6 ms·
I don't think he meant to be so offensive. He may just not realize how hard this problem is. The fact is, finding a perfect solution for taking care of small c
by pg 18y ago
I don't think he meant to be so offensive. He may just not realize how hard this problem is.
The fact is, finding a perfect solution for taking care of small children in an industrial society is probably an insoluble problem. And if so it's not one you can solve before having kids, or after them.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- davidw 18y ago> I don't think he meant to be so offensive. Looking at it again, I hope that he wrote quickly without really thinking about what his words meant.
- xlnt 18y agoYou still haven't thought about what his words meant. You said you were facing a certain problem "now", 2 months after the child was born. You could have made your decision about how to handle it prior to the child being born. If you'd done that, you would not be facing the problem now, it would be decided. But you didn't. He asked about why you didn't decide in advance. You got offended by the implication that you hadn't decided in advance. That was something you said yourself, so it's unreasonable to be offended by it, or to blame him for noticing you said it.
- ph0rque 18y agoDo you have any kids? Do you realize how unpredictable it is to plan things for your child, for example, how sick the child is going to be, or how well-tempered?
- xlnt 18y agoMy post is simply about logic and who said what. Nothing more. Why can't you read it rationally? And, BTW, if you and other parents can't read it rationally, why should I believe you handle parenting matters rationally? Parenting matters are more difficult and more emotional than reading a simple forum post.
- pg 18y agoHere is the rational answer you seem to want. (a) This problem is so hard you can probably never solve it satisfactorily, and (b) you can't know what it's going to be like to have kids before you have them, or what your kids will be like. So however much thought you expend on the question before having kids, you're still going to be working on it afterward.
- xlnt 18y agoI didn't argue with that, or ask for an answer of that type, or say that davidw did anything wrong other than misread lisper's post. I thought the waterfall development link basically answered the question about advanced planning. I'm mostly interested in the emotional fragility of parents and wanted to see what would happen if I pointed out that logic does not back up his reaction.
- lurkage 18y ago"I'm mostly interested in the emotional fragility of parents and wanted to see what would happen if I pointed out that logic does not back up his reaction." = trolling
- xlnt 18y agoThe form of my post was to make correct, logical points. That is not trolling. The fact I had an honorable motivation -- learning -- does not suddenly make my posts worse.
- gruseom 18y agoxlnt isn't a troll. He just operates within a zone of disembodied rationality so robotic as to make Spock look like Oprah. Can I have my DH rating now? :)
- xlnt 18y agoHeh. Someone else told me today that I use "a lot of very emotive language" like a "preacher".