5 ms·
Simple. Geeks respect and understand the scientific method. Anything that cannot be observed and tested is considered speculation and not fact. Being an atheis
by petercooper 18y ago
Simple. Geeks respect and understand the scientific method. Anything that cannot be observed and tested is considered speculation and not fact.
Being an atheist in no mean requires that you remain an atheist forever. Scientists have believed, at many times, in things that we now know are not strictly correct. Once evidence arrives and experiments are performed, scientific consensus changes.
- reazalun 18y agoI know several atheists (some of them are scientists) who became Islam, Christian, etc, because they need HOPE in life. And they did not have to wait until science provides them the evidences that show God does exist.
- petercooper 18y agoIf you choose to ignore science and logic in one area of your life, that is your choice and not necessarily a bad thing. It is often necessary psychologically to hide from the truth, but it doesn't make the untrue any more true. Some people find it impossible to accept or not accept all manner of things, but whether or not you accept or do not accept something does not change whether or not that something is true.
- robg 18y agoUnfortunately though we put too much faith in the scientific method. I'm still waiting for an adequate explanation of Gravity but I believe in it.
- albertcardona 18y agoA few years ago I was arguing with a mormon that, if he wanted some scientific theory to attack with bile, he'd have his best shot at gravity. Evolution, on the other hand, has been very well explained from all possible fronts. The problem with gravity is that, as a daily experience, it fades out into uninteresting routine (except perhaps for rocket scientists and other specialists.)
- sauvage 18y agoI've always found it extremely ironic that the religious crowd (yes, I know I'm over-generalizing) spends so much time arguing against evolution, which has nothing whatsoever to say about gods or the origins of life. But they say nothing about quantum mechanics, which not only elegantly eliminates the need for any sort of "prime mover", but blows the possibility of a god existing completely out of the water.
- gizmo 18y agoColor of bike-shed.
- time_management 18y agoHow does quantum mechanics "blow the possibility of a god existing completely out of the water"? This is why I believe in God: based on some unusual personal experiences that made it difficult to reject the supernatural, I came to the conclusion at one point that, in fact, consciousness is not an illusion, and that there is no such thing as randomness, and that our course along the quantum "tree" is chosen by some being for a purpose (or purposes). This doesn't mean that we live in a deterministic world, but that we live in a physical one that is constantly taking "pushes" from a spiritual beings. This seems supernatural and unlikely, but if we believe that the spirit (consciousness) is not an illusion, then we accept that a complex physical system, the brain, can be affected by a spiritual entity, human consciousness, and so it doesn't seem implausible that there are other spiritual beings among us, doing things like rigging the seemingly "random" collisions of particles so that 10^-20000 improbabilities (life) actually happen. This, coupled with the direct experience of mystics, makes it likely that there are vastly superior spiritual beings in existence, which could be construed as gods or facets of God.
- gizmo 18y agoFirst of all - you should disregard unusual personal experiences if you don't know of any way to repeat them. I dream. I even start halucinating when I don't sleep enough. People can even dream and halucinate under fairly ordinary circumstances. Given the tendency for people to halucinate, I see no reason to seek for supernatural explanations. "Human consciousness" doesn't need to be something metaphysical. The brain is basically a big petri dish. Chemical reactions everywhere. Our understanding of it is poor, but we're making lots of progress. We know which regions serve which purpose, and we can make people laugh or cry by sticking electrodes in somebody's head during brain surgery. We can see people enjoying music, by watching electrical activity, and we can see how brains of savants differ from ours. The more we learn, the less of a mystery the brain becomes. But we still have 95% to explain. As you make computer programs more complex you realize that sooner or later you have to start meta-programming. Only by making a program introspect itself or the system around it can you give it additional functionality. Windows Vista is a good example - it's all about processing watching other processes work. Watching memory patterns, to improve cache efficiency. Monitoring which programs are run often. Watching which clusters on the hard drive are suspiciously unresponsive. Meta. Meta meta meta. Windows Vista is conscious in the sense that it feels when programs are unresponsive, or when the system has trouble shutting down. And it will try to take measures to fix it. Isn't this just basic consciousness? Nothing spiritual about it. And when you can explain consciousness by just saying it's a function of complexity of a brain we have a pretty plausible answer. Does your cell phone have consciousness? Yes, but very little. Less than an ant, probably. How about babies? Yes, but only as much consciousness as a cat. How about a rock? Yes, about as much consciousness as a "Hello World" program. That's simply no consciousness at all. Consciousness doesn't need to be a binary switch. A spark that people get at some point. A "soul" doesn't explain anything. You probably don't agree with the way I frame my answers. So what's do you think the difference is between the capacity for introspection (think about self) and consciousness?
- gizmo 18y agoThe scientific method is used to make educated guesses based on prior evidence. Using newton's models we have figured out how (and why) planets orbit the sun, why objects fall equally quickly in a vacuum, etc. The scientific method has nothing to do with finding absolute answers. Still we're able to accomplish remarkable things simply by testing what works and what doesn't. Man on moon. Proves pretty conclusively that it's not about having ultimate answers, it's about having a model of the world that's so awesome you can stick people on a giant rocket and hurl them into space without anything going boom. For every answer a scientist gives you you can answer a more specific question, until the scientist answers; "I don't know". Always. The ultimate answer is always "don't know". But every decade or so we have one extra answer in the chain of knowledge before we have to admit we don't know.
- petercooper 18y agoProving that something exists is the first step, before getting an "adequate explanation." The scientific method already proves that gravity exists. It doesn't matter if we don't have an explanation for it, but it exists. The same cannot be said for a god / gods at this stage.
- tokipin 18y agohere's an explanation of gravity http://www.amazon.com/Gravitation-Physics-Charles-W-Misner/dp/0716703440/ref=pd_bbs_sr_2?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1215294514&sr=8-2 http://www.amazon.com/Gravitation-Physics-Charles-W-Misner/d... long story short, gravity is the curvature of spacetime. objects of mass cause the curvature, and the curvature in turn causes objects to move locally along geodesics (shortest-distance paths), which causes the curvature to shift when you throw a ball and it's moving through a parabola, that curve taken with time in a riemannian space is actually the straightest line possible from one end of the throw to the other this is Einstein's magnum opus General Relativity
- icey 18y agoFrankly, I believe that a lot of people who call themselves Athiests are in fact Agnostics; and don't really stop to think about the difference. I would venture to guess that most scientists especially are agnostic because it fits the scientific method better - we can not presume to know what we cannot measure, and all that. Atheism is the idea that we know that there is know higher power. Any scientist has to know that it is impossible to have that absolute knowledge because we have no tests to prove or disprove the hypothesis.
- randallsquared 18y agoThere is some confusion here, I'll agree. I made the argument earlier in this thread that not only do we have no tests to prove or disprove theism, we cannot have any such tests, because theism and atheism are statements about what's beyond our (philosophical) universe. Any god you can formulate a test for isn't really God-the-Creator-of-All in the first place. So, belief in God, or the lack thereof, is just an assumption. This assumption will influence your actions, of course, and belief or the absence of it may well be beneficial or harmful. Either you live your life as if God exists, or you don't. If you don't, you might as well call yourself an atheist... and that's why I do.
- icey 18y agoThe difference is subtle: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agnostic http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agnostic http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atheism http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atheism And largely an exercise in classification. Still, it's handy knowledge to have, should you enjoy that sort of thing.
- maw 18y agoI disagree. I think most atheists are, strictly speaking, agnostics (even if some may not know the term agnostic). When pressed, we'll concede that, no, we don't _really_ know whether a Creator exists. However, our doubts are so very small that, for all practical purposes, it's more convenient, and not really any less honest, to think and argue as though we were entirely sure. Conversely, I think that intellectually honest believers have a similar but opposite belief. Although, as a nonbeliever myself, I have a hard time putting myself in their shoes, or my brain inside their skulls, so maybe I'm mistaken here.