7 ms·
Or lazy. No, the lazy choice is to have the visions of the infinite you mention and instead of trying to understand them, simply to describe them in terms of w
by pg 18y ago
Or lazy.
No, the lazy choice is to have the visions of the infinite you mention and instead of trying to understand them, simply to describe them in terms of whatever traditional concepts are floating around in your culture-- which in this case are at best 99% anthropomorphizing fable, and often consciously designed to enslave you.
- robg 18y agoThat's a very strict definition that I mostly agree with to understand the past. But it still leaves the leading question unaddressed. The solution to rejecting something isn't replacing it with nothing. By "understand them", I think that can operate on many levels simultaneously. The key for me is either giving up traditional concepts or reinterpreting them in contemporary terms.
- jsrn 18y agoNo, the lazy choice is to have the visions of the infinite you mention and instead of trying to understand them, simply to describe them in terms of whatever traditional concepts are floating around in your culture. maybe it's not an either-or choice. E.g., Don Knuth manages to be a (non-lazy) scientist who has thought a lot about infinity and a Christian at the same time.
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoPerhaps some of us have grown out of our traditional concepts designed to enslave us and have managed not to have visions of the infinite (study of infinities is a fairly mature science, btw) but still understand the need for a taxonomy of the unknowable? The lazy is on you, it seems, for making all kinds of straw man arguments here. Surely 99% of belief in God is based on culture and anthropology, but 99% is not 100%. You do the topic a disservice to say that it is. Personally? I find it funny when people say they're an atheist. "How do you know what not to believe in?" is my first question, and usually that shuts them down. You see, atheism is a response to those traditional cultural ideas of religion (and the history of how they have evolved), not to the real concept of a God. To the atheist, God, santa clause, the christian church, the easter bunny, etc -- it's all the same thing. Stuff you can't prove. They haven't grown to understand where the definitional fault lines are. That's lazy.
- aswanson 18y ago"How do you know what not to believe in?" There are an infinite number of things we can believe in. This makes it necessary to come up with a rational framework based on what we know to make probabilistic inferences. This is basically an argument handled as such: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russell's_teapot http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russell's_teapot I don't want to come off as attacking faith or your beliefs, either. I know what it is like to believe and to not believe so I can respect your experience even though I don't share it.
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoHey -- I have very little faith, so no harm done. I'm not a religious person. You are answering in the positive -- how you know _what_ to believe in. That is not the question, and the two are not logical opposites of one another. Let's try a thought experiment, shall we? Let's say you and I meet on a train. If I told you my barn was red, would you believe me? You might or might not. We might have a discussion about science and how we know things. I'm sure we could come to some sort of understanding about levels of proof and this and that. Why is that? Because reasoning and logic work inside of a web of meanings that we call language. That's what science is built on. It's both part of everyday knowledge and part of advanced reasoning. We are dealing with concrete things: nouns with meanings, lists of things, perceptions and the relationship of formal systems, empiricality and positivism. But what happens if I introduce an item without common meaning? Perhaps things without any meaning at all. Let's say you are a caveman and I am from the year 4000. I say "I have something that you do not understand. It is so outside your understanding such that that I cannot describe it to you inside of our limited window of conversation. I cannot even begin to describe the generics of the things that lead to those concepts" Now you're perfectly capable of saying "I don't believe that. I only believe things that have a strict order (not realizing, of course, that all of "common sense" is tenuous at best. Read up)" That's cool. Nothing wrong with that. But it does not impact the veracity of my statement. In fact, without language, reason, observation, theory, and reproduction, _you're unable to make any conclusions about my statement one way or another_. Things outside our web of understanding exist in a place where we can make no conclusions one way or another. All I am saying is that there is a class of such statements. There always have been, and there always will be. Most of these statements -- perhaps 99.99999% of them -- are eventually dealt with as our experiential and smenatic toolbox expands. God, to me, is the set of those true statements that we are unable to understand. Now I'm not talking about reasoning in common language and logical space -- I think science probably forms the interface between the true and unknowable and the true and knowable. In that sense, science and religion are like yin and yang -- one is simply the thing the other is not (and likewise, one is contained inside the other) Looking back over written history, we can see the wonderful dialectic of reason and faith. One can look at this as the war of reason over superstition, or one can look at it as the conquest of universal concepts of morality and faith over political, tribal, and primitive power systems -- the species learning what part of God-belief is critical to its survival and what is not. Same thing, different viewpoint.
- rbanffy 18y ago"No, the lazy choice is to have the visions of the infinite you mention and instead of trying to understand them" There is some ground between being religious and being an atheist. Being an atheist implies some degree of faith. The question whether there is a God cannot be answered within our current knowledge (and it may pretty well remain so until the end of our universe). An atheist firmly believes the answer is "no". An agnostic acknowledges we are unable to answer the question. Maybe in a million years, maybe never. Interestingly, the only answer science can give to questions like these is on the lines of "we can neither prove nor disprove this hypothesis". As I use to joke, I lack the faith required to be an atheist. ;-)
- pg 18y agoOutside of math, you can never be sure that something is false. But if someone asked you whether the Red Sox won the 1950 World Series, it would seem pretty bogus to say that you were keeping an open mind. There's no distinction between atheist and agnostic on that question. The only reason there's one on the question of God's existence is because people have a much stronger desire to finesse the answer to such a historically loaded question.
- rbanffy 18y agoFinding out the results of the 1950 World Series does not require an open mind - History can answer that one. I think we are really playing with words here. You are absolutely sure God does not exist, but I cannot make the required leap of faith that being a true atheist implies and, thus, I can only call myself agnostic. Still, I am pretty sure He (or She, or It) doesn't exist. As you well pointed out, I am not absolutely sure of anything that cannot be proved with a sound mathematical demonstration. That's about all the faith I have. And I place it _very_ carefully ;-)
- kirubakaran 18y ago"To count oneself as an atheist one need not claim to have a proof that no gods exist. One need merely think that the evidence on the god question is in about the same state as the evidence on the werewolf question." -- John McCarthy I used to think that it is just as arrogant to be an atheist as it is to be religious. Both sides have no proof. I considered myself to be agnostic as all we can confidently say is that "we don't know". But I changed my label on reading jmc's words. [edit: on reading other parts of this discussion, I see that jmc has already been quoted. However I'll let this post be, as it is still a reply to the parent.]
- bokonist 18y ago...at best 99% anthropomorphizing fable, and often consciously designed to enslave you. Ironically, in the modern West the relationship between church and state has been almost entirely severed. Christianity is now mostly harmless. The truly dangerous religions are the civic/nationalistic religions. Instead of pledging to God, we pledge to the flag. Instead of wearing crosses we wear lapel pins. We even get to elect a high priest every four years ( http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jjXyqcx-mYY&feature=related http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jjXyqcx-mYY&feature=relat... ). And unlike Christianity, nationalism has conscription and nuclear bombs. The history of the 20th century shows that dropping the "God" label did not get rid of religion, it made religion far more insidious and dangerous.
- asdflkj 18y agoYou're mainly talking about the modern USA, not the modern West. And USA happens to be the most Christian of Western nations. In other Western countries, too, the state religion is roughly proportional to Christianity. UK, for example, is midway between USA and Sweden in both respects. Unless state religion causes Christianity (unlikely, IMO), that leaves us with two possibilities: either Christianity causes state religion, or they are both just different faces of the same mentality. In either case, your assertion that "Christianity is now mostly harmless" is wrong.
- wumi 18y agoand so the logic follows, then, that all smart people who have tried to understand the 'visions of the infinite' are atheists?
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]