5 ms·
Confused: OP says the service was taken down. That seems the most significant part of this action, even beyond the criminal arrests. Is an encrypted communicati
by JoeAltmaier 6y ago
Confused: OP says the service was taken down. That seems the most significant part of this action, even beyond the criminal arrests. Is an encrypted communications company liable/responsible if criminals use their product? Surely there were many, many legitimate users e.g. lawyers, business negotiators, lovers. Can the 'bad apples' be laid on the communication company's doorstep? If so, why not Facebook, Zoom or even Apple?
Why is HN not addressing this point? Instead of speculating about criminal activities etc.
- bladegash 6y agoIt’s hard to say. At least in the U.S., there has been some precedent relatively recently where companies knowingly facilitating criminal activity can be subject to prosecution. They could probably argue that they didn’t have access to the the contents of communications so they were unaware of the criminal activities. However, they (it’s unclear if it was resellers or the company doing this) actively marketed to criminals, via ad placements on websites known to be used for criminal activity. Needless to say, it’s a pretty complicated situation in terms of liability.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoSee? The websites "known to be used for criminal activity" we ok somehow, but not this company. Were the ISP or site hosting organizations shut down? Why not? And selling communications equipment to a criminal - maybe they wanted to talk to their sweetie without being monitored. They also bought a bagel and took a taxi ride. Is the bagel store shut down too? The taxi company? There's lots to talk about here.
- bladegash 6y agoI think there needs to be a certain level of reasonableness when tracing back liability. I mean, why stop at the ISPs? Why not take it all the way up to RIPE for allocating IPs to the company? Or how about the telecommunication companies that used government allocated RF spectrum to facilitate the communications. In that case, the telecoms and the Government(s) themselves should be liable. As for people wanting to talk to their sweetie without being monitored, I believe authorities have already said people who were using the services for legitimate purposes may request to have their communications excluded from any legal proceedings and naturally, won't be prosecuted just for using the devices.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoYes, of course, the criminal side is well understood. Except, of course, the massive wiretapping without a warrant part. Gun sellers have been pretty safe from prosecution for selling a gun that gets used in a crime. Why not encrypted communications companies? That's the distinction I wonder about. (Hopefully using the 'g' word wont further derail the conversation)
- bladegash 6y agoYeah, I get where you’re coming from. So the case I was referring to earlier as a recent example, was Backpage. I think there are some key elements that need to be met, but you can see with that case where lines can be crossed. I’m not arguing encrypted communication companies should be liable for all activities using their service. However, if a company specifically markets to criminals, in my mind, that gets really close to crossing a line. I think it’s the difference between facilitation and knowingly facilitating. With the gun store example, if the person purchasing the weapon said “I’m going to go kill someone, can you tell me which gun would be best for that?”, the gun store would be absolutely liable if they sold them the gun.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoGun stores have expertise in 'personal protection' weapons. They sell guns to people all the time with the express intention of being easiest to use and the most fatal. I'd say, marketing to criminals seems pretty close to the line, but depending on the conversation its no closer than the 'personal protection' sale? As long as they're not advocating "use this to break laws", they're just selling privacy. Like selling a fence for your yard or padlocks for your house. No natural illegal nature to those sales. Even if they ultimately get used to conceal crimes etc.
- JoeSmithson 6y agoThe company took it down themselves
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoYeah that sounds un-coerced. Governments of every European Union nation coming down on them.
- JoeSmithson 6y agoIt was because they were compromised. How could they stay in business at that point? Here's the message they sent to all their users telling them to destroy their devices; https://mobile.twitter.com/aglongo/status/1275766945510559749 https://mobile.twitter.com/aglongo/status/127576694551055974... https://www.vice.com/amp/en_us/article/5dz9qx/encrochat-hacked-shutting-down-encrypted-phone https://www.vice.com/amp/en_us/article/5dz9qx/encrochat-hack... > "We have been forced to make the difficult decision to shut down our service and our business permanently," the person wrote in an email to Motherboard. "This [sic] following several attacks carried out by a foreign organization that seems to originate in the UK." Both of these are from before the authorities went public today
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoPermanently? Just change the encryption. Something fishy?
- JoeSmithson 6y agoTheir credibility was shot, though, who would buy from them again? They just told everyone they were completely pwned.