6 ms·
Year old iPad runs x86_64 in emulation faster than the Surface natively
- alwillis 6y agoA sign of things to come…
- kissiel 6y agoI think the "in emulation" bit uncertain. I think this got AOT translated to armv8. Also not very apples-to-apples comparison.
- NobodyNada 6y agoI’m not sure what you mean; could you clarify? > I think the “in emulation” bit uncertain. I think this got AOT translated to armv8. The benchmark is measuring the performance of Geekbench running in Rosetta, which is the emulation layer allowing x86_64 code to run under Apple’s ARM chip. Are you saying you don’t trust that the benchmark is actually running under Rosetta, or are you claiming that Rosetta doesn’t count as “true” emulation because it performs some translation AOT? > Also not very apples-to-apples comparison. How so? The benchmark is between Apple’s flagship tablet CPU and Microsoft’s flagship tablet CPU, with the additional handicap that Apple’s chip is running the code through an emulation layer in order to demonstrate the impressive performance of Rosetta. How is the comparison unfair?
- qayxc 6y ago> The benchmark is measuring the performance of Geekbench running in Rosetta, which is the emulation layer allowing x86_64 code to run under Apple’s ARM chip According to Apple it's not an emulation layer at all, though. They themselves call it "translation technology" [1] and the term "emulation" is nowhere to be found. I'm not sure why tech outlets insist on calling it an emulation layer, was it called that in the WWDC presentation? [1] https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2020/06/apple-announces-mac-transition-to-apple-silicon/ https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2020/06/apple-announces-mac-t...
- olliej 6y agoHonestly at this point I don’t even really understand the difference between emulation and translation at the app level. My intuition is that “emulation” generally means an entire system rather than individual apps running on a system?
- kissiel 6y agoWith translation the cod will be translated before it starts running. With emulation it's more like a VM, where each instruction run is translated to the other archs counterpart. In other words, consider an imaginary program that has one big loop. Let's say it has 100 instructions. With translation you get another program with some instructions of the similar size (same order of magnitude). With emulation you interpret each instruction as it goes, so if your loop has 1B iterations you pay the penalty of emulating (converting on the fly) 1B times (very simplified). So translation is better for performance.
- ch_sm 6y ago"Emulation" usually means reconstructing the hardware of a specific architecture in software (See BSNES for a good example). Rosetta translates binary code of an app from one instruction set to another.
- kissiel 6y agoNot apple to apple because we're still comparing binaries for different architectures. Apple kit is running x86_64 binary and Surface is running an arm binary. The hardware comparison should be done once geekbench is recompiled to armv8.
- NobodyNada 6y ago*2 year old iPad; HN ate the beginning of the title
- derision 6y ago2 year old iPad chip running inside a development kit with proper cooling, compared against a Surface Pro X which is essentially a fanless tablet
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- serf 6y agoyeah, agreed, it's a weird cherry-picked comparison. Smells like marketing.
- chipotle_coyote 6y agoIt's a weird comparison, but I don't think it's "cherry-picked" as much as sort of general "this is an interesting if fuzzy data point about Apple CPU performance." It's not too likely Apple is secretly feeding numbers to Steve Troughton-Smith. He's a somewhat (in)famous developer known for picking apart Apple OS releases and documenting the undocumented -- I suspect he's probably not on Apple PR's Christmas card list. :)
- mikece 6y agoI don't understand the point of comparing an A12Z running x86-64 emulation to the Microsoft SQ1 processor which is also an ARM processor but nowhere as beefy as the A12Z. I am not familiar with the Surface Pro X but if Microsoft is doing x86-64 emulation on it I am not surprised it's not as fast as the A12Z. https://www.tomshardware.com/news/microsoft-sq1-processor-surface-pro-x,40537.html https://www.tomshardware.com/news/microsoft-sq1-processor-su...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- izacus 6y agoIt makes fans of Apple feel better about how much more superior their platform is over the others. That's mostly the gist of it in most of these debates - the comparisons are usually pretty meaningless and cherry-picked to make a writers favorite brand look better. The more interesting comparison is just how much better the ARM macs will be from the x86 ones in comparable workloads and power consumption. Seeing the Apple ARM cores being able to show all they can with proper cooling and less power limitations is something we've been waiting for awhile.
- mikece 6y agoI don't know how tongue-in-cheek that comment is but I am curious what the performance of these new ARM-powered Macs will be. I do photography on the side and Adobe Lightroom on the iPad Pro runs just about as fast (if not faster for some rendering and processing tasks) as it does on my MacBook Pro. How the heck this is possible is beyond me but it gives me hope that photo and video editing on an ARM-powered MacBook Pro could be faster, maybe even significantly faster, than my i9-powered MacBook Pro.
- m0xte 6y agoSee my comment at the same level as yours. 2020 iPad Pro is about the same as an i7-7700k. It’s insanely fast at a much much much lower TDP.
- rstat1 6y agoI don't understand all the hype here. It did better on one half of the test by way less than 100 points, and got beat on the other half by over 300. Not that impressive.
- ArgyleSound 6y agoTo be fair they're both 8 core big.LITTLE processors but the Apple chip is running the benchmark under x86 emulation and thus isn't able to use asymmetric cores, only the four performance ones.
- qayxc 6y agoI was under the impression that Rosetta 2 is install-time translation and thus not emulation at all...
- ArgyleSound 6y agoI think it does both, but I'm not familiar with what Geekbench 5 actually does and whether it can be fully translated ahead of time. Regardless the translation doesn’t seem to be able to make use of both sets of cores.
- qayxc 6y agoMaybe Apple will release more detailed information in the near future. I'm curious to learn what the differences between Rosetta 2 and Microsoft's emulation technique are.
- ArgyleSound 6y agoYeah. Presumably more information will also trickle out from the developers who are using the DTKs.
- saagarjha 6y ago
- jdlyga 6y agoTrue but it's still an iPad. It still feels like you're working with one hand tied behind your back.
- saagarjha 6y agoIt runs macOS.
- bluesign 6y agoI see 25% reduction in single core performance, 45% on multicore performance, according to ipad pro benchmarks [1] Nothing to be too happy about [1] https://www.macrumors.com/2020/03/23/ipad-pro-2020-a12z-benchmarks/ https://www.macrumors.com/2020/03/23/ipad-pro-2020-a12z-benc...
- saagarjha 6y ago(Under emulation.)
- AgloeDreams 6y agoFor emulation of x86.. that's not too shabby at all seeing as the Surface Pro X emulation is a much harder hit. Keep in mind that the iPad result is based on use of 8 total asymmetric cores, which is kind-of an issue for apps like these so it only uses the 4 high-power cores. In either case, this system in emulated state will out-perform a number of laptops they have sold like the 12 inch MacBook, with emulation. Thats impressive. The Rumored machines they will ship add two more high performance cores and likely eat way more power. I wouldn't be shocked to see it be as fast as current macs in emulation.
- chipotle_coyote 6y agoThe headline here seems misleading: (1) It's an iPad CPU running x86_64 code in emulation, but it's running macOS, not iPadOS. This is not an iPad, which AFAIK can't run x86_64 code in emulation. (2) It's a two-year-old chip, not a one-year-old one. :) The whole thing is a little weird; if I'm understanding it correctly, they ran the Windows ARM version of Geekbench natively on the Surface X, and ran the macOS x86_64 version of Geekbench on the ARM-based Developer Transition Kit hardware and it still performed competitively. So Apple's CPUs are pretty good and Rosetta 2 does really good instruction translation, but I don't think we can draw a lot of conclusions from the specific numbers either way. (Even setting aside complaints about Geekbench as a benchmark, commercially available ARM Macs when they start shipping are almost certainly not going to based on the DTK CPU/hardware, just like the original Intel DTK compared to the first Intel Macs.)
- hartator 6y agoYes, the next macbook will probably feature something faster than the 2-year old ipad chip?
- czzr 6y agoYes, all benchmarks right now are highly questionable. Still, it’s understandable everyone is curious - we’ll just have to wait and see.
- fomine3 6y agoIt seems that there's no Geekbench for Windows ARM. So it's comparing between emulated benchmarks? https://www.geekbench.com/download/ https://www.geekbench.com/download/
- doener 6y ago>(2) It's a two-year-old chip, not a one-year-old one. :) The original title I put in was "2 Year old ...". Hacker News just deleted the 2 automatically after posting.
- soapdog 6y agoBut my Surface Pro X can run Linux inside WSL2. Apps made arm32, arm64, and x86 32bits just works, both Windows and Linux terminal apps, or GUIs if I install an X11 Server. And I can install whatever application I want, and not what Apple allows me to. It might be a bit slower, but it is more flexible.
- saagarjha 6y agoWhile the DTK can't, Apple has announced that they will be offering virtualization on Apple silicon, and Rosetta 2 will take care of the Intel binaries. And they have affirmed that you can always run whatever you like, as the switches to do so are there if you want them.
- Wowfunhappy 6y ago> And they have affirmed that you can always run whatever you like, as the switches to do so are there if you want them. I've heard this repeated elsewhere as well, and I'm quite confused about it. Because, Apple also shared this weird screenshot: https://images.macrumors.com/t/_vG0G6_BcznVoKBolteArd1wReM=/800x0/filters:quality(90)/article-new/2020/06/apple-silicon-mac-startup-security-screen.jpg https://images.macrumors.com/t/_vG0G6_BcznVoKBolteArd1wReM=/... The most permissive option is "Reduced Security: Allows any version of signed operating system software ever trusted by Apple to run." How do you run an OS that Apple never explicitly trusted?
- saagarjha 6y agoYou can turn off secure boot.
- AgloeDreams 6y agoUhhh... how is this any different? Thy have stated that the download options on these macs will be any source you want, ARM and Intel Mac apps, plus docker support for linux and etc. It's the same stack.
- 6y ago
- cbhl 6y agoIsn't the first rule of access to developer toolkits "thou shall not benchmark, and thou shall not publish benchmarks"? Although, granted, I'd imagine the new Macbooks having newer, faster chips than the developer toolkits once they finally launch.
- jaywalk 6y agoYes, and Apple was very explicit about not benchmarking this machine.
- GeekyBear 6y agoFor those interested in how Apple's current iPhone chip fares against Qualcomm without the active cooling found in the Dev Kit: A13 Big Cores: >In the mobile space, there’s really no competition as the A13 posts almost double the performance of the next best non-Apple SoC. Last year I’ve noted that the A12 was margins off the best desktop CPU cores. This year, the A13 has essentially matched best that AMD and Intel have to offer – in SPECint2006 at least. In SPECfp2006 the A13 is still roughly 15% behind. https://www.anandtech.com/show/14892/the-apple-iphone-11-pro-and-max-review/4 https://www.anandtech.com/show/14892/the-apple-iphone-11-pro... A13 Little Cores: >In the face-off against a Cortex-A55 implementation such as on the Snapdragon 855, the new Thunder cores represent a 2.5-3x performance lead while at the same time using less than half the energy. https://www.anandtech.com/show/14892/the-apple-iphone-11-pro-and-max-review/2 https://www.anandtech.com/show/14892/the-apple-iphone-11-pro... A13 GPU: The differences to Qualcomm’s Adreno architecture are now so big that even the newest Snapdragon 865 peak performance isn’t able to match Apple’s sustained performance figures. It’s no longer that Apple just leads in CPU, they are now also massively leading in GPU. https://www.anandtech.com/show/15246/anandtech-year-in-review-2019-flagship-mobile/2 https://www.anandtech.com/show/15246/anandtech-year-in-revie...
- whywhywhywhy 6y agoHows it compare with a real world example like Cinebench rather than "Geekbench" scores which never seems to actually correlate to the real world?
- kristianp 6y agoOne question I have, is: couldn't they get the IOS geekbench to work on the Developer kit?
- panpanna 6y agoHmmm... these are two different benchmarks.