6 ms·
I wonder if Apple would be ok with asking them to give up their email? Apple clearly likes the idea of the hide option... personally I would expect a less than
by duxup 6y ago
I wonder if Apple would be ok with asking them to give up their email?
Apple clearly likes the idea of the hide option... personally I would expect a less than positive reception from Apple.
I get where both AnyList (if they asked) and Apple (if they didn't like it) would be coming from here.
It does seem to be a shortcoming here where outside of a user one time sign up situation... you don't want to have to burden the user with coming up with silly names and codes to use social like features that require someone else knowing an identifier for you that isn't email.
I don't want to go back to a time where we have to remember / pass along everyone's ICQ number. ...
- whateveracct 6y agoI don't think Apple would care about asking for email for legitimate use. I thought the point of Sign in with Apple is that it decouples giving away your email from signing up. Not that it bans apps from collecting emails in any way.
- duxup 6y agoI hope so.
- crispyporkbites 6y agoWhy should Apple be allowed to dictate if an app asks for an email address? They should not become the defacto law makers of our society
- duxup 6y agoI'm not sure they should be able to, but I assume they could disable Sign in with Apple for a given site if they wished.
- barkerja 6y agoThis applies to any SSO.
- kinkrtyavimoodh 6y agoThat ship sailed long ago. Apple basically has apps and app-developers by the balls, not to mention the 30% extortion money they try to get not just for app purchases but any transaction done within the app, so much as even banning an app from telling the user that they can do the transaction elsewhere. It makes my blood boil but from the discussions I see on HN about it, most people here seem to be more or less ok with it.
- scarface74 6y agoIt’s not any transaction. It’s any digital transaction. You can sell physical goods and services either without giving Apple any cut, or by using Apple Pay and Apple just gets your standard credit card processing fee. Does Walmart let you sell your product in their store and say you can look at it there but get it cheaper from Amazon?
- kinkrtyavimoodh 6y agoMy app is not the App Store. The user has already paid to download my app from the App Store and Apple has gotten 30% of the cut. What users do on my App after that is none of Apple's business, though of course Apple would like to claim otherwise. Similarly, once I have bought something from Walmart I can use it as I wish. Our business transaction ends there, so your analogy isn't really apt. > Does Walmart let you sell your product in their store and say you can look at it there but get it cheaper from Amazon? Funny you say that, because Walmart and many other brick-and-mortal retailers will happily price-match Amazon and each other. You know why? Because they are not a monopoly or pseudo-monopoly and so need to do good by their users to compete. Of course you can justify Apple's behavior any way because you can claim that I am on an iPhone so I am on their property or something and so they are my overlords but that is precisely what users here are trying to argue against. Or to be honest, you don't even need to justify it that way. The magical market justifies it because the fact that these apps are on the Apple ecosystem means that staying on it is better for them than staying off it. And no other justification is necessary. And you would not be wrong. But people have a moral intuition about these things based on how they see the world work, and so they have an intuitive sense for when something seems 'off', even if the market seems like it's working. That's why they complain against things like exorbitant pay-day loans despite them too being an example of a market that seems to be working. Last I checked, I did not get an iPhone on lease from Apple. This attitude where just because I am on an iPhone means I owe Apple in perpetuity needs to die.
- barkerja 6y agoThey don't, the user controls this. When the user authorizes the client, they have the option to share their actual Apple ID email or use an obfuscated one. Apple isn't forcing anything here.
- KeepFlying 6y agoI think it would come down to user hostility here. If I sign in with Apple and opt out of giving my email only to be faced with a prompt demanding I give up my email address, I'll be upset. I JUST told the app (via checking the box in Apple) that I don't want to give my mail, so why is it now suddenly required? However if the app allows me to sign in and only asks for my email when I try to interact with a feature that would be more usable had I given my email, then I would be more accepting of it. Though I would still fully expect to be able to use the app in its entirety even if I opt out. Now what Apple will say to this, I have no idea. But as a privacy conscious user, I would be happier with this. As for having to come up with silly names, I don't understand why I need to be discoverable within an app. We have established social media and communication platforms, use them. Let me send a link to a friend to connect with them in your random app. I don't need to be able to add them within the dang app.
- duxup 6y agoI think the problem is that once you want to be found, like for a grocery shopping app, most folks think you search and just find them and when it doesn't work....they don't know to go find some settings and figure it out.
- IggleSniggle 6y agoYeah but I dont want to be found. That's why I don't share my email. If I want to share with someone, I don't want the use that app to establish a link between us, because I don't want the app to know anything about us except what it must to do it's job. "Go find some setting and figure it out" is a UX fail. When I share eg a Dropbox link or a Google Photos link, you can get to it whether you have an established account or not. If there's something special about an app that requires an account before interaction is possible, then you can still make it a one-time share. Yes, it does make user support more complicated. Yes, that's what I want and expect. I hope when I come asking for help, you can't help me because you have no clue who I am and have no way to get in touch with me because I used some email obscuring service. That's on me.
- 6y ago