4 ms·
> You would need to make real, deep friendships with high status individuals over a long period of time This is backwards - in order to see how people treat pe
by chrisseaton 6y ago
> You would need to make real, deep friendships with high status individuals over a long period of time
This is backwards - in order to see how people treat people based on their profession, you can't make friends with them... because then they aren't judging you on your profession any more, are they?
If the exact same person is treated in two different ways, and absolutely nothing changes except their profession, then the profession is the only possible cause of the difference.
You try it! Go into an environment presenting with one profession, then another, and see the difference! Book into a hotel describing yourself as 'doctor' and you'll get treated differently than when you book in as 'mister'. You can try it yourself and it's plainly obvious that society sees a difference.
> it's not truly high status
I think you're possibly lost track of where this started - I said A was lower than the B. You're trying to argue with me that B isn't the highest, but I never said that - you're arguing against something nobody said in the first place.
- yowlingcat 6y ago> This is backwards - in order to see how people treat people based on their profession, you can't make friends with them... because then they aren't judging you on your profession any more, are they? > I think you're possibly lost track of where this started - I said A was lower than the B I think you're unintentionally making my point for me. You may be missing the limitations of your singular example, and the archetype to which it belongs. The reason you think that your vocation has anything to do with it is because you lack charisma to such a degree that the miniscule surface level that vocation affects how you are perceived has a significant effect on how how you perceive others to perceive you. You don't seem to understand that there are people out there who are extremely well off and very charming and who can make friends with anyone within half an hour such that whatever their profession is simply does not matter. Vocation is optional for them. The world is a playground for their charisma. Would they play alone? Of course not. The world is a playground for many with charisma, resources or not. For you, the much more likely scenario is that your example is a common scenario for those that lack charisma, often those whose identity can be reduced to their vocation. But this is obviously not universal. For you to say A is lower than B when for all intents and purposes both your A(x) and B(x) are lower than either my A(y) and B(y) doesn't mean that A < B or A > B -- it could easily mean that x << y and that A(z) = z and B(z) = z. And if that were the case, you would never know unless you broadened your sample, and quite frankly, your viewpoint for how things work for others. Is charisma highly variable within members of a vocation and within the general population? I would say yes, and trivially so.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> you lack charisma to such a degree Not sure why you've decided to turn this into such a weird personal attack against the character of someone you've never met! Pretty sure you're just trolling for effect so I'll just flag you and leave you to it.
- yowlingcat 6y ago> Not sure why you've decided to turn this into such a weird personal attack against the character of someone you've never met! > Pretty sure you're just trolling for effect so I'll just flag you and leave you to it. It isn't a personal attack, it's just the truth. The fact that you think that social status is something you can conduct "experiments" against by presenting as one vocation or another, and not something that is the gradual accumulation of a lifetime of personal experiences, indicates that you don't really understand how social interactions work and so you are trying to simulate that using a rationalist, scientific method. But, this is a flawed approach, because it doesn't obviate but rather magnifies the observer bias -- you. The problem for people like you is that you believe that your struggles with social status are generic (vocation based) rather than individualized (you). But the more likely case is that you are in a vocation that tends to attract people who have difficulties with social status. This is the same line of reasoning that people who self identify as "involuntarily celibate" take. It's a misattribution of cause and effect. You overindex on surface level factors (such as vocation) rather than on deeper factors (personality, charisma). Most importantly, there's a "schroedingers cat" type effect where your belief that your vocation negatively impacts your social status becomes a self fulfilling prophecy -- indeed, people will be reluctant to want to associate with /anyone/ who thinks that they are treated poorly on account of their vocation, because these kinds of people have a victomhood mentality that almost ensures they will project personal issues onto purported external factors! You can go ahead and flag me if you want, but I think the idea you are espousing is really seductive and dangerous, and more common than I would like. Worst of all, it can seem accurate because it's a self fulfilling prophecy, as I indicated above. And that's why I feel the need to speak out against it -- I don't want other in technology to fall further into that trap. If you feel you are lower status because of your vocation in technology, there are enough counterexamples available of it being vocation based that you ought to be able to reconsider whether that is the case. If not, I think you have some personal problems you need to work on.