7 ms·
The iPad is 99% more open than any other computer
- siglesias 16y agoFun fact about the technology: if there can be spam, there will be spam. If there can be porn, there will be porn. If there can be malware, there will be malware. If there can be scams, there will be scams. Apple's goal is that these things can't be. Their solution is the top down approach and App Store. Other platforms will (or will not) have other solutions. It's really that simple.
- mhd 16y ago…for some values of "open".
- dazzla 16y agoI think this is a description of accessibility not openness.
- arctangent 16y agoThe author of the article is making the point that the device is "more open" because although it has a lower "unit openness" it is appealing to more people, thus raising the "total openness". http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Utilitarianism http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Utilitarianism
- lukeschlather 16y ago>By giving people freedom to explore the app store without having to worry about anything (except their wallets), Apple has possibly made the best move they could make by locking down the iPad’s installation sources. What a brave new world that has such people in it.
- CaptainZapp 16y agoInteresting, I wanted to comment along the line of Hate is Love War is Peace etc ... Brave new world (in combination with Newspeak) just about captures it.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- StavrosK 16y agoGiven that Brave New World described a utopia, I think "Hate is Love" is the only way to put what the article's saying.
- cpr 16y agoYes, he's equivocating "open" with "more freedom to explore without fear", which is understandable for an enthusiastic 14-year-old. ;-) But he's making the same point that others have made, that freedom from worry about virii/spam/etc is a real advantage over the absolute openness of the web or desktop worlds, at least for non-geek population.
- lukeschlather 16y agoWell, I think Brave New World is particularly applicable because the same basic philosophy which supports Apple's actions also supports the belief that Huxley's dystopia is in fact a utopia. Obviously there's a difference of scale, but there's still the same sense. If people are content to be protected from smut and 'evil' speech, why do they need to have complete freedom to choose for themselves?
- cpr 16y agoNo, now you're equivocating the rather trivial matter (in the big picture of real life) of protection from sketchy apps with stifling freedom of speech in real life. You can always access the sketchy stuff on your Android or general web browser. There's no real lack of freedom. And, personally, beyond whatever moral objections I might have to porn on the app store, it's always associated with bottom-feeder and generally sketchy behaviors (they obviously don't have any qualms about making money any way they can), and I'm glad I don't have to deal with that. (Let the downvoting begin! ;-)
- mhd 16y agoBefore I noticed the age of the author, I was hoping that someone is pulling a Swift on us here. NB: Imagine you've got an app store + additional ways to install applications. Why would this increase the worries of teenagers? (Their parents & teachers might think otherwise.) I certainly never got depressed in school by swapping around floppy disks of pirated games…
- maxharris 16y agoBefore I noticed the age of the author So you're saying he must be wrong just because you're older than him? This can't be right because I'm 30 and I agree with him. It doesn't seem like age is the critical factor here. If I happen to be older than you, should I be able to dismiss anything you say as youthful naivety?
- mhd 16y agoThe incorrectness of the argument was never in doubt for me, to be honest. I was merely wondering whether this was out of naivety or a cynical parody. And in this day and age (and especially on the internets) I'm more prone to assume cynicism. Until I reread the first few paragraphs.
- Rhapso 16y agoA Brave New World indeed, now to make sure everybody finishes Huxley's book, and does not just think about how cool the the first few chapters are.
- pbourke 16y ago> What a brave new world that has such people in it. And read the Tempest, as well - that's what Huxley references in the title.
- dutchrapley 16y agoWell said. It's not about the platform or OS being open. It's about opening up possibilities for people. One way Apple did this was with the App Store. Apple didn't create this model for distributing apps, they simply discovered it, allowing more people to discover what is possible. The same goes for the App Store on OS X. I, personally, have discovered a couple of applications I otherwise wouldn't have.
- tomlin 16y agoI upvoted because I dig the psychological aspect of the article -- The teenage market is where I like to turn for a prediction of where the general market will be in a few years. Because while teens aren’t nerdy, they tend to be early adopters because it’s cool But the argument about openness is greatly flawed.
- mrspandex 16y agoNow, I am a fairly young person myself, but the author is in 8th grade. I'm not sure he's qualified to talk about changes in the market over a few years.
- runako 16y agoThat's what they told Gates and Jobs. :-)
- bagelicious 16y agoIt's the innate understanding of the market viewed from a teenage perspective--they already count Microsoft out.
- sp332 16y agoIt's not too young for an interested person to know this stuff. In the eighth grade, I was already dual-booting Linux on the family computer, was following VA Linux Systems' and Red Hat's IPOs, and was looking for alternatives to MS Office for my school.
- tomlin 16y agoObservation is available to anyone at any age. A person who is outside of the tech bubble may also look at the market from a psychological point of view rather than a pragmatic one.
- fname 16y agoVery much agree about the openness argument. Though, speaking to the quote about teens and prediction, I present this: This is what Motorola and Google and Samsung and BlackBerry and everyone else, with the sole exception of Apple, do not get about “open” computing. It’s powerful, but for ordinary people, it’s too powerful Notice a prominent name missing from that list? If what the author feels is true (and being a teenager himself), this speaks volumes to just how far they are behind the curve.
- delinka 16y agoThe author is 14yo. I am truly stunned at his ability to articulate his experience and opinions to the world. He should be commended for that if nothing else. Now to the topic at hand: I own Apple products and they serve me well. However, I have to agree with dazzla that JP describes accessibility rather than openness.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- dfj225 16y agoI don't think you can reach the conclusion that the iPad is more open than any other platform because one person, who doesn't even own an iPad yet, thinks it does more. Although, it would be interesting to know why the author's friend has that impression. I wouldn't think it's common, at least it isn't in my (admittedly tech savvy) circles.
- roboteti 16y agoI use a specific example because I prefer them. But everyone thinks that, and it's not just teens. All the adults I've talked to all think so too.
- dfj225 16y agoHave you asked why they think that? I'd like to know their reasoning. I certainly understand the allure of the device, I just can't see where the idea of it doing more than they are already doing on their computers comes from, unless they are simply referring to apps that are only available on iPad.
- gfodor 16y agoNot going to say I agree with his point of view, but this is absolutely incredible writing for an 8th grader.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- runjake 16y agoThe kid's 14. Give him a break. I wish I could write as half as well when I was his age. Hell, now.
- sp332 16y agoFree software might be open from a legal standpoint, or even a tech standpoint, but if it's not actually making itself accessible to people, it's still closed. Maybe you can assuage your conscience by sticking a GPL license in your source code directory on your FTP server, but if your users can't actually change anything, it's still closed to them.
- ctdonath 16y agoMy flip-side take of the same idea: sure Linux is "open", but every time I try to really use it, I get mired in obfuscation and decide that shelling out a few bucks will get me a lot closer to my goals a whole lot faster. Kinda like driving vs. walking: sure, moving your feet will take you anywhere - anywhere! - you want to go, but more than a few miles soon becomes impractical ... while the fuel-roads-and-rules limitations of driving can get you almost anywhere up to halfway across the country within a day in comfort. To say walking is more "free" (aka "open") than driving kinda misses something key. And, while we're at it, this kid (!) can download the Xcode IDE, write any software he wants (short of obscenity, libel, or flagrant IP violations) and have it distributed with the greatest of ease to every iOS user who wants it. For just $99 and a percentage he can make a profit to boot. Is something "open" if most people can't get at it?
- jokermatt999 16y agoirrelevant aside, skip if desired At first, I was annoyed because I knew this was going to be the same foolish logic of "It is more free because I am free from worry with it! See, I can use the word free too!" logic that makes me repost that lovely quote from George Orwell's Politics and the English Language about words having contradicting meanings and people arguing over them pointlessly. Then I RTFA and found out it was written by an 8th Grader. Whew, I feel better now. If other people making this argument would realize they were using 8th grade logic as well, I'd feel a lot better about this. Every time I see an adult making an argument stemming from poor understanding of the fact that words have multiple meanings, I want to bonk them over the head with a dictionary while shouting "see definiton (2)!" It is..a pet peeve of mine. irrelevant aside over This is still a terrible argument, because it ignores what the people complaining about the iPad being not open is all about. It has nothing to do with it being open meaning accessible, free meaning with a lack of worry, or any similar semantic strawmen. It has to do with the fact that you cannot put any application you want on an iOS device without Apple's permission. Jailbreaking is not an excuse, and neither is the "you just have to pay $100 a year and join a developer program". Users should be able to install what they want, when they want, without asking anyone's permission. You should own the hardware you purchase. Apple disagrees, and thus iOS devices are not free and open in the sense of being able to do with them as you please.
- glhaynes 16y agoUsers should be able to install what they want, when they want, without asking anyone's permission. You should own the hardware you purchase. Why, though? "Should" is a strong word that implies a more overarching requirement than just a desire on the part of an individual purchaser. I understand that you want to be able to do anything you want with your hardware, and I'm very very glad that there exist systems that you can buy to do this on — I'd be extremely concerned too if all systems became walled gardens, but I don't see any reason to think that there's even a chance of this happening since Android is so very successful — but it's hard for me to see why that requirement "should" be a part of every product. In fact, the idea that this form of openness is some sort of moral imperative (and thus should exist on all systems) ignores the fact that by the same reasoning I should be able to buy a system that trades-off binary-installation freedom for the benefits that come from the closed-down approach.
- mcantelon 16y agoThis kid's coming for you, John Gruber.
- DavidChouinard 16y ago> As you may or may not know, this is my 8th grade year. Interestingly, the sentence that completely blew me away had nothing to do with the argument being made.
- shasta 16y agoI thought the article was terrible, but rather than contribute anything useful, I'm going to mock the title. "99% less open" is idiomatic and means "1/100 as open". It's a round number, conveying an order of magnitude. On the other hand, "99% more open" implies you've measured precisely enough to claim that the iPad is 1.99 times as open as the best alternative. Thank you.
- Pewpewarrows 16y agoThis is a cute read, and as others have stated, it's well-written for a 14 year old. The idea that the iPad is opening up more people to technology than other products though is quite naive. It might get the most press, fan-fair, and attention with an exclusive event to debut it every year, but that doesn't make it any friendlier to non-tech-savvy users than its competitors. Has the author even touched another tablet-like device on the market? The iPad might be "open" in the sense that it is making technology accessible to regular users. But more "open" than the rest? That's the product of good marketing. Sure, the device itself has to stand on its own, but so do its competitors. The media loves to give Apple plenty of attention, and combined with aggressive advertisement its products are now household names.
- drcode 16y ago"There is more than one kind of freedom... Freedom to and freedom from. In the days of anarchy, it was freedom to. Now you are being given freedom from. Don't underrate it." - The Handmaid's Tale
- samlevine 16y agoObligatory: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Negative_and_positive_rights http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Negative_and_positive_rights
- turtle4 16y agoWhy do people get hung up on wording? It is a shame people are just going to dismiss this because he worded it as "open". In reality, what he is saying is that the iPad is more useful than a regular computer, and usefulness trumps openness. As someone who is very technical, is a computer (or ipad) more useful to me if I can install whatever I want, and program it however I want? Yes. Are most users very technical? No. People just want to use their computers to do something, and quickly. Why don't alot of people who aren't comfortable with technology install software? Well, they have experience that they download something and install it, and suddenly their computer runs like crap or they have a virus. They have learned they are better off just to leave it be. That's why so many users just stick with the default. They install something, they get hosed. Again and again. The alternative is to spend a great deal of time determining whether the source is trusted, or official, or whatever. The app store removes that restriction, making it more useful to the -average- user. Apps don't write all over each other, they don't bog down the ipad, and the source is already trusted. Those things mean that a typical user is able to do more, because those are all barriers to -doing something- that don't exist on the iPad that do on other platforms. That's all he is saying. That's the point, and one that people who are building businesses here should recognize. Don't get hung up on wording. You can sit around and argue all day that people should be willing to take the time to understand their devices better, and then they would benefit from a more open system, but you are wasting your breath. People aren't interested in that, by and large. They just want to do something else, and do so without opening themselves up to a giant hassle.
- ZeroGravitas 16y ago"The iPad does everything that a regular computer user does. Facebook. YouTube. Email. Web browsing. It does all this out of the box." Doesn't basically every device with a browser do these out of the box? If we're talking apps I wasn't aware that the iPhone pre-installed Facebook and I didn't think there was an iPad app for Facebook. Is this a new thing? I've heard of Android phones having it installed, even having buttons for it, but I don't remember seeing it on my iPhone.
- roboteti 16y agoFair point. But it does web browsing out of the box and that's all you need for Facebook. And yes, every device does so out of the box. The point is that for an average computer user, it does this out of the box and it does more and they can still figure it out. But you're right about the Facebook thing. Thanks for reading.
- roboteti 16y agoJust a few things (I'm the author). First: I'm kind of blown away that anyone's reading this and thinking about it at all -- including those of you who disagree. Thank you all. Second: I don't want anyone to think that I believe the iPad is more powerful than a regular computer. Several people have said that I think that, and I don't. I know I couldn't survive on just my iPad. But what I am saying is that the iPad is kind of like computer training wheels. For a lot of normal people, it makes it possible for them to explore without worrying. That doesn't mean in any way, shape, or form that all computers should be like that. I don't think so. That would be terrible. We need open computers, but there is a place for that and a place for closed ones, and I think most people do better with a closed one. Finally, I am well aware what the Android folks mean by "openness", and I am deliberately redefining the term. Call it "relative openness" if you care that much. Openness comes at a cost, and unfortunately, it doesn't scale. Have any of you ever watched someone use an Android device? They don't get them. They find them confusing and difficult. They make people hate their electronics because they aren't worth using, and that's no way to push things forward. I would never want to live in a country made and run like iOS, but a country is not the same thing as an electronic device used to communicate with others and the same principles cannot be applied.
- Raphael 16y agoWe need a rich language in order to communicate effectively. By using a term differently than expected in your post, and then mixing it with the original meaning, you're making absolutely no sense. Let's call the iOS interface "accessible" (covering any number of characteristics) and acknowledge the missing feature of "arbitrary installs". I'll grant that Android is not perfect. But the arbitrary install feature does not seem to be the issue. The crucial non-nerdy segment would never need to know about it, as they are free to explore the default market app to their heart's content. In fact, arbitrary installs are disabled by default and have to be enabled from deep in the settings menu. As for the principle of disabling arbitrary installs, it's insulting, like a pair of safety scissors (an inferior product for intended safety).
- roboteti 16y agoMy last comment. I'm sure this will make you guys even more sarcastic, but haters gotta hate: http://jpteti.com/post/4091718756/ipad-followup-post http://jpteti.com/post/4091718756/ipad-followup-post. I hope you folks are glad that I'm no prejudiced (probably unfairly) against all of you because of the behavior of a few.
- mukyu 16y agohaters gonna hate Frankly, it is disturbing how much of 4chan slips into the thoughts and lexicon of today's youth.