3 ms·
> But if so, what new does that reveal, what does it tell you that is useful and not already known? How does it help do the math? It dramatically changes your
by bsder 6y ago
> But if so, what new does that reveal, what does it tell you that is useful and not already known? How does it help do the math?
It dramatically changes your emphasis even if you can't predict in advance.
If we have a uniform spreading, then we have to heavily lock down everything and we have to be invasive about contact tracing. We have to worry obsessively about anyone with human contact in the service industry. We have to keep people at home except for the most imperative of reasons. We have to trace even the most casual of contacts if someone gets diagnosed.
If it's mostly superspreaders, then we only really have to be careful about gatherings--sports, church, theaters, etc. We can trace in response to an outbreak because we're likely to know who is driving it. And reasonable protection measures (like wearing a mask) protect service workers against incidental contact from most contagious people.
This is the difference between massive shutdown and actually getting back to life but with some precautions.
The problem is that superspreaders are that way because they both emit high viral loads (for whatever reason) AND engage in behaviors that encourage the transmission of the diseases.
And, funny that AIDS was mentioned, because it seems like one particularly attractive, promiscuous flight attendant was responsible for a lot of the initial AIDS transmission--a classic superspreader.
- giardini 6y agoNothing you said is useful(in the USA at least): we aren't going to do "contact tracing", we aren't going to "keep people at home" unless they want to stay at home. We can't "diagnose" anyone b/c the testing is too slow. So everything you talk about is moot, beside the point, and useless in the current context (which will not change). And in particular, everything about the "superspreader" concept is useless in improving our situation vis-a-vis Covid-19. And in reference to your AIDS story: I'm familiar with it, so is almost everyone else and HOW THE F* DOES IT PROVIDE INSIGHT INTO OR GUIDANCE IN OUR CURRENT SITUATION? (Please do not answer - that is what is termed a "rhetorical question" - one intended not to be answered, but to make a point known).
- bsder 6y ago> Nothing you said is useful(in the USA at least): we aren't going to do "contact tracing", we aren't going to "keep people at home" unless they want to stay at home. We can't "diagnose" anyone b/c the testing is too slow. New York and the states surrounding it prove you wrong. New York, in particular, has almost 100% contact tracing due to 10,000 contact tracers. They also have a positive test rate of about 1% which indicates that they are testing all the people that need it and then some. New York has an R0 < 1.0. This could be contained, even in the US. Even at this late date. But hey, what's the point in arguing with someone who is impervious to facts that disagree with their predetermined political narrative? No need to answer. That's a rhetorical question.