4 ms·
Presumably downvoted because people don't like it. But it's the truth.
by globular-toast 6y ago
Presumably downvoted because people don't like it. But it's the truth.
- ambicapter 6y ago> A 2700lb subcompact vehicle that scores Good may fare worse than a 5000lb SUV that scores Acceptable. This is because the small overlap tests involve driving the vehicle into a fixed obstacle, as opposed to a reference vehicle or vehicle-like obstacle of a specific weight. This is, in some sense, equivalent to crashing the vehicle into a vehicle of the same weight, so it's as if the 2700lb subcompact was tested by running it into a 2700lb subcompact and the 5000lb SUV was tested by running it into another 5000 lb SUV. Its the "truth" until you run into something that's bigger than you.
- globular-toast 6y agoNo.. that still shows it's the truth.
- komali2 6y agoThis isn't correcting for whether people can safely drive the biggest vehicles on the road, semi trucks.
- jbay808 6y agoIt's the "let's defect in a prisoner's dilemma" strategy that works great until others use it too.
- nitrogen 6y agoI've been riding out the quarantine in a less populated area, and I am surrounded by trucks so tall that the driver can't even see the roof of my car if I am stopped next to them at a light. It's already too late to avoid defection -- if I stay here for good, I will have to get a taller car just so other drivers can see me and so I can see through the windows of parked cars when turning.
- jbay808 6y agoI know; I've had the same experience. :( It's a shame. The pedestrians will have to find a way to get taller too.
- globular-toast 6y agoPedestrians have no place on the road, just like cyclists. They aren't people, they are obstacles. It's going to take a huge reform to change that, especially in the US.
- globular-toast 6y agoIt is not the prisoner's dilemma at all. If everyone gets big cars then everyone is equally as safe. They don't all die. For crying out loud, people, I know it's stupid, I know it's wrong, but it's the truth. It's an uncomfortable truth that your downvoting will not change.
- tpmx 6y agoI think you're on to something. First: there's vehicle-to-barrier crashes (think trees, etc): Having a vehicle with a large well-designed crumple zone seems obviously good from a survivability POV. Second: there's vehicle-to-vehicle crashes: Is it really a zero-sum game? If a small car crashes head on with a large car, will the people in the small car suffer worse than if they crashed into another small car? To what degree?
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoTo an amazing degree. In the limit, the large vehicle proceeds nearly unimpeded and the small one is a ball of tinfoil.
- tpmx 6y agoI mean, that makes sense if we assume that cars are sphere-shaped with consistent density. Of course, they aren't. I guess what I was looking for was actual data, not assumptions.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoData? My son in his Ford F350 had a collision with a compact car that pulled out directly in front of him across the highway at speed. Small car: totalled. Truck: some scratches on bumper, loud noise.
- Marsymars 6y ago> Is it really a zero-sum game? If a small car crashes head on with a large car, will the people in the small car suffer worse than if they crashed into another small car? To what degree? Well it's zero sum in the linear sense as the relative total velocity change is the same, but crash survivability isn't linear. Rather, it decreases exponentially, since kinetic energy is proportional to the square of velocity - so a head-on crash between a semi and a compact car subjects the occupants of the compact car to nearly 4x the force that they'd be subjected to if they crashed into another compact car.