6 ms·
I’ve got a “hot button” about castes. I hate ‘em. Comes from growing up overseas (I live in the US), and having servants. These were the people that raised us
by ChrisMarshallNY 6y ago
I’ve got a “hot button” about castes. I hate ‘em.
Comes from growing up overseas (I live in the US), and having servants.
These were the people that raised us, and were, for all intents and purpose, “family.”
Except they weren’t, and when I found out how they lived, it broke my heart.
I was also raised by a British mother, who was an awesome woman, but came from a middle-class Liverpool (“scouse”) family, and spent her entire early life feeling “not good enough,” despite attending an Ivy-League university, and excelling at her work (http://cmarshall.com/miscellaneous/SheilaMarshall.htm http://cmarshall.com/miscellaneous/SheilaMarshall.htm).
Knowing how she felt also broke my heart.
The British have a heavy-duty caste system that isn’t as codified as India’s, but just as pervasive.
Of course, in the US (and, I believe, in other parts of the world), we are currently facing a reckoning about another type of “caste system.”
There seems to be an innate human need to “just be better” than others. I think we all have it, and have to make a conscious effort to suppress the impulse.
- randomguy2379 6y agoAs someone who was born a lower caste hindu, I don't really mind the british caste system at all. Because the british caste system is fluid. If you are born to servant parents and study hard to become a doctor, you end up at the top of the caste system. Not in Hinduism. Even if you become a doctor, but were born a dalit(lowest caste), you will remain a dalit and so will your future generations. There is no escape from the inhuman hindu caste system.
- piker 6y ago> If you are born to servant parents and study hard to become a doctor, you end up at the top of the caste system. I think this is the opposite of a caste system.
- randomguy2379 6y agoIt's the opposite of the hindu caste system, but pretty much in line with the british caste system where caste is based on profession and not by birth.
- piker 6y agoIt seems you're seeking to define a "British caste system" by reference to the Hindu caste system minus the Hindu caste system's defining feature. You're ending up with something like a meritocracy. It's not clear what point you're making other than "I don't like the Hindu caste system".
- saiya-jin 6y agoWhile I get what you mean, to somebody who spent whole life in pretty egalitarian society it still sounds pretty horrible. You get much better working society overall when this kind of shit isn't there. If whole society prospers, everybody gets the benefits in many ways. I've spent 6 months backpacking all over india in 2008 and 2010, and what I saw there broke my heart many times. The frequent kindness of the poorest folks on top of their misfortunes was very inspiring though
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoGood point, and I appreciate it, but it isn't quite as "fluid" in the UK as it may seem. In the US, yes. In the UK, not so much. We recently had a woman that works for the State Department give testimony, and one of the things she mentioned, in her prepared remarks, was that she came to the US, because she couldn't get a fair shake in the UK, due to her "Northern accent," despite some heavy-duty cred. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L5gmpdtbWB0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L5gmpdtbWB0 The one thing that the Indian caste system has, is something to outlaw. Since it is so codified, there's a specific thing to point to in a law.
- arethuza 6y agoBecoming a doctor does not make you upper class in the UK. You can't really become upper class, at least in the traditional sense - certainly not through a job or money. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_class_in_the_United_Kingdom#Upper_class https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_class_in_the_United_Kin... e.g. David Cameron, Eton educated prime-minister, described himself as middle class. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-25744526 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-25744526 Edit: You could argue that everyone is middle class these days - almost nobody self identifies as working class and there are so few real upper class people (I've never met one). Edit2: Of course, you used to be able to buy entry into the upper class. But that doesn't happen anymore ;-)
- randomguy2379 6y agoA doctor would happily take being middle class rather than being a lowest caste hindu dalit. The fact that someone can advance to middle class makes it vastly different from Hinduism where you and your future generations are doomed to be born in the same caste.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- bluGill 6y agoThe lords system in England buys someone in your family a seat in the house of lords. It might mean you were born born with land that theoretically you have government rights over, but if you take that farther than changing competitive rents you will discover the powers haven't been removed only because it wasn't worth the bother since nobody used them. That is my impression as an outsider anyway. I'm sure the details are different somehow.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoBut I just love watching Parliament in session; especially The Prime Minister's Questions. Those toffs can absolutely shred you, while complimenting you the entire time. It's watching the English language being wielded as a weapon.
- thewindow 6y agoYou seem to have quiet a rosy view of the British class system, but that is not the reality. Money or profession will not just make you higher class here in UK.
- randomguy2379 6y agoMaybe the term that I was looking for was middle class, rather than higher class. I'm just comparing it to Hinduism, where a lowest caste dalit cannot even progress to middle castes even if he becomes a billionaire.
- vishnugupta 6y agoPerhaps you are mixing up “class” with “caste”? Because it’s perfectly possible for a poor lower caste person to climb up the ladder of “class” to be a middle class. It does buy you certain privilege which otherwise wouldn’t be possible. Because money, ad the end of the day, does matter to an extent. Caste on the other hand is an entirely different beast, as you have rightly pointed out.
- naruvimama 6y agoIndian Jatti are more fluid than the European caste system. Any one can be a kings, and Jattis can move. They can have their own temples, gods, priests and kings. European caste system on the other hand is very clear on who is royalty, and who isn't. In fact even today in countries like Denmark, ordinary people are NOT allowed to have royal second names. God is also monopolised by the church and the clergy, until people (the new middle class) started quitting the church. Please do not mistake the progress made due to economic development to social changes, and the other way around.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- garmaine 6y agoUpward mobility is not a British trait. “Upper class” is Britain is something you have to be born into, not something you achieve through making money or education. At least not in this century. Now America in the other hand, we hold greater respect for self-made immigrant success stories than a privileged rich kid spending daddy’s money.
- Lio 6y agoNews Flash: doctor isn't the top of our class system. Even if you become a doctor you still won't be a part of the aristocracy. The best you can do is upper middle class. That might mean you're the head of a FTSE100 company, which is still pretty good but you won't be upper class until the Queen dishes out a knighthood for all great works of charity you'll do. ...and even then though you'll probably still wear the wrong kind of shoes and hold your knife a bit funny at supper.
- randomguy2379 6y agoSorry I am not entirely familiar with the intricacies of the British class system. My point was more about the British class system having upward mobility. Hindu caste system has none. A dalit doctor is still the lowest caste and all of his future generations will also be lowest caste. While poor farmer brahmins will call themselves highest caste.
- Lio 6y agoNo worries at all mate. My post is very tongue in cheek and should be taken lightly. Although I work closely with many people in India I don't understand the caste system at all. So I'm just listening to the rest of the conversation and being informed.
- WhompingWindows 6y agoWhat's to stop any Indian from changing their last name? Are there other sure-fire signs of caste status, other than name?
- cmonnow 6y ago> There is no escape from the inhuman hindu caste system. The Hindu caste system talks about spiritual evolution of the soul as it goes from body to body in each birth. You might be a lower-caste in this birth, but you might get upper-caste birth in a next life. And vice-versa. That's how you escape it.
- ashayh 6y agoPeople taking such myths seriously is the crux of the problem. After all, if you were born low because of your alleged past sins, why should you not suffer in this current life?
- cmonnow 6y ago> People taking such myths seriously Well, atheists don't believe in anything before or after this life. It's usually such people who have no fear of committing crimes when they are confident they won't get caught. > why should you not suffer in this current life? they will suffer. But not because of you or me. But because of reactions to their actions long ago. Does it mean you can ill-treat them without consequence ? No. If you do so, you will be born in that caste in a next-life and suffer the same oppression they're facing now.
- C1sc0cat 6y agoCaste is not the same as Class Discrimination.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoDepends on who is doing the definition. The British system has a lot more to do with who mommy and daddy are, than what the sheepskin says. It's pretty hard for people raised in the US to understand it. We keep looking at it through our lens, and we have a relatively young, egalitarian, culture that started when our continent was used as an overflow for the prison system. A lot of folks in the UK try to get ahead by modifying their speaking patterns and accent. My mother had impeccable English (her mother sounded like she came from Liverpool). She was a scientific editor, and was absolutely brutal. I know. She edited some of my work. I don't think it really got her what she wanted.
- C1sc0cat 6y agoYes but Class discrimination is no where as brutal as Caste discrimination is - you don't get honour killings for marrying the wrong person. Don't take this the wrong way this is your white privilege showing
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoYGBSM. Are you sure that you want this post to stay up? EDIT: I removed the quote of your insult, and simply flagged your post. Let's be adults, here. I'll probably remove this post before the two hours are up.
- pessimizer 6y agoIs mentioning white British privilege over low-caste Indians now a flagging offense?
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y ago> Is mentioning white British privilege over low-caste Indians now a flagging offense? Flat-out, deadly, insults are. It was delivered as an insult. > Don't take this the wrong way this is your white privilege showing I didn't "take it the wrong way." I took it exactly as it was intended. What's ironic, is that the insult was delivered without the person even taking a few minutes to find out a bit more about me. I don't hide anything. It's all there, for you to examine. I understand that this is an emotional issue, which was why I carefully kept all of my responses to my own experience, and never made a value judgement. I'd suggest that you read through all my comments, and point out my insults. If I have inadvertently done so, then I sincerely apologize, and will make any amends possible. I am not Indian, and won't even pretend to understand what Indians of lower caste go through, but I do have some experience in the British system.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoI feel that I need to make a point here. I did not mean to offend anyone. I was simply talking about my experience, in my life, and my outlook. I am very grateful for others sharing their experiences and outlooks, and it has helped me to understand things a bit better. I appreciate it. Really. I understand that this is an emotional topic, and that some people have suffered greatly. But let's not turn this into a flame war. 'K? K.
- hitekker 6y agoYou conflated caste with class. The comments below are a reaction to that false equivalence.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoActually, only one other person (besides you) sank to insults. I've enjoyed the responses, and the responses to responses. I've learned a bit from it. This has been a really good thread, about a topic that has a thousand years of pain behind it.
- hitekker 6y agoI corrected you, not insulted you. Caste and class are similar but not the same. Merging the two concepts into one is useful for generating outrage and maybe for bonding, but less useful for understanding the suffering of one society compared to another.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoHave a great day!