7 ms·
In a word: "no." In some more words: I don't see the problem. Reddit is a private organization, they decided some other people are not welcome there, that is
by mulmen 6y ago
In a word: "no."
In some more words:
I don't see the problem. Reddit is a private organization, they decided some other people are not welcome there, that is their prerogative. Hateful racists can go start their own forum, which they did. They are free to welcome other viewpoints or not.
In specific words:
> The last wave of bans across multiple platforms have got me thinking that we're on a bad version of the Internet.
We aren't, people are free to conduct their own business as they see fit. It's still the Internet.
> In general, I dont like shutting up the opposition and with traffic consolidated so heavily on a few platforms/companies, bans effectively shut people up.
Great, you can run your own forum and amplify the voice of whoever you want. Other people are free to moderate their platforms as they please.
> On the other hand, I cant deny that even the most outrageous claims find willing ears on the internet. Diseases that were all but exterminated are now flourishing in Europe thanks to anti-vax propaganda.
Right.
> Is there a middle-ground here, where people can speak their minds, engage with others - likeminded or not - without the damaging effects? Or are we destined to end in some form of dictatorship where 10 people determine who says what?
The internet is the middle ground. I see no reason we are destined to end in some form of "dictatorship", unless we maintain this insistence that all platforms have to allow all speech.
> And what happens when we no longer agree with these 10 people? Can we even get to that point if the entire narrative is so heavily controlled?
You can just... use the Internet. Register your own domain, pay for your own hosting, or buy some servers, take out come ads. It's the Internet, you can still do anything.
Sure, if you host a bunch of white nationalist toxic garbage your registrar may revoke your domains. Your hosting provider may pull the plug on your servers, etc. That's exactly how it should and does work.
- knasmai 6y ago> You can just... use the Internet It's also important to note that discovering content on the Internet today is mostly done using platforms controlled by one or more of these 10 people.
- mulmen 6y agoThat's not how it works. Platforms like Reddit and Facebook do the opposite of what you describe. They are walled gardens that go out of their way to prevent you from escaping to the open Internet.
- core-questions 6y agoThat's actually pretty much what they were saying.
- vitejose 6y ago> You can just... use the Internet. Register your own domain, pay for your own hosting, or buy some servers, take out come ads. It's the Internet, you can still do anything. Agreed. The infrastructure is there, and running a web server is pretty straightforward. > Sure, if you host a bunch of white nationalist toxic garbage your registrar may revoke your domains. I am not a die-hard "free speech" guy (especially when it comes to something as repugnant as white nationalism), but I do find the idea of having my domains suspended/revoked by my registrar a bit troubling. Let's say that someone wishes to publish material that no registrar wants to be associated with. Is the only option in that case to simply have no domain name? Just an IP or onion address? There's no Let's Encrypt for domains, right?
- mulmen 6y agoI suppose you can start your own registrar but I'm not really gonna make that argument because clearly that's a major barrier. It's arguably the weakest point in the current internet model. On the other hand yeah, you can still use the Internet without domains. And I guess it's an opportunity for someone to invent a new technology which will make the internet even stronger. So while I don't think the internet is perfect I definitely don't think we need to tear it down or even make any huge changes. It's already really flexible and the few weak points (like domain registrars) are fixable and would benefit everyone.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- core-questions 6y ago> Reddit is a private organization It's not okay to allow "the front page of the internet" to exist in stark opposition to the free speech values (a) that it started with and (b) of the country it is incorporated in. This bullshit, corporate-toady argument of "oh mwaaah it's a private corporation they can do whatever they want" is worse than any "bootlicker" attitude I can think of. Go ahead and give up the freedoms my ancestors fought for so that you can feel just a little bit more comfortable in your echo chamber. Never mind that it runs on infrastructure that is often paid for with public funds, on a network designed by a government that ostensibly believes in free speech. > Sure, if you host a bunch of white nationalist toxic garbage your registrar may revoke your domains. So you're totally fine with giving private, unregulated companies carte blanche to control people's ability to even register their own site? You'll reap what you sow. At some point whatever you think will also become unacceptable, and there will be nobody to stand for you.
- mulmen 6y ago> It's not okay to allow "the front page of the internet" to exist in stark opposition to the free speech values (a) that it started with and (b) of the country it is incorporated in. It's totally ok to allow that because it's a private organization. Reddit is free to claim they are from Alpha Centauri too. They can call themselves whatever they want. It up to you and me to decide if we believe them. > This bullshit, corporate-toady argument of "oh mwaaah it's a private corporation they can do whatever they want" is worse than any "bootlicker" attitude I can think of. Go ahead and give up the freedoms my ancestors fought for so that you can feel just a little bit more comfortable in your echo chamber. Never mind that it runs on infrastructure that is often paid for with public funds, on a network designed by a government that ostensibly believes in free speech. And what about the contributions of my ancestors? Or is that not relevant? Reddit is free to amplify whatever speech they want, or not, that's exactly what those freedoms you claim ownership of are promising. > So you're totally fine with giving private, unregulated companies carte blanche to control people's ability to even register their own site? Well, domain registrars are regulated. Also, I did not say I am ok with the amount of control registrars have. Please do note that these banned subreddits immediately were able to register domains. So while I agree this is a weak point in the current model I don't think it is an existential threat in 2020, especially because the Internet works even without domains. > You'll reap what you sow. At some point whatever you think will also become unacceptable, and there will be nobody to stand for you. I'm comfortable with my beliefs and my ability to introspect and change. And I am comfortable with the inherent conflict.
- bitwize 6y ago> You can just... use the Internet. Register your own domain, pay for your own hosting, or buy some servers, take out come ads. It's the Internet, you can still do anything. Until CloudFlare -- or MasterCard -- bans you because they don't like what you say. No matter -- just start your own upstream services provider or credit card processing company.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mulmen 6y agoSure, or invent a new way to pay for things. Or stop saying things that get you banned. Nobody has a right to a CDN or a credit card or a domain name.
- eaandkw 6y agoCan't wait to go down this road. Hey you don't like it. Just become a doctor and fix yourself. Healthcare isn't a right. Hey you don't like it. Just get you own water, filter it, and clean it. Clean water isn't a right. Is this really the answer?
- lazyjones 6y ago> Reddit is a private organization, they decided some other people are not welcome there So, if they decided to openly ban Trump supporters, or perhaps Muslims, or black people, that would be OK also? Where do you draw the line? In my opinion, all of these are just as discriminating as what they did so far.
- austincheney 6y agoYes, that would be ok because it’s a private platform. They can ban who ever they want. If you find that problematic then don’t go there. I don’t. Where do we draw the line? We don’t. They do, because it’s a private platform.
- TheOperator 6y ago>you can just... Use the internet I don't get why you made this argument and then immediately rebutted it in the next paragraph. If people with enough power dislike a group of people enough, in this case white nationalists, they can be marginalized to the point they're making TOR websites. The idea that censoring free speech isn't a problem because people can just start their own website is about as naive as free speech absolutism is. It trivializes censorship. If a major platform banned all lgbt discussion on the pretense it was no big deal because peoole could start their own website nobody would have any of it despite the fact that the only thing that had changed is the target. Realistically censorship haalways been part of the internet and human society more broadly, it's an inevitability. The broad issues I'm concerned with is concentration of power over speech and increasing echo chambers in online communities. Reddit has shifted more and more towards central control including implicit threats for moderators/communities who step out of line.
- mulmen 6y agoI understand your echo chamber argument but I don’t find it compelling. I think preserving freedom of expression specifically and liberty in general is more important than forcing ideas on people against their will and the foundation of our society. The question was “do we need a new internet” the answer to which is “no.” In my opinion. I don’t care if a bunch of hateful racists are marginalized by private organizations. The problem here is not the network, the problem is people who want to force their ideas on everyone. Luckily our technical and social systems are both resistant to such threats.