4 ms·
Sure, until you get hit by a 10,000-ip-strong botnet all trying to fill out your form at once.
by eli 16y ago
Sure, until you get hit by a 10,000-ip-strong botnet all trying to fill out your form at once.
- harrybr 16y agoThe article states that Animoto use "honeypot fields and timestamp analysis" instead of CAPTCHAs, which they claim has been effective to date. What do you think of this?
- kia 16y agoIf the attack is specifically against your site these won't help.
- RyanMcGreal 16y agoIf timestamp analysis is effective now, it won't be forever. It would be trivially easy to program an autofiller to leave pseudo-random pauses between filling individual fields. If this becomes a much more common technique, the spammers will adapt.
- JonnieCache 16y agoThis will greatly reduce the rate at which they are able to send the spam though, even if the delay is tiny. Similar to how bcrypt works.
- eli 16y agoI use honeypot fields myself and they stop a ton of spam submissions. I'm sure timestamp analysis can be very effective too. I'm totally a fan. But are there bots smart enough to defeat it? You bet! Some of my forms also have a CAPTCHA. I think it's got to be case-by-case. Do you have something desirable to bad guys (like the signup for a new Yahoo account, or a high-ranking blog about pharmaceuticals)? Do you have tools in place to deal with spam submissions effectively when they do occur? Will a bunch of bots signing up for accounts degrade service for legitimate visitors? For example, the Contact our Sales team form definitely does not have a CAPTCHA. The sales team will gladly sort though a pile of junk if it means one more inbound lead. But the Post a Comment form would be an absolute disaster without a strong CAPTCHA. A surprising amount of junk gets through anyway, in fact. (As far as I can tell, it's actual humans in developing countries copy/pasting into comments by hands. Blocking referrers from Google that have the phrase "post a comment below" made a dent)
- larrik 16y ago"Blocking referrers from Google that have the phrase "post a comment below" made a dent)" Can you elaborate? I haven't heard this technique (I don't personally have a lot of need for spam fighting), and I'm very curious as to what you mean.
- 5l 16y agoThink he probably means spammers are searching for the phrase 'post a comment below' on Google looking for forms they can spam. You'll see this search term in the HTTP referrer header. Edit: obviously you could just avoid using this phrase on your site instead.
- larrik 16y agoAh, that makes sense, and is rather clever. Thanks
- OstiaAntica 16y agoWarning on Honeypots-- some mobile devices like Blackberry seem to trigger them on our service.