3 ms·
It is but there isn’t a good fix that satisfies everyone. Even the USSR had private apartments for people who didn’t want to live in multi-family per apartment
by mc32 6y ago
It is but there isn’t a good fix that satisfies everyone.
Even the USSR had private apartments for people who didn’t want to live in multi-family per apartment arrangements (communal apartments). Obviously not everyone could afford private apartments —very few could, buy they existed because even with all the resources of a top down bureaucracy they could not meet the needs of the people.
- vkou 6y agoThe USSR always had a shortage of apartments, because of its inability to affordably hammer raw materials together into housing. It had no problems with parceling land into housing, though. The USA has no problem hammering raw materials into houses, but it has a shortage of apartments because of its inability to affordably parcel out land into housing. You need to be good at both, in order for housing to be affordable. However, it should be noted that affordable housing is not the goal of at least half the country - because that half of the country own houses (or mortgages for houses), and housing becoming affordable would financially destroy them. So, in that sense, everything is working by design, and things will never change, if the government can help it.
- AlexTWithBeard 6y agoAn important thing about USSR, which people often forget about, is there was no free movement. Oversimplifying things a bit, you could only relocate when you're changing jobs and your new employer must have a special permission to hire workers from outside their region. Very similar to H1B quotas.
- mc32 6y agoIt’s the same in China today. They have the Hukou system. This is your family registration system and you need special permission to register somewhere new. Your benefits as a citizen are tied to this. If you move to a city without approval, you work illegally and are not entitled to housing or educational facilities (which is why parents who’ve moved illegally need to send their kids to illegal schools). The local government also can go raid these places from time to time depending on what quotas they need to align with. So kind of sort of of like the four belt system in the USSR which limited internal movement and required internal passports.