3 ms·
"'Quipus can be traced back to China, and the fact that our indigenous people also utilized the quipu as a means of communication implies there should have been
by tokenadult 16y ago
"'Quipus can be traced back to China, and the fact that our indigenous people also utilized the quipu as a means of communication implies there should have been a direct contact among the two cultures,' said Vega."
I call B.S. on this. I've studied Chinese history extensively (Chinese language was my undergraduate major, along with many elective courses in linguistics) and there is no evidence that knotted cords (attested in a few ancient Chinese texts for keeping tallies) had any role in recording language. There is also not good evidence of any pre-Columbian trade or other contact between China and Central America.
- vyrotek 16y agoApparently other people think there is a connection. I'm not sure what the sources are, but it seems there are a few places that had similar things. http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1G1-239461704.html?key=01-42160D517E1A1760170C0318066A4B2E224E324D3417295C30420B61651B617F137019731B7B1D6B39 http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1G1-239461704.html?key=01-42160D... The Romans used knotted strings for tax collecting at least into the second century A.D., and there are references to a quipu-like system used in China around 500 B.C. Knotted strings are still used in rural areas of Okinawa, Hawaii, and West Africa.
- troymc 16y agoIndeed, it's very common for something to be invented independently in different places. (Some would go farther, citing evidence that independent simultaneous invention is, in fact, the rule rather than the exception.) Further reading: http://www.kk.org/thetechnium/archives/2009/08/progression_of.php http://www.kk.org/thetechnium/archives/2009/08/progression_o...
- asolove 16y agoA better way to say this would be: knotted cords are definitely attested in classical Chinese texts, they just tend to be the kind of texts that aren't trustworthy as actual history. The standard mythical history of Chinese says that knotted cords predated written language, and that a mythical figure invented the Chinese writing system after observing the tracks of birds. Given widespread evidence of cord-tying used to keep tallies, it sounds like this doesn't prove any connection to anything.