9 ms·
Also that many judges are appointed. > In the last election, I tried to find out about the local judges on my ballot and could find virtually nothing. In my l
by godelski 6y ago
Also that many judges are appointed.
> In the last election, I tried to find out about the local judges on my ballot and could find virtually nothing.
In my last election I had the voting booklet. There were two judges running for a position. One had a website and the other (the incumbent) didn't.
Honestly, a lot of candidates I found didn't have websites. If you aren't going to take the time to make a simple website to state your policies I'm not sure I trust you to be transparent and make decisions on my behalf. In 2020 if you don't have a website you are demonstrating to me that you don't want to inform me, the voter, about yourself.
- chrisseaton 6y agoI don't understand why a judge would have a website. That's so crazy to me. They're not supposed to be appealing to anyone. They're supposed to interpret the law as it's written. They're technocrats. What would you like to see on a judge's website? Their opinions on things? They shouldn't have any personal opinions!
- godelski 6y ago> They're not supposed to be appealing to anyone. Like... voters? > What would you like to see on a judge's website? Qualifications, what ideals are important to them, how they handled complex cases, etc > They shouldn't have any personal opinions! Unfortunately they are human, so they do have personal opinions. They are allowed to have personal opinions. They just aren't allowed to have party affiliations. But if you look at the supreme court this is clearly also an absurd notion to expect them to not have leanings.
- chrisseaton 6y agoThis is bat-shit insane to me. The public elect the legislature who write the law... the judiciary implement it according to the legislation. They don't any personal opinions to it, that's not their job at all, they don't try to appeal to anyone, they just implement it. Is this not how it works in the US? In the US could a town elect a judge who says they're going to convict everyone who's left-handed?
- godelski 6y agoWhich part is confusing? Can you answer this? "Are laws objective?" It seems you think so. But if they aren't, then someone needs to interpret them. This is essentially what lawyers are doing and the judge and jury decides what is right. > they don't try to appeal to anyone, they just implement it. Is this not how it works in the US? On paper, yes. In practice, no. Because again, laws aren't objective. > In the US could a town elect a judge who says they're going to convict everyone who's left-handed? Let's rephrase it. > In the US could a town elect a judge who says they're going to convict everyone who's black? Welcome to Jim Crow era. So the answer is clearly yes. Of course, conviction still relies on the jury and "jury nullification" exists in an effort to put these types of judges in check. This is why you're supposed to be judged by peers. Now there is interpretation of what peers means. Or what community is. Is this your neighbors? Or is this just people that live in the town? Are people in the Brooklyn your peers if you live in Queens? What about if you live in Mountain View? If you do a search you'll quickly find different answers from legal scholars as to what "jury of peers" means. I brought up the first and second amendments because these are frequently debated in the public domain (where judges/legal scholars are debating and we the public can see and listen in). To me, the idea that laws are objective and not up for interpretation is "bat-shit insane." To do so would require perfect humans writing laws and last time I checked we didn't have any of those.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> But if they aren't, then someone needs to interpret them. If they're open to too much interpretation... send them back to the legislature to clarify. > Welcome to Jim Crow era. So the answer is clearly yes. Well this seems like an indication to me that the system is not great.
- godelski 6y ago> If they're open to too much interpretation... send them back to the legislature to clarify. Good idea. Now what do we do in the mean time with people that are being tried? Wait? How? Are they free or in jail? What's the default position? Or do we just do our best (i.e. interpretation)? > Well this seems like an indication to me that the system is not great. Well... yeah... I don't think anyone has claimed it as such. If you have a better system I think a lot of people would be happy. The issue is that there's lots of nuances involved. Even if we had Multivac judging it would still be difficult. People can't write code to be absolutely unambiguous and error proof. Code that takes into account every possible scenario. So I'm not sure why you would expect people that are in a more complex feature environment and using a less precise language would be able to perform better. This is really absurd, to me. HUMANS ARE NOT PERFECT ROBOTS. And I'm not sure why this is a controversial opinion.
- erichurkman 6y ago> They just aren't allowed to have party affiliations Unfortunately wrong. https://ballotpedia.org/Partisan_election_of_judges https://ballotpedia.org/Partisan_election_of_judges
- curryst 6y agoThey absolutely have opinions, often about how to interpret the law. This is why Supreme Court decisions always have the "dissenting opinion" document listing out why they think the majority decision was incorrect. Many laws are not so black and white that the decision is explicit. You have to handle weird chain of custody questions, whether evidence was seized lawfully, etc, etc.