4 ms·
Is that attenuated by making the system "blind" to race in those decision-making processes?
by mc32 6y ago
Is that attenuated by making the system "blind" to race in those decision-making processes?
- mlyle 6y agoIt's pretty hard to make the system "blind" to race. If you blind a system predicting recidivism to race, but it is able to see a lot of things that are correlates of race... it can end up being racist anyways. E.g. for a non-ML example -- redlining is theoretically "blind" to race, but makes extremely racist decisions.
- compiler-guy 6y agoThat is difficult to do because there are many things that correlate with race. So even if you remove race explicitly, things like neighborhoods, level of education and such end up being proxies. Removing race from the model is a very hard problem.
- mlyle 6y agoOne example: Credit card issuers have been known to take into account places that you have made purchases in assessing risk. If you shop at businesses that are primarily frequented by minorities, odds are you'll get a lower credit limit than if you didn't.
- mc32 6y agoI guess the question is why would that be germane to issuing credit? Is it correlated to something that indicated actual credit risk? If it makes erroneous assumptions correlations, would it not behoove them to eliminate the contamination?
- mlyle 6y agoSure: some of your purchase history definitely indicates behaviors that indicate you're a credit risk. Some of your purchase history indicates you're likely black (and if you're black, your credit risk is, empirically, a little higher-- even if it is not fair to not issue credit to people because they're black). ML will figure out both but can't explain the hidden variables: it'll figure out behaviors that directly indicate higher risk, and behaviors that indicate you're a minority that tends to be a higher risk.
- mc32 6y agoIs it too entangled to say disregard anything that leads to a path that makes inferences based on demographics? Although I suppose age is also tough to avoid in assigning risk.
- mlyle 6y agoAlmost anything you'd use is correlated to demographics somehow or another. We tend to think certain systems are "OK" and not too racist, because they have a well-articulated rationale independent of demographics. But ML is not very good at explaining rationale for decisions, so we don't have the benefit of that argument and it's difficult to even empirically understand how biased the system is. This is a hard problem.
- unishark 6y agoBasing your entire decision on something as simple as the applicant's income will presumably produce outcomes that differ with race. Is that what you mean by racist? Or do you mean the system identifies some individuals as high credit risk when they aren't and may actually lose money versus a more colorblind algorithm?
- mlyle 6y agoWhat's racist is squishy. Many people would say that identifying people who spend a lot of money at bars or casinos as a credit risk isn't racist, even if it happens to pick up more minorities. The mechanism for the credit risk and behavior seems tightly correlated. Many people would also say that identifying people who spend some money at clothing retailers that market to minorities as a credit risk is racist. Here, the relationship seems like a hidden way to spot minorities, who happen to be more of a credit risk. When banks drew red lines around all the minority neighborhoods and didn't lend to people there, because they couldn't consider race anymore, most thought this behavior unacceptable, even though it did genuinely reduce credit risk for banks. ML can't explain its rationale, and very often does the exact same thing inside an opaque box.
- 6y ago
- lawnchair_larry 6y agoDo you have a source?
- mlyle 6y agoe.g. https://consumerist.com/2008/12/22/amex-lowers-your-credit-limit-if-you-shop-where-deadbeats-shop/ https://consumerist.com/2008/12/22/amex-lowers-your-credit-l... Capital One has admitted doing the same, as well as a number of other lenders. There's been analyses done since, that show that when controlled for all other variables in credit reports, credit issuers issue less credit to blacks.. e.g. Cohen-Cole, 2011, Credit Card Redlining, Review of Economics and Statistics
- lawnchair_larry 6y agoCredit Card applications do not ask for race. I suspect it’s more likely based on zip code or similar.
- mlyle 6y agoI said "One example: Credit card issuers have been known to take into account places that you have made purchases in assessing risk. If you shop at businesses that are primarily frequented by minorities, odds are you'll get a lower credit limit than if you didn't" You asked for a source. I provided a source of the same. Yes, things like purchase histories are used as proxies for race and used to deny credit to mostly people of color. Then you go here: > Credit Card applications do not ask for race. which was never asserted. > I suspect it’s more likely based on zip code or similar. Yes, zip code can be another proxy for race.
- lawnchair_larry 6y agoYes, thanks for the example of the former. As for the latter, no, it’s not a proxy for race. It might be highly correlated with race, but that is very different. I don’t know why everyone does these gymnastics to find a racist angle to everything, but it’s nonsense and it’s very harmful to spread that narrative. Nobody is searching for black zipcodes and using that as an input to deny credit. The goal is to increase revenue by giving as much credit as possible with the least risk possible, so it wouldn’t even make sense. Scoring based on where you shop is still behavioral analysis. I think it’s a bad policy, but it isn’t targeting people of color. Your zip code affects insurance rates too, and that’s based on claims. It doesn’t cost more to insure your car in south side chicago than beverly hills because there are black people there, it costs more because there are more claims. The same effect is seen in “white” zip codes that are in areas with severe winters.
- lawnchair_larry 6y agoOr is race the proxy?
- Natsu 6y agoIt's really, really hard to erase biases that are deeply systemic. For example, from the outset, would you object to an AI that made decisions on how harshly to sentence someone based on age & number of prior crimes? What about hiring or admitting people to college based on the results of an IQ test? Yeah, those end up being badly biased, this first has been studied and the second is the reason for dropping SAT/ACT scores--every mental ability test correlates with IQ. The more interesting thing, IMHO, is that the opposite is also helpful. For example, if you help all poor people equally, you help even the playing field by disproportionately helping out all disadvantaged groups.
- mc32 6y agoApplication of law should always have room for judicial discretion. Mandatory minimum sentences should not exist, but then you get outrage over some light sentence here people get all riled over about and want to impeach judges and all. Education is different. IQ shouldn’t be relevant but competency and aptitude should and in addition we should recognize some people are better off going to vocational school where they may do better economically during their lifetimes.
- gold_mustard 6y ago>For example, from the outset, would you object to an AI that made decisions on how harshly to sentence someone based on age & number of prior crimes? Yes. This is an overly simplistic system for which it would be hard to justify the cost of developing. >What about hiring or admitting people to college based on the results of an IQ test? Yes. For the same reason.
- Natsu 6y agoThe first one was intentionally minimalist in order to see how little it took for racial bias to be reconstructed. For the second, any mental ability test correlates with IQ, so you end up with a different set of difficulties. There have been attempts to, e.g. correct for cultural bias in the tests, but these actually made the problems worse. I'm not presently aware of anything that makes that situation better.