6 ms·
You're upset about them requiring hardware attestation in SafetyNet (I am too) so you move to a platform that is way less flexible and way more closed? Not a t
by freedomben 6y ago
You're upset about them requiring hardware attestation in SafetyNet (I am too) so you move to a platform that is way less flexible and way more closed?
Not a troll, I'm really curious.
- sitic 6y agoIf my phone has to be a walled garden, Apple's seems more enticing to me for the moment. I would want to give it a try at least. I might very well regret it and switch back to an Android phone which won't get updates after two years. I also have to say that to me, even if apps that require SafetyNet don't work anymore after unlocking, it certainly doesn't make the phone certainly useless. But I don't want to live with the inconvenience of not being able to use some random apps.
- californical 6y agoI can give an anecdote. I love most things about iOS design more than Android, and I've used both, but have stuck with Android over the last 7-8ish years. Mainly because of the amount that I could customize things, freely make little app projects, install custom ROMs, etc. Over the last few years, it's gotten inconvenient to tinker, and I just don't find myself bothering with it anymore. I've run into issues where certain apps stop working because of root. But also both OS's have gotten much better and need fewer (if any) tweaks anyways to be used effectively. Especially with the upcoming change to allow iOS to use a different default browser (finally). If the main reason I've been drawn to Android is vanishing more every year, I'd rather use the more elegant OS (Apple), regardless of how closed it is. I have a Pixel 2 that's getting near EOL (only 2 years after buying it), and I'll be getting an iPhone SE as soon as I can justify spending the money. I guess something that helps too is I've been on a de-googling kick these last few months where I've been switching off all their services because of privacy, another benefit of iOS to me
- homarp 6y agoiOS 14 does not let you use a different default browser engine. It's just the skin that change. It's still Webkit under the hood
- slipheen 6y agoAs much as you and I may care about that, for many (most?) people the browser chrome is the most important part. Syncing bookmarks, UI, tab handling etc tend to be bigger pain points for individuals, as opposed to the more dev-focused aspects such as supporting a certain API in Javascript.
- izacus 6y ago> As much as you and I may care about that, for many (most?) people the browser chrome is the most important part. Except that for many/most people it's equally important to have a market choice which drives product improvements by competition. Not being able to choose a fully opensource browser engine (not even Firefox!) on iOS is a severe blow to opensource as a whole and browser engine competition in general. It's way worse than it ever was in times of IE6 - you never needed Microsoft's private signing keys to switch to Firefox or Chrome.
- bad_user 6y agoIf you're technologically illiterate, this might be true. Witness however Firefox for Android (vs iOS), the most important differences for me being: - Extensions support, so uBlock Origin, Privacy Badger, the best ad-blocking combination that far surpasses Safari's content blockers, which are pretty shitty; and extensions are useful for more than ad-blocking — e.g. I have another one on my tablet that turns all web pages to dark mode, whether they support it or not - Web push notifications - (Up until very recently) webp format support On Android I wouldn't even install many apps, like Facebook, or Twitter, or Fastmail, I'd simply use them as PWAs (web apps), in Firefox with ads blocking on, because I could. I still use Firefox on iOS for the history / bookmarks syncing, but it's a shadow of actual Firefox.
- californical 6y agoYeah it's not ideal, but it lets me sync with Firefox at least. I really only ever use my phone browser for a few things, anyways. Neither situation is perfect, but the browser's rendering engine is surpassed by other priorities when choosing a phone. I do look forward to the day I can use something like Pine as a daily phone though
- TheSpiceIsLife 6y ago> Especially with the upcoming change to allow iOS to use a different default (finally). Did you leave a word out here? I assume you were going to write default keyboard?
- smichel17 6y agoIt was edited I think, the word is browser.
- copp 6y agoWhat makes iOS elegant over Android in your opinion ? You seem to state it as a fact but I believe it is your opinion .
- pjmlp 6y agoNot the OP, but I also share the same opinion. - OS Frameworks are not designed for the next year's IO, rebooting last years best practices, rather have long term roadmaps. - The build system has stayed mostly the same, instead of having had multiple reboots - C and C++ are integrated with the rest of tooling instead of feeling like an burden that has to be supported to keep game devs happy - Everything that matters on iOS development is available in XCode, instead of being a mix of Studio templates, stuff dropped in Github that we are supposed to build ourselves and apparently official APIs (e.g. Oboe, Vulkan) - Back to frameworks, while iOS offers high level frameworks for common workflows, Android offers Lego blocks that everyone fits in different ways with lengthy discussions on what is good Android code, MVP and whatever is the fad of the month on /r/androiddev - When Apple does game development sessions, they actually talk about game development tech and do provide related tooling, Google talks about Play Store console and advertising for gamers. Notice that main GDC 2020 theme for the Google talks was to try to show that they are listing and trying to change, pity it came 10 years later. - Most APIs in iOS seem to have had some though placed into them, in Android you have stuff like Animations that have had multiple instantiations, or others that have deprecated stuff even before reaching a proper release. - When Google decided to drop Eclipse they had nothing to offer for NDK devs, almost two years later JetBrains decided to create CLion and then they had a solution. Otherwise most likely there still wouldn't exist an alternative to this day.
- copp 6y agoThanks for your perspective from a game dev. w.r.t developing apps it has been long argued that iOS is better.
- ocdtrekkie 6y agoFor me, Play Services is a non-starter: It's malware, plain and simple. For a couple years I tried to use Android without Google services, but I found it too restrictive. Most apps I'd want/need to use wouldn't even run without Google Play, even if you got the APK, since there's not really a good app store that has a lot of Android apps without Google Play. (F-Droid's hard-line open source requirement is too restrictive for my daily driver.) I went to Windows Mobile for a while, it had more apps than a non-Google Android phone as it was, but obviously that's dead now as Microsoft has left the consumer space and literally told everyone to go buy Android phones. Until antitrust happens, iPhone is really all that's left. I've got a PinePhone too, and I'm pretty excited about it, but it'll probably be a while until it reaches Windows Mobile-level of app availability. I've been pleasantly surprised by Apple's pro-privacy moves since I bought it, and if they're opening up changing default apps this year too, really the most problematic limitation is going to be gone.
- user5994461 6y agoYou could try one of the Chinese android phones, like Xiaomi. Make sure to get an Asian import, because some models have an US/European export edition with the normal Google ecosystem. This is an interesting experience in what a fully functional phone not from Google/Apple can be like. It may not be able to run the usual apps though, unless you install the playstore manually.
- bad_user 6y agoWhy would someone not trusting Google, place their trust in Xiaomi, a Chinese company?
- fsflover 6y agoWhat if you live in the US? Which government you should fear more, US or Chinese?
- bad_user 6y agoYou should fear your local government most, of course, but it does not follow that given the choice you should pick foreign solutions, quite the contrary. As a citizen you have rights guaranteed by the law in your own country. That's the very definition of citizenship. As a citizen you have leverage over your government, even if small, because you can organize yourself with others, e.g. in class action lawsuits, you can vote, you can convince others to vote, etc. Foreign governments and companies couldn't give a shit about your rights, the only rights you have are those defined weakly by trade agreements. Not only that but data can be traded or leaked. A foreign company thousands of miles away, collecting data about you, could always leak that data to your local organized crime organizations. N.B. I know that big companies like Xiaomi also have a presence in the US. With a big enough presence, the US government could coerce them just as easily, so if you fear the US government, it's a double whammy. --- So this is a non sequitur. Even if you fear the US government, as a US citizen, you should either pick US solutions, or solutions from countries that have a culture and laws for preserving privacy, such as Switzerland or Germany. Frankly as a US citizen picking products and services from a country with disregard for basic human rights, because you don't trust the US, is just stupid.
- notyourday 6y agoPlay Services infuriate me. I have no idea what app is triggering what kind of actions via Play because all of those actions are done by Play on behalf of the app and Play is not showing it to me in enough details
- freedomben 6y agoI can certainly echo this sentiment. It is maddening to see Play services as the "culprit" for the bad thing I'm investigating. Very frustrating.
- kelnos 6y agoIf you're comfortable disclosing, what is this "bad thing"? From my understanding, Play Services provides roughly the same suite of things that are also supplied on iOS, only on iOS, it's built into the OS (location services, cloud messaging, etc.), while on Android it's a modular component that Google can push updates to without a full OS update. Is that not accurate?
- scarface74 6y agoEverything that Google announced in the submitted article requires an OS update. So being able to push just Play Services updates doesn’t help too much....
- nmfisher 6y agoAs a developer, I apologise for the Play Services requirement. I believe this is a hard dependency for Firebase integration (and at the very least, it's the easiest/fastest way to implement Google Sign-in, though I assume this could be replaced with manual OAuth). I didn't realize it was such an issue. I'll make a note to investigate how difficult it is to migrate away.
- notyourday 6y agoI do not think there's actually a good way for a developer to avoid Play Services, which in turn leads me to say that you should continue to use it or whatever else lets you get the most functionality out of the Android for the least amount of pain. Objectively, an Android user is not going to disable the Play Services as Google's apps will continue to rely on it so non-Google developers should use it as well.
- 867-5309 6y agoIn my case I am stuck with a spare phone on android 8 since they banned wireless scanning from 9 onwards. it's a matter of functionality over perceived security. fed up with google. will check out the PinePhone
- zimmerfrei 6y agoIs it clear exactly what SafetyNet does and reports back to Google? Is its source code available (including for any TrustZone component), maybe as part of AOSP? I am OK with the concept and I can value it also as a protection against advanced malware, but only if it is totally transparent (to me!) what data it collects and relies upon.
- panpanna 6y agoI think they use industry standard techniques (trust anchroing, attestation, etc) but their implementation is not fully open. I'm actually fine with that.