12 ms·
Someone with a full-time job making $10 an hour (1) makes about the same minimum wage as France; (2) is either eligible for Medicaid or pays $67/month for healt
by rayiner 6y ago
Someone with a full-time job making $10 an hour (1) makes about the same minimum wage as France; (2) is either eligible for Medicaid or pays $67/month for healthcare through an ACA exchange; (3) pays almost nothing in taxes. It’s definitely a livable salary for a young person in a low cost of living area. (Half of people who make under $10 an hour are 18-30.)
Where I live, an hour outside DC and maybe 30 minutes to Baltimore, you can get a 2BR apartment in a nice new building for $1,000 per month. Share that with someone, and a person making $1,500 is spending the recommended 1/3 on rent. $67/month for healthcare on an ACA silver plan, and that leaves $900/month, which is totally doable for a single person, or better yet each half of a young married couple. And frankly, around here you’d get $15/hour just working checkout. In places that have a significant number of $10/hour jobs, rent is something you spend a few hundred a month on. You can eat at a sit down place for under $10.
- taurath 6y agoAn ACA silver plan means you have a $4500 deductible. You will NEVER go to a doctor. You will also not have sick leave, and if you don't show up for your randomly timed work shift you will be fired. Thats if you get hours in the first place. So you pay your $500 for rent. Add 150 for utilities. Add 200 for gas and 50 for car insurance since you're gonna be living in a rural place. Thats 900 for a roof and ability to pay for it. Now you have $600 a month for food and literally any other expense. Say you never eat out and use staples like rice and beans as the basis for every dish, thats $250 a month (maybe you can squeeze out another $50, but one must have a slight bit of slack for say, a single gallon of ice cream per month). $350 for everything else. Entertainment. A gym membership. Your medical deductible. Your sanity.
- yellowapple 6y agoSo to put the below in context: my first job (at the tail end of the last recession) paid around $12-13 an hour, and was enough to survive with more than double that rent figure. Granted, I had a couple factors on my side (namely: my grandparents in the next town over, who would insist on stocking my fridge and cupboards with the essentials), but even if I hadn't it was workable, even if not comfortable. I also didn't pay for health insurance at the time (I wasn't eligible for work-provided insurance until shortly before I switched jobs), since I think this was right before the ACA's individual mandate made it "mandatory". That all being to say: $10/hr full time does not in the slightest bit seem unreasonable to me, even if I do strongly believe that workers deserve better than that. ---- > Add 200 for gas and 50 for car insurance since you're gonna be living in a rural place. Or a bike, which is a thing, that people ride to and from work, even in "rural" areas. No gas and no insurance, even for an electric one (and those have come down quite a bit in price, to the point where the only cheaper cars are absolute beaters). Even "rural" cities/towns often have buses, too. They don't always have the most exhaustive coverage, but bikes can make up for that for the "last mile" of each way's commute (especially if the bus has a bike rack on it, which is becoming increasingly common for exactly this reason and because it's relatively cheap compared to the cost of the bus itself). > $350 for everything else. Entertainment. A gym membership. Your medical deductible. Your sanity. You don't need a gym membership to work out (as I'm sure most of us trying to get even basic fitness in can attest over the last couple months, what with all those gyms being shut down). Jogging, hiking, bicycling, pushups, planks, jumping jacks, shovelgloving¹... all dirt cheap to do (if you don't go overboard and splurge on fancy bikes or backpacks or whatever; the basics will work fine). If you happen to live in a snowy area, snow shoveling is a good workout, too, and helps out your neighbors (you might even get paid for it). All of those things can double for entertainment and "sanity", too, so that just leaves the medical deductible. That $350 would give you enough savings to cover that deductible in a bit over a year (even faster if you throw in the aforementioned $250 you'd be saving without a car). Anything past that is pure savings, enough to eventually buy a used car for the occasional out-of-town trip, or to eat out every once in awhile, or what have you. ---- ¹: http://shovelglove.com/ http://shovelglove.com/
- maaarghk 6y agoRead the word "granted" and disregarded the rest of the post. Trying to pass off your experience as some kind of canonical working class struggle when you don't need to pay for food is about as tone deaf as it gets, not to mention starting it with "to put that into context" as if you have ANY idea what that context is. I can tell you're just like "well, the poors can just ride bikes" having never ridden one yourself, otherwise you would know that a bike that you could cycle a 40km to 60km round commute on in a rural area is gonna set you back $2k and you won't get finance on it the way you do with a car, not to mention the fact that the cycling clothes you would need to buy to cover rural distances are mostly in the designer category and therefore very expensive. Not to mention your mechanical service, which if you're commuting daily is probably $80 every six months plus any parts which wear out, $15 for brake pads, $5 every time you puncture any wheel, $60 for new tyres every year, and the occasional unexpected uninsurable $200 "bottom bracket, crank and chainring all wore out at once" repair.
- rayiner 6y ago> Read the word "granted" and disregarded the rest of the post. Trying to pass off your experience as some kind of canonical working class struggle when you don't need to pay for food is about as tone deaf as it gets, not to mention starting it with "to put that into context" as if you have ANY idea what that context is. No, you’re the one lacking context. Most low wage workers are young, and the median American lives 18 miles away from their mom. People making $10/hour living on their own for the first time who have parents or grandparents randomly drop by with food is a very common scenario. People making $10/hour trying to support a family is not. Also, the notion of biking 60 km round trip in rural areas strongly suggests you’ve never been to one. Someone working a $10 service job in a rural county isn’t commuting 30 km each way. My wife grew up in Sibley, Iowa. It’s about a mile and a half across North to south, and less than that East to west. The apartments are all in town, and so are the stores. The people who might need to commute longer are farmers and farm hands, but they make a lot more money. The average farm hand in Iowa with a high school education or less makes $30-40k/year: https://www.extension.iastate.edu/agdm/wholefarm/html/c1-60.html https://www.extension.iastate.edu/agdm/wholefarm/html/c1-60.... (The hours are long, so it works out to $12-15/hour.) They’re not riding bikes.
- swiley 6y ago>50 for car insurance since you're gonna be living in a rural place. Thats 900 for a roof and ability to pay for it. Someone in this situation is not paying cash for a car so there's probably $100-$200 for a car loan on top of that.
- threatofrain 6y agoAlso small employers are generally exempt from contributing to programs that help with employee healthcare or insurance.
- zaroth 6y agoThere’s another level of subsidies called cost sharing reductions which bring the deductible/out-of-pocket expenses down as your income is reduced. At 150% FPL the Silver plan deductible falls from about $7,000 to $250, and your maximum annual out-of-pocket expenses falls from $7,300 to $550. At some point you hit full-on Medicaid which is, depending on the state, truly excellent insurance and totally free.
- tigershark 6y agoAlmost 4 litres of ice cream per month? Every month? And someone wonders why there are so many type 2 diabetes cases...
- ryanwaggoner 6y agoThat’s about 250 calories per day, which is pretty reasonable for a daily treat. And I actually looked it up and it’s about a half gallon per American per month. I wonder if that includes children too. Probably. And then factor in the mountains of other garbage we also eat...it’s honestly a miracle that we’re not more obese than we are.
- taurath 6y agoForgot how big a regular thing of ice cream was :p
- jacobolus 6y ago1 gallon/month is 1 scoop of ice cream each on 5 or 6 days per week, or on average about 12–15 grams of sugar per day. It’s about the same amount of sugar you’d get from drinking one 12 oz can of soda every third day. If it’s the only sugary treat someone is eating, that’s still well below average for people in most industrialized countries. If combined with soda/candy/cake/cookies/cocktails/... then probably not such a good idea.
- r00fus 6y agoI presume this is for a family of 2-4; in that case it's arguably not much at all.
- bhupy 6y agoHigh deductible just means that you have to pay upfront for preventive care — like flu shots, bacterial checkups, and annual physicals. We pay out of pocket for tons of things, like food, clothing, and utilities. Insofar as this is undesirable, it's probably because the pricing system is impaired. If you have a financially ruinous healthcare event, the ACA silver plan saves you — that's the whole point of insurance.
- brianwawok 6y agoAnnual physicals and flu shots are generally (possible ACA mandate?) free with no deductible. Maybe bad example choices?
- bhupy 6y agoThat's all the more reason why the higher deductible isn't inherently a bad thing, even most of the basic needs are covered. Outside of that, it's just catastrophic coverage, just like car insurance.
- taurath 6y agoNo it doesn’t. If you go in with a cold, they check your temperature and give you some Tylenol you get charged $600 out of your pocket, until you meet the deductible. It’s the preventative care stuff that is /sometimes/ not counting against the deductible. Also literally any surgery is a financially ruinous healthcare event insured or not until you’re rich relative to the average person - I have the receipts of the tens of thousands of dollars of medical bills I’ve had to pay while insured to prove it.
- rayiner 6y ago> An ACA silver plan means you have a $4500 deductible. You will NEVER go to a doctor. Silver plans are eligible for Cost Sharing Reduction (reducing deductibles to $500-1,000), and pay for doctor’s visits before deductibles kick in. And preventative care has no co-pay and no deductible. > So you pay your $500 for rent. Add 150 for utilities. Add 200 for gas and 50 for car insurance since you're gonna be living in a rural place. How much do you think gas costs in Iowa? The median rural/town commuter travels about 1,150 miles per month. A 2000 Honda Civic gets 27 mpg. At $2/gallon for around 40 gallons a month, that’s under half your estimate. > Now you have $600 a month for food and literally any other expense. Say you never eat out and use staples like rice and beans as the basis for every dish, thats $250 a month (maybe you can squeeze out another $50, but one must have a slight bit of slack for say, a single gallon of ice cream per month). You are out of touch if you think $250 per month is a “rice and beans” food budget for a single person: https://mymoneywizard.com/how-i-spend-less-than-35-a-week-on-groceries-my-full-shopping-list-exposed https://mymoneywizard.com/how-i-spend-less-than-35-a-week-on... ($67 per week for two people). A weekly trip to Aldi for my family of five clocks in at about $100, and we don’t even try to save money. > $350 for everything else. Entertainment. A gym membership. Your medical deductible. Your sanity. In central Illinois, you can have a sit-down meal for $10, less if ethnic food. Coffee is a buck. The Y near my house is $40/month for a very nice place with heated indoor pool, and making minimum wage you qualify for financial aid. The county one, which is also nice, is $25/month. Netflix is $13/month. A Verizon MVNO is $35/month. In Iowa City, you can get $1-2 well drinks four days a week: https://www.brothersbar.com/iowacity https://www.brothersbar.com/iowacity.
- taurath 6y ago> Silver plans are eligible for Cost Sharing Reduction (reducing deductibles to $500-1,000), and pay for doctor’s visits before deductibles kick in You’re right about the deductible - after doing the math I saw that youd qualify for the 150->400% bracket of the federal poverty level. But can you afford 3 weeks pay for that $750 deductible? On top of other stuff? > You are out of touch if you think $250 per month is a “rice and beans” food budget for a single person I didn't say it was only rice and beans, but a cheap diet consisting of the cheapest carbs. The USDA has it around $180 as the absolute cheapest per person. Your money wizard person lives in the cheapest area of the country. I'll bet they have a stocked kitchen as well so they never need to buy spices. https://fns-prod.azureedge.net/sites/default/files/media/file/CostofFoodMay2020.pdf https://fns-prod.azureedge.net/sites/default/files/media/fil... > In central Illinois Having been thru Normal/Bloomington and Champaign, it’s extremely reasonable in price as rentals are dirt cheap, as long as you’re going to aldi. $1-2 well drinks aren’t a thing in a lot of the country. Coffee isn’t a dollar since the 90s. Your original example was between DC and baltimore. Things aren't so cheap there. Oh, and I forgot about the actual premium cost of the silver plan, which is around $200 per month. Sorry, but you're going into debt or homelessness the second your hours get cut. You have no stability. The smallest thing going wrong will ruin you. Have you seen the absolute hordes of people going into just APPLY for section 8? https://youtu.be/Q5ocjZ9GatA?t=140 https://youtu.be/Q5ocjZ9GatA?t=140
- newacct583 6y ago> Someone with a full-time job making $10 an hour Virtually no one who works jobs at $10 an hour works full time reliably. These aren't career-style 9-5 regular positions, they're ad-hoc shift work. At best, someone like this works several part time jobs whose hours add up to 40/week on average. In general people in this income bracket end up hopping between jobs and dealing with dry spells where they can't find work. Which is what the linked article is about. Your numbers are frankly just delusional. I mean, yes, if we had a program that could actually guarantee a regular $400/week income to someone, they could live on that reasonably comfortably in most of the US. But just "having a job" doesn't qualify, not remotely.
- coliveira 6y agoNot only that, but these jobs have no benefits. The person subject to this needs to pay out of pocket for insurance (Obamacare helped a little, but it is still an added cost). It is basically indented servitude, and if the person is not willing to do this he/she may end up homeless or in jail for some stupid reason.
- pphysch 6y ago(1) - What is the point of this comparison? (2) - Different discussion -- let's assume for sake of argument we are talking about a young healthy person anyways. (3) - Sales tax is "almost nothing"? With respect, this reply is coming off as completely out of touch with someone who can barely afford rent, food, gas and the many "poor taxes".
- ciarannolan 6y agoI agree that "It’s definitely a livable salary for a young person in a low cost of living area." is a laughable claim. But, it is true that most Americans pay very little taxes. > According to the Tax Foundation, the top 50% of taxpayers paid 96.96% of all federal income taxes in 2016, the last tax year for which comprehensive and vetted statistics are available from the Internal Revenue Service. This means that the bottom 50% paid just 3.04%. [1] And yes, sales tax is "almost nothing". About 2-3% of an average American household's total income. > With that in mind, the average American pays $10,489 in "personal taxes," representing 14% of the average household's total income. This includes federal and state income taxes, as well as other taxes such as personal property taxes, vehicle taxes, and certain other small taxes. $8,367 of this amount is federal income taxes, $2,046 is state and local taxes, and $75 is other small taxes. [2] [1] https://www.thebalance.com/what-the-average-american-pays-in-taxes-4768594 https://www.thebalance.com/what-the-average-american-pays-in... [2] https://www.fool.com/taxes/2018/04/22/how-much-does-the-average-american-pay-in-taxes.aspx https://www.fool.com/taxes/2018/04/22/how-much-does-the-aver...
- pphysch 6y agoI agree with your points--my point is that any % of someone's wealth who _can_barely_afford_basic_living_costs_ is significant. Income tax isn't even remotely on someone's mind who can't make ends meet. Sales tax _is_ neglible for most wealthy people so it is easy for them to forget about it and massively overrate the impact of income tax on non-wealthy people.
- ciarannolan 6y agoIf you can barely make ends meet, you do not pay income taxes in America. In fact, you get free money from the federal government once a year via the standard deduction rather than paying them. If you're scraping by on, say, $500/month after rent is paid, $10 of that on sales taxes is insignificant imo.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- bigbob2 6y agoI used to make $9 an hour and was not eligible for Medicaid. ACA exchange in Kentucky (Kynect) wanted well over $100 a month which was not affordable for me, but then again neither was the fee imposed by not having insurance. I paid around 30% of my wages in taxes, which I consider to be quite a lot more than nothing. I was able to live in a very cheap place (with room mates, of course), but not put anything away.
- pkaye 6y ago> 30% of my wages in taxes... That seems a high rate for making $9/hour.
- zaroth 6y agoAt $9/hr you’re getting EIC and the Federal tax rate is probably negative, not positive.
- gamblor956 6y agoThe US does not have a negative federal tax rate, unless you are referring to an effective tax rate (which is the calculated rate you effectively pay based on income, deductions, credits, etc.)
- simonsarris 6y agoThe USA does effectively have a negative tax rate at that level with EITC, that's what he's saying. $9/hr * 2080 hours = $18,720 After deductions that's $6,520 of taxable income. Eligible for EITC so a tax rate of negative $3,526. So if they paid zero federal income tax all year they'd get a "refund" check of $3,526 (except its not a refund, since they paid zero, its a negative tax rate) You can see here: https://www.calculator.net/tax-calculator.html?cfilestatus=Single&callowance=0&callowanceold=0&ctaxyear=2019&csalaryincome=18720&cwithheld=00&csalarystate=0&csalarylocal=0&chasbusiness=no&cbusinessincome=0&cestimatedtax=0&cmedicarewage=0&csalaryincome2=0&cwithheld2=0&csalarystate2=0&csalarylocal2=0&chasbusiness2=no&cbusinessincome2=0&cestimatedtax2=0&cmedicarewage2=0&cinterestincome=0&cordinarydividends=0&cqualifieddividends=0&crentalincome=0&cshortcapitalgain=0&clongcapitalgain=0&cotherincome=0&cstatetaxrate=0&cira=0&csalestax=0&cmortgage=0&cdonations=0&cstudentloan=0&cchildcare=0&ctuition=0&ctuition2=0&ctuition3=0&ctuition4=0&cotherdeductable=0&printit=0&x=53&y=24 https://www.calculator.net/tax-calculator.html?cfilestatus=S...
- ciarannolan 6y agoWhat kind of healthcare do you suppose a person gets for $67/month? What sort of meal do you suppose a person gets at a sit down restaurant for less than $10? How is a young married couple supposed to establish some wealth and make their way in life on $20K/year each? Every day HN amazes me at how completely out of touch some people are. "I make six figures typing on a screen in an air conditioned room all day. Why can't these damn poor people just take their $10/hr and shut up?"
- rayiner 6y ago> What kind of healthcare do you suppose a person gets for $67/month? It's not $67/month healthcare. Its $500/month healthcare that's highly subsidized by the government. You know, like the healthcare in most countries that have "free healthcare." (The ACA is similar to how the Dutch universal healthcare system works.) > What sort of meal do you suppose a person gets at a sit down restaurant for less than $10? Often, a really good one! > How is a young married couple supposed to establish some wealth and make their way in life on $20K/year each? They're not supposed to. They get better jobs, they get promoted, etc. From age 22 to age 38, the 25th percentile individual income (so 75% of people make more than that) triples from $10,000/year to $30,000/year. > Every day HN amazes me at how completely out of touch some people are. "I make six figures typing on a screen in an air conditioned room all day. Why can't these damn poor people just take their $10/hr and shut up?" It's the people earning six figures talking about hypothetical people trying to support a family of four on $10/hour that are completely out of touch. Yes, that's the reality for some people and it's sad. But for every one of those people, there are a bunch of 20-somethings making $10/hour who will move onto something better. People imagine 35 year olds with kids making $10/hour, but that's an outlier. The median household income for people aged 35-44 is $80,000 per year, and for married people that age it's even higher. And remember: that median couple lives in Topeka, not Palo Alto.
- mbrodersen 6y agoI have lived, worked and paid taxes in Denmark, the UK, the USA (Washington D.C.) and Australia. I am absolutely blown away by how out of touch you and others are from the reality of people struggling to survive in the USA compare with other rich nations. Having the intelligence, interest and family support needed to learn how to program is in itself a huge privilege. One that I benefited from myself. However the difference is that I am grateful for it and know how privileged I am. The difference is that I don't use it as a hammer to attack the people who are less fortunate.
- wonderwonder 6y agoYou cannot raise a child on $10 an hour. One might argue then that that person should not have a child, but very often those arguing that are also advocating for a reduction in birth control and against the raising of the minimum wage. Continuing with the French comparison, in France if you have a child you get 16 weeks of maternity leave as well as an 'allowance equal to their average income over the three months preceding the birth'. In France, 80% of childcare is generally covered, in the US its very expensive unless you have a relative that lives nearby that can watch your child. So while you are indeed correct, it is possible to survive on $10 per hour, many states have a minimum wage under $8.00. On the whole I very much agree with you, but it can get very complicated very quickly.
- bhupy 6y ago> but very often those arguing that are also advocating for a reduction in birth control Okay, but "people often have the wrong basket of opinions" isn't a strong counterargument to the central point being discussed. > against the raising if the minimum wage Raising of the minimum wage comes with price increases, which is a regressive way of guaranteeing a minimum standard of living. Expanding the EITC (or better yet a UBI) allows one to raise a child even if they are earning $10/hour.
- folkhack 6y agoEvery time that HN gets talking about poverty and how it's easy to "just budget!" my eyes almost roll out of my head because I'm damn-near certain every one of us here is making enough to support ourselves, or is being setup to support ourselves in the future (ie: school). We're so far removed from the actual experience of what it's like to "pull yourself up by the bootstraps". If you've been around extreme poverty you know how expensive it is to be poor... You're talking jobs that demand overtime to keep the position, old cars breaking down every other month, being more prone to health problems, the cost of education, the real cost of debt, lower COL housing and theft, etc etc. I'll argue that those who are advantageous, responsible, and disciplined can absolutely budget/work themselves into a better situation like OP suggests (ABSOLUTELY without children) - but if you've been around poverty (esp. in America) you know that this type of person is the exception and not the rule. Not disagreeing with anyone - just want to point out that most poor people aren't going to be able to get themselves out of that situation with "just budget!" advice when most of them can't do simple math and/or can barely read... let alone delay instant gratification (drugs/alcohol) for long-term prosperity (positive goals/aspirations). I agree with your comment so much. Thank you for pointing out how quickly OP's "just budget!" advice breaks down..!
- mnm1 6y agoThat's hilarious. That wasn't even a livable wage in 2003. Maybe if you live in the ghetto, where the job is unlikely to be. What a bunch of bullshit.
- deeblering4 6y agoAnd what happens when this young married couple decides to have children?
- gurumeditations 6y agoThat is insanely optimistic. You absolutely cannot live on your own on anything near $10/hr in any low cost area.
- FabHK 6y agoJust wanted to correct (1) - minimum wage in France is 10.15 EUR/h, which (at 2019 PPP of 0.732 [oecd], not market rate) equates to 13.86 USD/h. [oecd] https://data.oecd.org/conversion/purchasing-power-parities-ppp.htm https://data.oecd.org/conversion/purchasing-power-parities-p...
- mbrodersen 6y agoSo are you saying that anybody paid minimum wage in the USA, no matter where they live, can afford food, housing, a car to drive to work etc.? Are you sure you are not talking about a European country and not the USA?