2 ms·
Sure: some of your purchase history definitely indicates behaviors that indicate you're a credit risk. Some of your purchase history indicates you're likely b
by mlyle 6y ago
Sure: some of your purchase history definitely indicates behaviors that indicate you're a credit risk. Some of your purchase history indicates you're likely black (and if you're black, your credit risk is, empirically, a little higher-- even if it is not fair to not issue credit to people because they're black).
ML will figure out both but can't explain the hidden variables: it'll figure out behaviors that directly indicate higher risk, and behaviors that indicate you're a minority that tends to be a higher risk.
- mc32 6y agoIs it too entangled to say disregard anything that leads to a path that makes inferences based on demographics? Although I suppose age is also tough to avoid in assigning risk.
- mlyle 6y agoAlmost anything you'd use is correlated to demographics somehow or another. We tend to think certain systems are "OK" and not too racist, because they have a well-articulated rationale independent of demographics. But ML is not very good at explaining rationale for decisions, so we don't have the benefit of that argument and it's difficult to even empirically understand how biased the system is. This is a hard problem.
- unishark 6y agoBasing your entire decision on something as simple as the applicant's income will presumably produce outcomes that differ with race. Is that what you mean by racist? Or do you mean the system identifies some individuals as high credit risk when they aren't and may actually lose money versus a more colorblind algorithm?
- mlyle 6y agoWhat's racist is squishy. Many people would say that identifying people who spend a lot of money at bars or casinos as a credit risk isn't racist, even if it happens to pick up more minorities. The mechanism for the credit risk and behavior seems tightly correlated. Many people would also say that identifying people who spend some money at clothing retailers that market to minorities as a credit risk is racist. Here, the relationship seems like a hidden way to spot minorities, who happen to be more of a credit risk. When banks drew red lines around all the minority neighborhoods and didn't lend to people there, because they couldn't consider race anymore, most thought this behavior unacceptable, even though it did genuinely reduce credit risk for banks. ML can't explain its rationale, and very often does the exact same thing inside an opaque box.
- unishark 6y agoPresumably black people who are great loan customers would be incorrectly refused by a system based on fashion or addresses alone, so your answer seems to be that yes, racist methods actually lose the bank money. My tendency is to think that since it is optimized to maximize profit, the more features about a person we get in the data, the less "racist" the system becomes under this definition. Yes it's more possible to "hide" racism in a complex method using tons of features, but increasingly less likely it would happen. If we can use income and debt and whatever other things to make either a good classifier that ignores race, or an inferior one that sneakily identifies race and bases the decision on that, mathematical optimization of the model should result in the former. ML can be trusted more than humans in this situation, not less. Of course there's still the issue of the data being biased, which is where it all started.
- mlyle 6y ago> Presumably black people who are great loan customers would be incorrectly refused by a system based on fashion or addresses alone, Strawman. The question is whether predictions are improved by using race (or direct proxies for race), not whether it'd be wise to use proxies for race alone. Loan default rates are higher for disadvantaged minorities, even after controlling for many, many other variables (income, neighborhood, level of education, etc). Therefore, using race (or inferring race) improves prediction quality, but is ethically dubious.
- unishark 6y ago> Strawman. Can we skip this kind of snippy arguing please? Anyway I take it you agree the statement is true but don't want to. So now you're saying those great minority loan customers are impossible to identify? I think you just need to figure out what information is still missing. What's the effect size at this point anyway?
- mlyle 6y ago> > Strawman. > Can we skip this kind of snippy arguing please? If you don't start off by willfully mischaracterizing your opponent's argument in order to be able to more easily refute it, I think you'll find that they accuse you of this less. I think you're just willfully missing the point. Ideally, you'd just lend money to the people who will pay you back. Unfortunately, we can't predict this perfectly. Adding race, or proxies for race, to the things you consider improves your predictions somewhat.
- unishark 6y agoBy the way many methods are excellent at explaining their decisions. The favorite is decision trees which break the decision up into discrete decisions for individual features. E.g. a person was put in class 1 because their income was above X, their savings was above Y, etc. Other "shallow" methods like regression are fairly easy to interpret as well. It is mainly deep learning for which this is difficult. Which I'm sure is the method in the twitter discussion, but that is a different kind of problem where interpretability doesn't have a clear use.
- mlyle 6y agoWhen we say "ML", we usually don't mean regression. We not mean deep learning, but at least we mean SVM, SGD, etc. They may be less inscrutable than deep learning, but can easily still draw a box around most of the black people in a clever, non-obvious way.