3 ms·
A monopoly and a union have equivalent bargaining power. The union members have only vastly inferior substitutes for employment (e.g. Dairy Queen), and the comp
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
A monopoly and a union have equivalent bargaining power. The union members have only vastly inferior substitutes for employment (e.g. Dairy Queen), and the company has only inferior substitutes for labor (temps). It's in both of their best interests to eventually agree to split the rents.
In a competitive market, there is less rent to split (e.g., 5% profit margin instead of 15%) and there is always a third possibility: the unionized employer goes bankrupt and only non-unionized employers remain. So producers (as a class, not any individual one) get to survive, while the union (as a class) is destroyed.
But don't take my word for it. Go take a look at the world. The primary bastions of unionization seem to be monopolies or oligopolies: the government, Big 3 automakers (in their heyday, at least), cable companies and the like. Unionization also declined (outside the government) as the country became more competitive.
Think about what nearly happened to the auto industry. Consumers suffered with crappy overpriced cars, and the Big 3 + unions enjoyed their rents. Then the market became more competitive, and absent government intervention, the unionized part of the sector would have died. The unions seem desperately afraid of this effect in education which is why they fight tooth and nail against charters/vouchers.