
- protonimitate 6y agoI think the point of the $600 was to keep the economy from seizing up, and keeping people at home was a side effect.
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> they didn’t index the unemployment to the person’s earnings...we didn’t have an easy way to implement a more complex unemployment system at a national level This wasn't an oversight or logistical concern [1]. [1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/nation/2020/03/26/coronavirus-sanders-unemployment-relief/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/nation/2020/03/26/coronavirus...
- TheSoftwareGuy 6y agoFrom your own article: >President Trump and Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin worked to convince those senators that the universal $600 unemployment boost would be more efficient than varying supplements by income because that would require the federal government to administer funds through a patchwork of state-run unemployment programs, The Washington Post reported.
- amscanne 6y agoThe point made above is that this was a well-known aspect of the supplement. That the executive had other reasons for pushing the bill anyways doesn’t change that.
- Nightshaxx 6y agoRepublicans acctually did try to anticipate this problem with an amendment but Democrats pushed it through. [1] I don't know how long an amendment would delay the bill, but depending on the time period an argument could be made that this was intentional. Yes, if this was going to delay the bill a few weeks, it probably was just rejected to get it out, but if it would be a few days I think it would be reasonable to consider it. [2] https://www.vox.com/2020/3/25/21194278/lindsey-graham-coronavirus-stimulus https://www.vox.com/2020/3/25/21194278/lindsey-graham-corona...
- mitchdoogle 6y agoIf the Republicans had held up the bill, then Democrats would've pushed on less corporate bailouts. It's the same argument they always have.. who matters more, big business or individuals?
- entropea 6y agoWho consumes the products?
- adamsea 6y agoJust to nitpick a bit with language I dont think "problem" is the right word. The real problem is that the law lets companies pay so many people so little to begin with. Not saying you necessarily disagree. I think language has a tangible and often unconscious impact on our thought porcess so wanted to point it out. In America, large companies should be required by law to pay their employees a living wage. Its not OK for working people to be food insecure, unable to save for retirement or their childrens education, etc. Id say that is the root problem.
- centimeter 6y ago> The real problem is that the law lets companies pay so many people so little to begin with. Economists pretty much across the board disagree with you. If you don’t allow companies to pay market rate for low-value labor, they’re simply not going to hire those people at all. They’re not going to lose money paying $15/hr (or whatever) for a job that only nets them half that. All a “minimum wage” law actually does is eliminate categories of employment available to people with low skills or ability. You’re not helping those people by unemploying them.
- BurningFrog 6y ago> this is actually very expensive for the taxpayers Uncle Sam has long since stopped paying for things with tax money. Any new expense is handled by borrowing or printing money.
- onei 6y agoIsn't printing money when you're short risky economically? My high-school history was a long time ago, but this is what Germany did post-WW1 and it ended in people bartering the family silver for the essentials.
- pjc50 6y agoFirstly, it's only somewhat true; look at this graph https://tradingeconomics.com/united-states/money-supply-m0 https://tradingeconomics.com/united-states/money-supply-m0 and note that it's not zero indexed. The raw money supply has doubled .. with surprisingly little effect on prices and wages. Secondly, people get confused between extension of credit and money printing. For that you want the separate measure "M2". Thirdly, the real lesson of the hyperinflation crises of Germany, Zimbabwe, Argentina etc. is that you can't print oil, gold, or the foreign currency needed to buy them. Germany was paying a huge amount of reparations to France (which would be where the family silver ended up - 20 billion goldmarks was paid, which had to come from somewhere). The United States is in a hugely privileged position. It has enough domestic oil and food production for its needs. The gold standard is no longer relevant. Inflation and interest rates remain low. If you imagine a dial with a yellow warning at "8" and a warning redline at "9", the US is currently arguing over whether turning it from 1 to 2 is going to be the end of the world. The limit does exist, but it's a long way away.
- BurningFrog 6y ago> with surprisingly little effect on prices and wages. No one - who's talking at least - seems to understand what's going on with this. It's uncharted territory in a world economic system way more complex than when text books were written. I have to think fundamental reality must catch up sooner or later, possibly unravelling in a sudden crash. Then again, I do not understand this!
- brightball 6y agoAnd the bigger issue is that correcting this is going to be a new political hammer to hit people with.
- adamsea 6y agoRespectfully, I believe you have it backwards and the issue needing correcting is this (quoted from article). "Few employers have compensated extra for on-site work amid the health crisis. A recent survey by the Economic Policy Institute found that fewer than a third of people who had to leave their homes to work during the pandemic received additional pay or benefits. As U.S. coronavirus cases persist and some states are even backtracking their reopening plans, workers have flooded social media with calls for hazard pay."
- brightball 6y agoI don't have any issue with hazard pay. The concern is entirely about people being paid more than their jobs to stay home. In some conversations I've had with people, there's an attitude that staying at home is just a giant vacation that they'd like to go on as long as possible. It's an understandable position as well for anybody who won't see much of an impact from the economic side effects. When people begin asking to extend the stay-at-home-pay program, there are a lot of people who will support the idea of getting paid excessively to stay home and anyone who tries to correct that fiscally unsustainable situation is going to be made out to be the bad guy. Hazard pay for essential workers makes complete sense. It's the excessive unemployment for people to stay home that's the problem. For a bunch of people, it's a giant vacation. For others who are working through all of this, they are strained, stressed out, worried about getting sick and their nerves are shot. All in for hazard pay, but fix the unemployment problem. It's completely out of balance.
- adamsea 6y agoI guess what I’m saying is, it’s not just hazard pay. So many people in this economy aren’t paid a living wage to begin with. In an ideal world I would agree with you. In the world we live in my suspicion is that (not saying this is you specifically) calls to “balance” “excessive” (imho a case can be made for unemployment being higher than ones previous pay - parents for example have to home school now in addition to work - they paid taxes for schools but e kids can’t attend them. One theoretical.) unemployment right now are really just political cover for eliminating pandemic-related financial support for citizens from the federal government entirely.
- adamsea 6y agoThose are all good points but I want to emphasize that the root issue is that US law basically allows companies to exploit workers and not pay them a living wage, and as we are seeing now this does tangible damage to our society as a whole. [EDIT: I encourage downvoters to explain why they downvoted and point out what assertion I make about worker exploitation in the U.S. is not empirically verifiable.]
- entropea 6y agoThe Capitalist will always try to cut costs at the benefit of shareholder pockets, especially at a period when workers have the least or close to the least working rights of any western country. The most expensive costs are typically labor. Why do you think they started manufacturing in China? Can anyone explain to me how you get around greed like that in Capitalism?
- jjkkk 6y agoStrong unions, and strong contract law, without the current union call for elimination of issues addressed by said unions (minimum wage, health benefits) Problem will be taken care of by individual union contracts locally
- zippy5 6y agoWhy shouldn't the work go to the one who will do it the cheapest? The are billions of people around the world living in poverty, destitution, and with no opportunity. Globalization has been equalizing labor compensation around the globe, which means that Americans as whole have been averaging down but a great many below the global poverty line have been averaging up. If Americans laborers want to maintain their economic disparity, there are two paths. One is protectionism. The biggest benefit of maintaining this ”trade war” is not that we will get a better deal, it's that it add enough uncertainty to global labor arbitrage that loss aversion make US workers appear the ”safe bet”. The other path is higher productivity. In order to pay Americans orders of magnitude more than workers in other countries, they need produce orders of magnitude more. This means, better training and better machines. It's not an accident that computers and networks have both been the dominant machines of the past couple decades and working to create and use them has been accompanied higher compensation.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> The temporary COVID unemployment bill was so rushed that they didn’t index the unemployment to the person’s earnings. No, it was a deliberate choice to make total benefits bump up to approximately full earnings at a low-but-not-quite-bottom-barrel working income with common state formulas while providing (proportionate to income) less benefit to high income workers (presumed to, when working, have greater surplus income.) That at the very low end this meant that benefits would be above usual working income was known, but considered by supporters to have limited moral hazard since it required involuntarily becoming unemployed to qualify and unemployment was (and remains) high so that most people with it wouldn't be able to get new jobs anyhow, because of propensity to spend at the low end, the extra income was also viewed as general stimulus as well as individual relief. It was also controversial from the beginning, with the Right raising moral hazard arguments that it would encourage people to become and remain unemployed, as if that were an option for most recipients. > or assuming that our government has enough money lying around to pay everyone this much all of the time Federal spending doesn't come from money laying around, in the first place, it comes from money the government decides to have because it wants to spend it. Even if you buy into the mythology of the fisc, marginal spending comes out of borrowing at, typically, very low interest rates (currently, IIRC, at negative real interest rates), not
- SilasX 6y ago>It was also controversial from the beginning, with the Right raising moral hazard arguments that it would encourage people to become and remain unemployed, as if that were an option for most recipients. I don't get it -- you're talking like the concern was dubious, even as we see that prediction came exactly true.[2] And yes, not seeking re-employment, or not asking to return to work is an option; see all the stories about employers being unable to get employees to return to work because they'd take an income cut [1]. And, to be sure, that may be the desired outcome, that people stay away from work while receiving some income, so as to mitigate the epidemic risk, while preserving financial security. That's a fair argument to make. But the moral hazard concern was 100% correct, that it would layer on an extreme disincentive to work that overcorrects well beyond the incentives we might actually want. >Federal spending doesn't come from money laying around, in the first place, it comes from money the government decides to have because it wants to spend it. Even if you buy into the mythology of the fisc, marginal spending comes out of borrowing at, typically, very low interest rates (currently, IIRC, at negative real interest rates), It's true that the federal government can borrow on favorable terms and so it's probably prudent to borrow now for epidemic mitigation -- especially at negative nominal rates! -- but that doesn't make it "myth" that the federal government is not some infinite pot of real resources that will be able to indefinitely cover these expenses; eventually they have to hit a wall. We can debate where that point will be, but it's not mythical. [1] https://www.newsweek.com/baltimore-restaurant-owner-cant-get-employees-return-because-they-make-more-unemployment-1503808 https://www.newsweek.com/baltimore-restaurant-owner-cant-get... [2] Even on HN, it was like pulling teeth just to suggest this was a real effect to worry about; see this thread where I tried to point out the effect: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22640082 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22640082
- Spooky23 6y agoThat’s a factor, but not the primary. Remember that PUA applies to normally disqualified workers like gig economy and 1099 workers. No processes exist to process and monitor wage data for these workers. (By design, there’s a reason why Uber, etc uses “contractors”) With normal employees state labor departments have near real time monitoring of employer tax filings and can recapture fraudulent benefits. States administer the programs, and their ability to pivot their systems ranges from “meh” to “lol”. End of the day, the moral hazard of letting people pay rent is pretty minor compared to the benefit of getting aid available quickly, etc. Ironically the people in congress worried about the morality of this were/are fighting to keep direct payments to companies secret.
- dkersten 6y ago> She was making more money not working. This has actually often been the case I live, because the social welfare system gas a cut off threshold rather than a sliding scale, so if you have, for example, commute or child minding costs, you can easily make less net than you’d get if you stay on social welfare (for minimum wage to low paying jobs), so there isn’t much incentive for unemployed to seek those jobs. I personally know people who gave up on trying to work because they ended up with only €10 or €20 more per week, while being away from their children.
- femiagbabiaka 6y agoThat was an extremely good thing actually, because it incentivized more people to stay home knowing that they could be financially secure. Slowing the spread of COVID is the goal. Prioritizing means testing in this situation out of some sort of sense of pragmatism is deeply twisted.
- jellicle 6y ago> assuming that our government has enough money lying around to pay everyone this much all of the time (we don’t, this is actually very expensive for the taxpayers). If you want to learn more about why this statement is completely wrong, read Stephanie Kelton's new book. Even based on your own assumptions about "paying for it", the COVID unemployment increases/extensions have a negative cost, meaning they saved Americans more money than they cost. Thanks, Keynes.
- dicomdan 6y agoIt wasn't that complicated to index it to salary, there was an amendment proposed but Bernie threw a tantrum and it got rejected. Meanwhile European nations have suffered much lower unemployment because governments decided to subsidize salaries instead of paying people to stay off payroll, the former being a non-starter in the US given the current House composition.
- skwb 6y agoIt's not a bug but a feature! It wasn't just that the policy debating was rushed (it was), but it was also that precisely calculating how much you "should" earn is actually a really hard thing to do. Do you use this years tax return? What if they haven't filed it yet? Maybe last years? Well what about tipped income? What about seasonal workers? What about people who do not typically qualify for unemployment? etc etc etc. Frankly, it's just easier (from as administrative stance) to sorta throw money at the problem, and sorta hope it all washes out in the end. And since many states are reimposing shut down, it seems prudent to extend enhanced UI for the time being (at least until we're able to safely reopen). People like to bash against the US for "only" giving a one time payment of $1,200, but to ignore enhanced UI as part of the stimulus is intellectually dishonest. Will this policy cost us? Sure it will! It will likely mean higher taxes (and not just on wealthy people, but certainly they're the place to start) to maintain a stable GDP/debt ratio in the future. But the cost of not doing so and tanking the US economy is almost certainly worth it.
- ilyagr 6y agoThe humane solution would be to give additional money to underpaid essential workers, at least during the pandemic, rather than to give unemployed people less. That's the point of the article.
- gdubs 6y agoIf there were ever a time to spend, this is it. If people didn’t have to worry about being made whole for the duration of the lockdown, we could have locked down sooner, and much harder, and stood a chance at cutting this thing off at the knees. Instead, we’ve dithered, and the long term economic damage is looking far greater.
- microcolonel 6y agoThe biggest problem with the check was means testing. The U.S. has extremely progressive income taxes, there's nothing wrong with sending the same amount of money to everyone, and it would solve all of the problems except the one where you have to finally explain how taxes are calculated to the public.