5 ms·
Somebody would open a competing grocery. Likewise, racist and bigots can build their own internet platform.
by alistairSH 6y ago
Somebody would open a competing grocery.
Likewise, racist and bigots can build their own internet platform.
- disposekinetics 6y agoCompetition seems to get shut down whenever this happens.
- searchableguy 6y agoThat's a confusing answer to what I said. I am not defending anyone in the post here but just yesterday, visa banned gab's CEO and his family. Now you need to build a payment processor which is not possible for any individual to do so. To how deep you want to go here? Put your own cables in the sea?
- sixstringtheory 6y agoI wrote out a long response and only then starting researching Gab. So instead of my own words, here are some excerpts from their terms of service. If you don't like the counterarguments you're encountering here, you should consider that Gab feels the same way: > if you don't like what we're doing on Gab.com or simply want to manage your own experience, you can spin up your own Gab Social server that you control > We have the right to disable any user name, password, or other identifier, whether chosen by you or provided by us, at any time if we believe you have violated any provision of these Terms of Service. > You agree not to use the Website... To engage in any other conduct which, as determined by us, may result in the physical harm or offline harassment of the Company, individual users of the Website or any other person (e.g. “doxing”), or expose them to liability > the Company reserves the right to take any action with respect to any User Contribution that we deem necessary or appropriate in our sole discretion > User Contributions must NOT...be obscene... And of course all the usual legalese like indemnification and arbitration. AFAICT, the only difference between Gab and Twitter is that Gab has orders of magnitude less users, and if they ever reached the usership levels of Twitter/Facebook/Reddit I have no doubt they would behave in ways they currently enjoy denouncing. I think they just want to have their cake and eat it, too. edit: grammar, again haha
- searchableguy 6y ago> If you don't like the counterarguments you're encountering here, you should consider that Gab feels the same way I am genuinely curious why you are trying to divert my initial point into a different direction here. I gave an example of gabe to illustrate that there needs to be some hard point for private companies to be responsible or adhere strictly to the legality or public. Visa isn't a small private business that is refusing to work with you. They are a global monopoly. If your argument is there are more competitors, it doesn't matter if they all collude with each like master card does with visa to keep competitors off or does something to restrict people.
- sixstringtheory 6y agoI don't mean to divert. Allow me to try to summarize: You: Gab can't use Visa (A) for reasons, it's not reasonable to suggest that (B) a competitor be built Gab: we can kick you off (A') for reasons, you can always spin up a Gab instance to run yourself (B') What is the difference between A and A', and B and B'?
- searchableguy 6y agoI already explained that. Building an alternative to gab isn't hard. Building alternatives to visa is a bar beyond average people or group of them. I can spin up an instance of mastodon within few minutes. I can't do the same for visa. I can't do the same for google cloud, cloudflare or any of the other monoliths. This isn't applicable to all the situations but it is one of the factor differentiating gab from visa. Another is the reach. If gab has the same number of users as youtube, then they should have something to let the public have a choice in what happens on the platform. I don't know where to define the user scale though. it's a hard problem. At 1 billion? Maybe when 90% of the country uses it?
- s1artibartfast 6y agonot the same poster, but I think the point they were making had to do with the criticality of services and availability of alternatives? Should the only grocery store in a town be able to refuse service to an individual that they don't like? It is unlikely a single individual is in a position to open a grocery store that can economically compete with the super-wall-mart. How about a gas station in the middle of a desert where refusing service might literally result in death?
- s1artibartfast 6y agoWhat if the grocery store policy was no alistairSH, for their HN post history. Are you prepared to compete with the wall-mart superstore?