6 ms·
Gutenberg doesn't include a fairly important piece of context - these are the practical, battle-tested & known-to-work rules on how to actually run a democracy
by roenxi 6y ago
Gutenberg doesn't include a fairly important piece of context - these are the practical, battle-tested & known-to-work rules on how to actually run a democracy with diametrically opposed competing interests.
I'm not sure what the Indian government uses but I suspect Robert's Rules are state of the art.
Similar to First Past the Post voting where there are probably some easy wins tweaks that could be made based on the current academic literature - but the sheer number of popular "sound good, don't work" ideas floating around make change highly risky because it will have to run the political process and still be a good idea when it makes it through. In practice everyone wants their pet topic to be able to bypass normal procedure.
- DennisP 6y agoI've been in a lot of well-run Roberts meetings, ranging from a dozen to a thousand people. People who didn't get their way always felt they'd had a fair shot at it. I was also in a "consensus-based" meeting with a couple dozen people. It was dominated by one person who just kept insisting on getting their way, until everybody else got tired and "agreed."
- lliamander 6y ago> I was also in a "consensus-based" meeting with a couple dozen people. It was dominated by one person who just kept insisting on getting their way, until everybody else got tired and "agreed." Sounds like a manifestation of Nassim Taleb's "Dictatorship of the Small [Intransigent] Minority"[1] [1]https://medium.com/incerto/the-most-intolerant-wins-the-dictatorship-of-the-small-minority-3f1f83ce4e15#.z5ry4bucq https://medium.com/incerto/the-most-intolerant-wins-the-dict...
- 082349872349872 6y agoA game-theoretic problem with positive sum games (as opposed to zero sum) is that apart from obvious focal points, there's no objective way to split the positivity of the payoff. I've been brought up to "always leave something on the table", but I understand that other societies hold the opposite.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoRRO is used for the US Congress. That may be why it was developed. It is far from perfect, but I feel it works. I have been in many RRO meetings, and a few "CBDM" meetings. I worked for a Japanese corporation for a long time, and saw their consensus system, which was painful, but worked. It was completely different from the "CBDM" meetings I've attended. I once wrote up a very complete presentation and paper on real CBDM, but no one was ever interested in learning about it. In my experience, most CBDM meetings aren't actually designed for "consensus." They are designed to let "the people that matter" accelerate the process of getting what they want.
- bo1024 6y agoLink to your CBDM stuff?
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoI can send you a DropBox link, but I won't publish it here. Send me an email (See my HN profile). It's pretty damn complete. It's actually a multi-hour class.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoWell... that was fun. Downright nerdy as heck. Seems like folks leveraged most of my contact options. If I missed anyone, let me know.
- toomim 6y agoHow does the IETF's process compare? They famously run on "rough consensus."
- Animats 6y agoRRO is used for the US Congress. That may be why it was developed. The US House of Representatives uses a set of rules based on Jefferson's Manual. Bill flow is a bit different than Roberts Rules of Order, but the concepts are very similar.
- Yhippa 6y agoI second this. I've been a part of board meetings where I'm impressed how efficient and timely things can get if you use these rules.
- 082349872349872 6y agoMy impression of the reason consensus works for the Society of Friends is that they don't get tired, but rely on "seasoning", being willing to take time, over several meetings if necessary, to find unity.
- C1sc0cat 6y agoReminds me of a friend who at Uni who went to FCS (federation of conservative students) meetings that where run like this. Dominated by "drunken yahoos" was her comment, I believe this is where Guido Fawkes cut his teeth.
- someguyorother 6y ago>I was also in a "consensus-based" meeting with a couple dozen people. It was dominated by one person who just kept insisting on getting their way, until everybody else got tired and "agreed." I heard somewhere about a variant that would be interesting to try: everyone specifies a favorite option and a consensus option. If the consensus option eventually attains a supermajority, it wins, otherwise you choose a member at random and his/her favorite option wins. Because random is fair but usually bad, there's an incentive to reach a consensus. Anyone who blocks the discussion is gambling with the risk of getting a bad favorite option. You could probably fix the most egregious risks by say choosing at random from the options that a supermajority don't object to. (E.g. choose an option at random, if a supermajority has marked "definitely not this", then loop to the beginning and pick another one at random.)
- washadjeffmad 6y agoOne of our presidents over a pool of largely self interested and disparately oriented divisions has a similar tactic. When they have a big decision to make, he puts the division heads in a room, says "so, what are we going to do?", lets them bluff and bicker in their usual way, and then proposes in all seriousness the worst possible and least effective way to technically accomplish what has to be done. It's a gift, really. It's effectiveness in unifying them through their desperation to make sure it never comes to pass is unparalleled. He also had those same people give each other researched introductions to his leadership, which is every bit as brilliant and trollish as it sounds.
- tunesmith 6y agoSorry, I am having trouble understanding the point in your final paragraph - are you saying that there are probably some tweaks that could be made to Robert's Rules, or are you saying the Rules protect against tweaks that might end up harmful?
- lliamander 6y agoI think the suggestion is that Robert's Rules have actually the result of a bunch of previously tweaking, have been tested, and are shown to be safe to implement. On the other hand, many other decision making procedures (such as many alternatives to the U.S. first-past-the-post voting schemes for elections) might sound good in theory, but in practice could fail utterly.
- n4r9 6y agoSurely this is more about parliamentary process which is somewhat independent of the voting scheme? How do you even measure the success of a voting scheme? Most modern democracies use a form of proportional representation these days. This is particularly true in Europe, where most countries also score higher than the US on the Democracy Index: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democracy_Index https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democracy_Index . Even in the US, non-FPTP voting is starting to happen here and there. San Fran's mayoral elections used a ranked choice system if I'm not mistaken.
- Camillo 6y agoHaving a dominant two-party system is counted as a demerit in the democracy index scoring rules, so that is almost a tautology. See item 10 here: https://www.transparency.org.nz/docs/2017/Democracy_Index_2016.pdf https://www.transparency.org.nz/docs/2017/Democracy_Index_20... Item 14 is pretty interesting too. "Is the legislature the supreme political body, with a clear supremacy over other branches of government?" That's probably a no for the US, but who knows. The "experts" who make the determination are not revealed, so the whole index is really based on trusting what The Economist says. Item 18, "Do special economic, religious or other powerful domestic groups exercise significant political power, parallel to democratic institutions?". I can't imagine how that can be fairly scored: the only realistic possibility is that the "experts" vote on how much they like the interest groups in this or that country. There are lots of items like that. Even if they make sense for a democracy index, you can easily see how different people might give completely different answers. In item 40, "Alternatively, % of people who think that punishing criminals is an essential characteristic of democracy", where you get the full score if that is over 80%. Wouldn't most people say that punishing criminals is an essential function of _any_ government, not having anything to do with democracy in particular? On the other hand, many dislike the very notion of punishment. In the US, this waxes and wanes; does the country really become more democratic during the "tough on crime" phases of the cycle? The index seems to say so!
- Animats 6y agoThe whole point of Roberts Rules of Order is that the membership is in charge. Motions, after being discussed and amended, eventually come down to a vote of the group. That's the basic mechanism of democracy. Most nonprofit membership organizations in the US were run that way at one time. But since the 1960s, there are more self-perpetuating boards and other schemes for taking control away from the members. So people don't get practice at running a democracy. Which is a problem.
- DanBC 6y ago> the membership is in charge. Motions, after being discussed and amended, eventually come down to a vote of the group Strictly speaking, this could be a subset of the group, so long as that subset is quorate. For some groups this quorate level is going to be a surprisingly small number of people.