10 ms·
I don't get it -- Amex and Discover are still providing healthy competition, so the "duopoly" the author complains about seems to be largely irrelevant. Competi
by crazygringo 6y ago
I don't get it -- Amex and Discover are still providing healthy competition, so the "duopoly" the author complains about seems to be largely irrelevant. Competition between cards is thriving and consumers benefit -- witness the miniscule transaction fee the credit card companies keep after paying your rewards back of 2% to 5%, when you pay your bill on time.
The article's main point is that such large companies are a cybersecurity risk, and that the government should regulate/nationalize/globalize payment infrastructure.
Unfortunately, experience tends to show that governments would be far worse at providing secure, low-cost payment services. Also, credit cards already are highly regulated when it comes to consumer protections.
So, this article is just not making a lot of sense to me.
- briffle 6y agoImagine if companies charged 2-5% less because they didn't have to fund CC company marketing tools like cashbacks.
- newacct583 6y agoIndeed, let's imagine. I'm guessing that the increase in seller revenue and decrease in consumer price would sum to... somewhere between two and five percent. No one cares about numbers like that. That's way, way below the convenience threshold for a typical consumer. Most of us, me included, would rather pay an extra 3.5% than fiddle with deciding on which card to use. Which is to say: the market has spoken. We've settled on the duopoly not because it's a trap but because it actually maximizes utility. The uniform convenience of "credit cards just work" has quantifiable economic value. And it turns out to be somewhere around 2-5% of the transaction.
- crazygringo 6y agoThat is common. My grocery store, my bodega, my doctor's office, my dentist -- they all offer a 5% discount for paying in cash. Obviously not everyone does it, but it's certainly not uncommon. On the other hand, there are also a lot of costs associated with handling cash. The expense of tracking bills and coins and going to the bank every day is not insignificant. So it's pretty easy to argue that there's no reason for cash discounts either, because handling cash can actually be more expensive than handling cards, particularly when you're doing it for only 5 or 10 percent of customers.
- koheripbal 6y agoThat's a little different. They offer discounts of 5% because they then don't report the income and don't pay taxes. The CC companies are only taking 2.5%-3.2%. If they're offering a 5% discount for cash - it's almost certainly tax evasion.
- crazygringo 6y agoYou're forgetting the percentages are on top of a ~$0.30 flat fee (though obviously this varies). So if you buy a $2 Coke, it's not a $0.054 fee (2.7%), it's $0.354 (or a whopping 17.7%). Maybe my dentist evades a few taxes, I dunno. But people buy cheap things at the bodega, so it probably is closer to the actual fees.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoIf the merchant doesn't offer the same cash discount for debit cards, then it's tax evasion. Debit card fees are a few cents, and the only reason to offer a big discount for cash, but not debit cards, is to not have the transaction on paper and hence evade taxes.
- blacklion 6y agoHow could I know are my card credit or debit from system's point of view? I have two cards in my bank, both are exactly same MC cards, embossed, and all (not some Maestro variation). One card is linked with my current account — I have real money at this account, my employer pays my salary by transfer to this account and such. I can not pay if thus account is depleted. Second card is linked with credit account, where I have some limit, and I need to pay off in 28 days after end of each month or I'll pay draconian interest. But cards are exactly the same, with very similar numbers. And I never had any problems with any if these cards, like one works and other doesn't. Is one of my cards debit and other is credit or they are credit both?
- lotsofpulp 6y ago
- deadbunny 6y agoSo, Europe?
- manquer 6y agoThere are payment standards like UPI in India and mobile number based banking , which offer transactions for very less or no cost ( mostly debit driven )
- smart_jackal 6y agoUPI is great and so is NEFT, many other Asian countries are in talks to replicate these successful models in their own countries. Also, India came up with RUPAY which is a great answer to VISA/MasterCard monopoly. But somehow it didn't catch up in usage I think.
- briandear 6y agoBusinesses aren’t required to accept credit cards.
- quacker 6y agoBut it obviously hinders their business if they don't, in the US at least. Even most food trucks typically have Square terminals (or similar) for card transactions. Which leads me to believe that it's generally worth it for businesses, despite the "fees".
- biaachmonkie 6y agoBut since the retailers can't offer discounts for cash transactions, people who pay with cash are being over charged and subsidizing those fees.
- anamexis 6y agoRetailers can offer discounts for cash transactions, per the Durbin Amendment to the Dodd-Frank bill of 2010. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Durbin_amendment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Durbin_amendment
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoIt depends on where you live. 10 states have laws that prohibit or restrict discounts for cash transactions: California, Colorado, Connecticut, Florida, Kansas, Maine, Massachusetts, New York, Oklahoma and Texas. Some of those restrictions have been invalidated by federal courts, but I was somewhat confused about which states were affected.
- komali2 6y agoWeird, because in three of those states (New York, Texas, and California) I have used cash to get a cash discount in the last year. I imagine it's because of lack of enforcement?
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoAll three of those states I believe had their surcharge bans invalidated by federal courts. Texas' law was declared unconstitutional in summer 2018: https://faq.sll.texas.gov/questions/9631 https://faq.sll.texas.gov/questions/9631
- just-ok 6y agoI have definitely personally seen many instances in which you get a discount paying in cash in California. Maybe they get away with it because they technically frame it as charging extra for paying with a card?
- pradn 6y agoCC rewards seem like a indirect regressive tax. Wealthier consumers who can afford to pay on time and have better credit ratings are subsidized by poor consumers who actually use the "credit" part of "credit card".
- cpsempek 6y agoI'm ignorant to CC companies' financials. But I would have thought their revenues are driven by transaction fees, which end up ultimately getting passed down to the buyer through higher prices. Would be interested to learn more though about CC economics. It would indeed be sad if CC rewards operated like a regressive tax, as you say.
- sdenton4 6y agoIf you have poor credit, you get a crappy credit card: low limit, high interest rates, no rewards. If you've got great credit, you get a high limit, slightly-less-astronomical rates, and all the rewards. The cost of the rewards is (as I understand it) mainly carried by the transaction fees, spread out over all purchases everywhere. So you have pointless price increases for people who /don't/ use credit cards (like me) or have poor credit, and the benefits of that 'tax' going to users with good credit (ie, rich people). So, yeah, it's a wealth transfer to people with better credit.
- DevKoala 6y agoI had poor credit at a point in time. I "bought" a credit card to build my credit by putting a deposit. After 1 year of on-time payments I was able to graduate to a credit card with cash back. The system didn't feel punitive to me, and honestly, I had poor credit in the first place because I was irresponsible while in college.
- Gaelan 6y agoOf course, the system is designed to encourage you to be irresponsible in college.
- ummonk 6y agoThe competition between credit card issuers is healthy. It's the payment processor side that isn't (though micropayments seem poised to disrupt the space).
- ravar 6y agoAs someone who has never used visa or mastercard and only discover for credit cards (I do have a visa debit card) I second this sentiment. There is no duopoly from my vantage point.
- dpacmittal 6y agoAmex and discover maybe popular in the US, but rest of the world still has a duopoly. I'd say 90%+ cards in India are visa/mastercard.
- smart_jackal 6y agoIndia also recently introduced RUPAY which is an alternative to VISA/MasterCard duopoly. Don't know about the success and usage of that though.
- matthewdgreen 6y agoEvery time I pay for something in cash at a store, I’m paying for those 2-5% rewards, even though I won’t partake in them. This happens because the credit card companies, by dint of their crushing market power over small retailers, can force stores to charge identical cash and credit prices. I suppose a well-functioning competitive market would fix this problem, but weirdly enough Amex and Discover don’t seem interested on competing to offer a better deal to retailers. Credit card fees and rebates are such an amazing example of how systems can fool human beings. The entire system clearly could not exist in a frictionless, well-functioning marketplace —- but people seem hard pressed to actually figure out how the whole thing works. It’s kind of brilliant.
- akira2501 6y ago> I’m paying for those 2-5% rewards Well.. you're paying a 2-5% higher price, but the merchant gets to keep all of that; it's not as if they have to also pay that fraction into their transaction processor. > I suppose a well-functioning competitive market You ever see retailers that offer a discount card? Like, spend $50 here get $10 off in the future? Typically they'll only offer those for cash transactions. This is why.
- jhloa2 6y agoAnecdotally, I have never once seen those discounts limited to cash transactions in the United States
- matthewdgreen 6y agoIn a properly competitive market the merchant doesn’t really get to keep it. Presumably they set their prices to a value that is X% higher than where they would normally set their prices without the need to pay transaction fees. If exactly half their business is paid in cash/debit and half in credit, then X might be set to something like half of the excess CC transaction fee. Then the credit card customers get to split up all of those rewards amongst themselves, and the cash/debit customers get nothing.
- 6y ago
- analyte123 6y agoThe article (particularly the linked tweet) somewhat addresses your point: Amex and Discover may offer a superficial degree of competition for consumers, but banks have to obey Mastercard and Visa's rules even when it comes to offering bank accounts to merchants, otherwise they (and therefore all their other account holders) can't participate in the 80% of card transactions that are on the Mastercard and Visa networks. If you're a bank who wants their business customers to receive payment via Mastercard, you are not allowed to give a bank account to or otherwise handle payments for anyone on the MATCH list, otherwise Mastercard will shut off your bank's access to their network completely, probably putting you out of business. There is little transparency about how entities end up on this MATCH list. The article does not propose an exact regulation, but the end goal would be that a single company can't arbitrarily shut people out of most of the financial system.
- Polylactic_acid 6y agoI have seen many stories of legal and legitimate businesses for things like weed (legal in the stores location) and legal porn sites getting their merchant accounts shut down because the payment processors just don't want them to deal with it leaving cash as the only option.
- bagacrap 6y agoWeed is still federally illegal in all locations in the US.
- unethical_ban 6y agoGood point that perhaps "regulation" is not a good thing, and that the most free, common payment method is the decentralized one: cash. People laugh about bitcoin, and the implementation surely has its drawbacks, but the idea of a decentralized digital payment system is alluring.
- ElCapitanMarkla 6y agoThe hard reality is there’s a high rate of fraud and chargebacks in a lot of these types of businesses. It’s a tricky one for the merchants to manage but things like 3DS2 should help, maybe, if they ever sort it out properly...
- argonaut 6y agoI don't get it -- bringing up Amex and Discover is like bringing up Bing and DuckDuckGo when people talk about the Google monopoly.
- danhak 6y agoI was curious if this was true so I looked it up. AmEx + Discover have 20% - 25% market share depending on the metric you care about. Bing + DDG have 8% https://wallethub.com/edu/cc/market-share-by-credit-card-network/25531/ https://wallethub.com/edu/cc/market-share-by-credit-card-net... https://gs.statcounter.com/search-engine-market-share/all/united-states-of-america https://gs.statcounter.com/search-engine-market-share/all/un...
- argonaut 6y agoThe stats are all over the place. This report says Amex + Discover is ~11% of US purchase volume in 2019. https://nilsonreport.com/publication_chart_and_graphs_archive.php https://nilsonreport.com/publication_chart_and_graphs_archiv...
- quacker 6y agoThe article references [1] which says, "Visa holds a 60% share of the credit and debit card market, followed by Mastercard with 30%, according to Ellis, with American Express far behind at 8.5%." That puts Discover + AmEx at 10% or so. 1. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-visa-mastercard-stocks/swiping-their-way-higher-visa-mastercard-could-be-the-next-1-trillion-companies-idUSKBN1ZU0JA https://www.reuters.com/article/us-visa-mastercard-stocks/sw...
- numpad0 6y agoAlso it’s like bringing up search alone when talking about web. In reality an intermediary called “payment processor” handle all CC brands in single system and they are the ones enforcing ideological punishments to merchants. Like there’s web search and web browser, card networks and payment processors both should be brought up.
- dayaz36 6y agoDid you even read the article? Visa and Master Card own 90% of the market. Discover has ~1%. I wouldn't call that competition let alone THRIVING competition...
- adultSwim 6y agoNo one uses or takes those.
- giancarlostoro 6y agoSure Amex and Discover provide alternatives but if you want to start a credit card company you dont get to tag team with those two at all as far as I can tell. Which I think is a bigger problem. If you as a bank want to start your own credit card you have to go for the most supported provider to even attract potential credit card holders.