4 ms·
For sure, central planning is so inadequate. And China's economic failure compared to liberal countries like India is a great illustration of that. Oh wait… (A
by littlestymaar 6y ago
For sure, central planning is so inadequate. And China's economic failure compared to liberal countries like India is a great illustration of that. Oh wait…
(Also relevant, in the 20s and 30s, USSR came from a shithole agricultural country with no industry, to the second biggest industrial economy of the world).
I'm not saying that central planning is desirable, but it's for sure more than adequate of your goal is development.
- nickik 6y agoIf you even the slighest bit of understanding of Indian history and Indian economics calling it 'liberal' is complete nonsense. After WW2 India adopted a diliberatly socialst agenda, often called Indian Socialism the was all about top down managment of all markets with heavy government guidence and intervention. This concept was popular in pre-WW2 British Socialism and India served as a huge experiment. While some of this has been removed you can still see it all over Indias economic policies today. India is still a far, far away from any sort of free market economy or liberal political order. > (Also relevant, in the 20s and 30s, USSR came from a shithole agricultural country with no industry, to the second biggest industrial economy of the world). Its is another bunch of nonsense socialist myth making. The trope of Imperial Russia being a backwards shithole then as soon as Soviets take over its some paradise is nothing but Communist propaganda. In fact before WW1 Russia was one of the fasted growing nations, that itself was one of the reasons for WW1 as the Germans realized that within a generation Russia would probebly match or be more powerful then them. If you look at Russia WW1 economy, you will see that in terms of manufacturing it actually performed incredibly well. They had a problem with food distriubtion and political authority, more then with production. The Imperial Russian economy was already one of the biggest industrial countries by a lot of different measures. This is clearly confirmed when you look at the weapons output during WW1. In the 20s Soviet economy first of all starved millions of people and only by the end of the 20s did they reach pre-war levels of output. From 1928 they started collectivisation and even more agressive industrialisation, but it should be noted that it required millions of people dead, many more millions put into forced labor and massive starvation of the whole population to export grain and thus import pretty much everything from the West. To make a point of this, the Soviets literally copied US and German factories and payed tons of money for them and then used lots of forced labor to build them. Putting that as some great success of centralised planning is dubious to me. And this great plan also didn't lead to much improvment for the actual people, it was primarly about the production of military equipment.
- littlestymaar 6y ago> After WW2 India adopted a diliberatly socialst agenda, often called Indian Socialism the was all about top down managment of all markets with heavy government guidence and intervention. Yes, and with tremendous success (literacy exploded, and starvation plummeted), but such movement is long dea and now. For the past 30 years Indian economic policies have been heavily inspired by the western “neoliberal” trend (which is itself heavily inspired by Hayek's work) . And looking back how China where in 1980 and how they are now is quite telling. Five-years plans really add up in the long run… But if you don't like the comparison with India (which, now I realize, is pretty ill-advised in this period of nationalist tensions between both countries …), you could do the same with most Western countries and still be astonished how China went and how stagnant we have been. > And this great plan also didn't lead to much improvment for the actual people, it was primarly about the production of military equipment. You are mixing up periods: here you are referring to the cold war era (with the arm race with the US) but that wasn't the case at all pre WWII (and they didn't really started the war with stockpiles of new weapons to say the least…).
- nickik 6y agoThere is a lot of talk about India and the freeing up of the economy. However it is quite clear that there is a massive legacy there. All that said, I think the diversity and distributed power structure in India could not be overcome by any purely economic philosophy. About China we should also mentioned that decreasing the control over the economy is what allowed them to grow. Current policy in China is much more like the West then it was under Mao or afterwards. So success came by reducing control over the economy and to reintroduce private property. Market economy today is as powerful in China as it ever was in the history of China by far. China so far has profited from massive catch up growth and China is not unique in that, just much bigger. The same thing happened with the Asian Tigers. China is now starting to pull ahead in some technologies, but it has yet to be seen if how far that is possible. People also thought Japan would blow past US and the West. In the end if you have a reasonable competent government and a reasonable market economy with reasonable polices regarding global trade you will likely end up on the same overall growth path of all the advanced economies. If China manages to avoid this keep growing after the have reached per person parity, I would be incredibly impressed and it would challenge my thinking on economics. > You are mixing up periods I am talking about the pre-WW2 period where production was overwhelmingly focused on everything needed for military production. There were exceptions like housing construction but the overwhelming focus was military buildup.
- humanrebar 6y agoThe Uighurs and Ukrainians might disagree that your examples are adequate.
- tumetab1 6y agoI would say that China prosperity is very related to the Free Economic Zones which allows for non-centrally planned zones within China.
- postingawayonhn 6y ago> liberal countries like India India is probably the most bureaucratic country on earth. It may be a democracy but that does not mean it is economically more liberal than China.
- littlestymaar 6y agoAnd it inherited this taste for bureaucracy from the British Empire, which was the former biggest bureaucracy in the world while being economically very liberal.
- bhupy 6y ago> And China's economic failure compared to liberal countries like India is a great illustration of that. Oh wait… China's success is actually a very powerful illustration of this, in fact. Through the 1980s-1990s, China went through dramatic economic reform, and the results largely speak for themselves[1]. Before the reforms, the Chinese economy was dominated by state ownership and central planning. From 1950 to 1973, Chinese real GDP per capita grew at a rate of 2.9% per year on average, albeit with major fluctuations stemming from the Great Leap Forward and the Cultural Revolution. This placed it near the middle of the Asian nations during the same period, with neighboring capitalist countries such as Japan, South Korea and rival Chiang Kai-shek's Republic of China outstripping the PRC's rate of growth. Starting in 1970, the economy entered into a period of stagnation, and after the death of Mao Zedong, the Communist Party leadership turned to market-oriented reforms to salvage the failing economy. The first stage, in the late 1970s and early 1980s, involved the de-collectivization of agriculture, the opening up of the country to foreign investment, and permission for entrepreneurs to start businesses. However, 87% industry remained state-owned. The second stage of reform, in the late 1980s and 1990s, involved the privatization and contracting out of much state-owned industry, followed by the 1985 lifting of price controls. The private sector grew to the extent that it accounted for as much as 70% of China's gross domestic product by 2005. From 1978 until 2013, unprecedented growth occurred, with the economy increasing by 9.5% a year. India actually experienced a similar trajectory — from 1947 until the late 80s/early 90s, India's economic system was described as "Nehruvian socialism". It was more derogatorily called a "License Raj"[2]. Under the License Raj, India's annual economic growth rate stagnated around 3.5% from the 1950s to 1980s, while per capita income averaged 1.3%. In the same period, Pakistan grew by 5%, Indonesia by 9%, Thailand by 9%, South Korea by 10% and Taiwan by 12%. Before 2015, India grew at a slower pace than China, which had been liberalizing its economy since 1978. In 2015, India's GDP growth outpaced that of China. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_economic_reform https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_economic_reform [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Licence_Raj https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Licence_Raj
- logicchains 6y ago>And China's economic failure compared to liberal countries like India is a great illustration of that. Better to compare China to Korea, Singapore, Hong Kong and Taiwan, which all started at a similar position (and have similar cultures), but now those others all have way higher GDP per capita than China.
- burntoutfire 6y agoChina started thriving in early 80ties precisely because they considerably loosened the central planning. For example, they allowed plant directors to have some input into what a plant is going to produce and into setting prices of their products. Beforehand, it was all decided centrally, with plenty of absurdities unimaginable for Western people. One tiny example is the shortage of bread in Poland in the eighties, which was caused by the centrally set price of bread being lower than the price of the ingredients... So, bakeries did everything to bake as little bread as possible, to minimize their losses - resulting in a nation-wide shortage. There's actually a whole subgenre of comedy in Polish cinema, focusing on realities in living in a centrally planned economy.
- cafard 6y agoRussia's industrial power before WW I was larger than a lot of people remember.
- Digory 6y agoThe fore-mentioned EconTalk recently had a discussion of China’s centralized politics but relatively open economy. Less than 10% of Chinese agriculture employment is in state owned enterprises now, for example. https://www.econtalk.org/branko-milanovic-on-capitalism-alone/#audio-highlights https://www.econtalk.org/branko-milanovic-on-capitalism-alon...